Playlist: To Be An Emotionally Intense ’90s Woman

I’d always heard that women were crazy, and that we’re super difficult to deal with, let alone figure out. We’re like ticking time bombs of inexplicable and confusing insanity! Everyone else (men) are chill and reasonable, and we’re all fucking nuts — and if we’re not crazy, it’s only a matter of time before we’ll be crazy. I didn’t know much at 10 or 11 years old, but that stereotype had definitely been ingrained. Perhaps you can relate? So when I started feeling Every Available Feeling a few years later, I just chalked it up to being a crazy girlperson — someone’s future crazy ex-girlfriend, or future complicated mess in some way or another. And I was ok with that, actually, because being complicated and tiptoed around (lest I DETONATE!) was pretty satisfying at the time, even if I didn’t feel interesting enough to be complicated.

For those times when I was really seizing my Womanly Psychosis (“feelings”), I would find sisterhood and solidarity in the female musicians of our time (“the ’90s”). I’m realizing now that, taken out of context, some of these lyrics are terrifying. Many of them give me the warm feeling of “thank goodness I’m not dating the singer of this song,” followed by “wait, I’ve been a version of the singer of this song. Hm.” This is the soundtrack to a decade’s worth of processing and embracing emotional intensity.

To Be* An Emotionally Intense ’90s Woman

[*or to be in a relationship with / to break-up with]

90s woman ok2


You Oughta Know – Alanis Morissette
Bitch – Meredith Brooks
Jealousy – Liz Phair
You Were Meant For Me – Jewel
Silent All These Years – Tori Amos
I Want To Come Over – Melissa Etheridge
Do You Love Me Now? – The Breeders
Nothing Compares 2 U – Sinead O’Conner
Stay – Lisa Loeb
Don’t Speak – No Doubt
Untouchable Face – Ani Difranco
Take A Bow – Madonna
Fade Into You – Mazzy Star
Sleep To Dream – Fiona Apple
Only Happy When It Rains – Garbage
Rid Of Me – PJ Harvey
I’m The Only One – Melissa Etheridge
Jealousy – Natalie Merchant
Adia – Sarah McLachlan
I Will Always Love You – Whitney Houston
#1 Crush – Garbage
Violently Happy – Bjork
Who Is He And What Is He To You – Me’Shell Ndegeocello
Angry Johnny – Poe
Ex-Factor – Lauryn Hill

What did I leave out? Let’s light some candles and talk about it.

Want to suggest a playlist theme? Hit Crystal up on Formspring and someone from the team will make it for you, if you’re lucky.

Autostraddle cannot exist without the generous support of our readers. We're running the fundraiser through March 29th! We're out of immediate danger...but we had to ask...what if we could survive for longer? Will you help?

Go to our Fundraiser!


Laneia is the Director of Operations and founding member of Autostraddle, and you're the reason she's here.

Laneia has written 930 articles for us.


  1. I love this playlist (my Pandora often resembles it!), and your intro. But I am having “feelings” about the omission of one kd lang. Anything from Ingenue (1992): Constant Craving, Mind of Love, Miss Chatelaine, Outside Myself, Save Me.

  2. I am SO INTO this playlist. Bonus points for including Poe!

    Basically every song from the Paranoid and Sunburnt album by Skunk Anansie, but especially “Intellectualize My Blackness” and “100 Ways to Be a Good Girl.”

    Also, “Hold On” by Sarah McLachlan, not “Adia.”

  3. one time my family drove to new hampshire and i spent the entire trip in the back seat staring out the window playing “Just a Girl” over and over on my walkman and singing along, with much feeling.
    after about 7 times my dad finally asked me to stop and i moped, VISIBLY, for the rest of the trip
    i don’t recall how old I actually was, but I still fondly consider this my First Day Of Being A Teenager

    • OMGGGGG.

      She was the most intense! For the uninitiated, Diamanda Galas performed what would become her best-known work (masterpiece) naked from the waist up, covered in sheeps blood, in an abandoned Catholic church. Themes were the complicity of Church and State in perpetuating the stigma of HIV/AIDS and responding with fear and homophobia, rather than compassion and, well, research funding.

      Also, the dignity denied to AIDS victims in their deaths.

      Also, she quotes the Bible and old spirituals.

      Also, it’s called the Plague Mass.

      MOST INTENSE. I would encourage ‘straddlers to look this shit up, but be warned: this is the only music that has ever actually scared me.

  4. this is perfect.

    Also, I may have listened to too much Liz Phair in high school. I am not sorry for this.

    Whenever I happen to hear “Untouchable Face,” I can’t help but cringe a bit when thinking of my high school self. That one I am a bit sorry for.

  5. How about some Paula Cole? She was another ‘must play’ for any emotionally intense 90s girl — ‘Where Have All The Cowboys Gone?’ if you’re feeling a little bitter, or ‘I Don’t Wanna Wait’ for a more upbeat emotion (or to relive all those Dawson’s Creek memories). Aaaaah!

    Sheryl Crow is another omission – I’d go for “Every Day Is A Winding Road” for its great bongos.

      • y’all it’s not a snub! that song doesn’t belong here bc it doesn’t fit the theme! “what’s up” is about your feelings about the whole world and yourself and your place in it and such. this playlist is about your feelings about a specific person (or maybe a couple of people I SEE YOU POLYS), which is a very different kind of feeling.

        but i will concede that i should’ve added the other sarah mclachlan song, the natalie imbruglia one, and i didn’t listen to skunk anasie so maybe that one too. and ok, probably hyperballad, but it’s just a touch too happy for too long to really fit this theme.

        i take my playlisting seriously! PURIST.

        • Have you listened to the Brodsky Quartet version of Hyperballad? Because it gets INTENSE. Like, I can’t really listen to it without feeling all the feelings and my eyes welling up. And then also sort of feeling like I just had an orgasm in my ears and heart. TMI FTW.

  6. My parents banned me from listening to anything but Christian music for most of my youth, so I missed all of the 90s ladyangst. I’ve been trying to catch up by building a similar playlist of my own, so thanks for this – more material I can add to it!

    One that strikes me as missing is Bif Naked, but maybe she wasn’t a hit across the border? The album Splendora did, in additional to their music for Daria, is pretty good feelings material also.

  7. This is everything I could have ever wanted.

    Also – am I the only one that thinks the song titles themselves can be remixed into a pretty good 90s song?

    You Oughta Know, Number One Crush
    Nothing Compares to you..
    I want to come over
    and Fade Into You.

    Who is he and what is he to you?
    Angry Johnny?
    the Ex-Factor?
    Jealousy – Don’t speak – I will always love you.

    I’m the only one, only happy when it rains.
    Take a Bow, rid of me,
    Violently happy, my untouchable face.

    Do you love me now?
    Do you love me now?
    Do you love me now…

    I want to see other attempts.

    • I made a heartbreak-themed Heartthrob quote mashup along the same lines when the album came out. “Go if you want! I can’t stop you; what you are is lonely. They say, “love heals all wounds. Love removes the hurt in you”, and I have nothing to hold you down: How come you don’t want me now? I stuck around. I was a fool for love. Sometimes it feels that the side that I’m on holds the toughest hand. The longest stand.”

  8. This list is fantastic and gives me all the angsty 90s/coming out feels (because my first two girlfriends were total 90s chicks.)

    My fav emotional 90s song is “Precious Things” by Tori Amos. Still play it on repeat on angsty days, especially when I’m all flustered about my religious past.

  9. oh my god Laneia get out of my head. I just yesterday created a playlist entitled “90’s insanity”.

    Everything on your list is amazing. The only thing I could add would be: Natalie Imbruglia – Torn.

    She was lying naked on the floor, cold and shamed. I mean really.

  10. I was but a child in the 90’s…but my first taste of 90’s female emotional intesity was I think..

    The Cranberries – Zombie. Was very powerful to me when I first heard it (not sure if it quite fits the playlist) but they have a lot of other songs that could fit the bill, I guess in terms of well known Cranberries songs:

    Ode to my family
    Miss you when you’re gone

    Oh, and one song that did spring instantly to mind

    Kiss the rain by Billie Myers.

    • Yes The Cranberries! I grew up on them. My parents were playing one of their cd’s when I was about 8, and I remember asking why it sounded like they were yelling. My mom just said “you’ll understand when you’re older.” Then when I was 10 my Alanis Morisette obsession kicked in, and it all made sense.

      I was just thinking today about my old 90s music. I played Jagged Little Pill, the Buffy Soundtrack, and Precious Little by Eleanor McEvoy about a million times. Everything about this playlist is wonderful.

  11. Yes yes YES!!!!!! This posts sums up my teenage years. Sarah McLachlan started it all when I happened to hear “Possession” in that one due South episode and she was my gateway drug to these other emotionally intense women. Much time was spent listening to these songs contemplating my feelings and life and just generally getting lost in the utter intensity of it all. So many deep feelings ;)

    Thank you sooooo much for this post, totally made my day :)

  12. I am so excited about this post!! I was just a little kid in the 90’s but when I became an angst adolescent I became totally hooked on 90’s women musicians, and it totally changed the way I approached my life and music and I’m so excited I made a run on sentence. Fiona Apple is my hero, I have a lyric from her tattooed on me, and I cried when I saw her in concert last summer. I remember realizing when I first started listening to these women that it was okay to be angry and to have feelings and to actually express them. Soooo good!

  13. Friends, please stay with me here; I’m going to nominate “Hyperballad” as a more suitable Bjork song for this list. So feelings-y! Or, of course, Possibly Maybe.

    But it’s hard to improve on perfection, though, so… these are just list “alternatives,” perhaps.

  14. I’m pretty sure this is verbatim the exact mixtape I made over my first baby-dyke broken heart. Complete with hand decorated cover, sent via snail mail. There should definitely be some Cranberries, Natalie Imbruglia, and Indigo Girls added to this list.

  15. This playlist plus the Sassy junk food panel tasting issue would reduce me to a puddle of blissful gratitude. Don’t have that issue any more so I’m still in solid form, but whooee: Happy.

Contribute to the conversation...

Yay! You've decided to leave a comment. That's fantastic. Please keep in mind that comments are moderated by the guidelines laid out in our comment policy. Let's have a personal and meaningful conversation and thanks for stopping by!