Hello this is Tinkerbell. This weekend I posted an article on Autostraddle.com regarding the impending apocalypse, as foretold by a newspaper article entitled “The Rise of the Biebians.”
For the beginning I would say that “the apocalypse” is hyperbole, just like the title “The Rise of the Biebians,” which gave me flashbacks to a) the bible, 2) With God on Our Side: George W. Bush and the Rise of the Religious Right in America, Rise of the Gargoyles, Hitler: The Rise of Evil, Mongol: The Rise of Genghis Khan and Terminator 3: Rise of the Machines.
Because I am a dog with limited wordspan and also because Strunk & White says “eliminate needless words,” my post was short. It was a direct response to the way an article had characterized a generation of teenaged lesbians. But I forgot that this is the internet, where people read headlines and then angrytypetype at their computers before considering that maybe I love you.
Hello teenaged lesbians of the world. If you are here, I already love you and believe in you. As just a stuffed dog I find myself in awe of your style and movement, as well as your words and tumblrs.
That is why I am sad to read statements published in mainstream media which reflect apathy at the exclusion of all other feelings, such as:
“…maybe this phenomenon could be indicative of a more apoliticized generation of lesbians who aren’t looking for a dose of politics with their music. ‘After being so hyper-obsessed with political figures like Ani Difranco, maybe the queer community just wants to enjoy themselves with someone like Justin Bieber who doesn’t stand for anything,’ Lichtman says.”
I do not think that is how you think, lesbians of the world. I think you have nice hair AND care about things. It is our duty as human beings and stuffed animals in the media to challenge apathy, even if we ourselves are not always Ani DiFranco. For many eons people have taken gay words out of context and made them into sensational trend pieces!
Furthermore, lesbians who did not like my stance against apathy, do know that Autostraddle has a significant history of ‘lighthearted’ Justin Bieber support. Intern Hot Laura, the best-looking member of the Autostraddle family, team picked “Lesbians Who Look Like Justin Bieber” on March 5th, 2010, four days post-launch, which makes her the first human on the internet to spot Justin Bieber [that I know of]. Intern Hot Laura said:
I spent a long time trying to figure out why it’s taken me so long to find this tumblr, but then I looked through the archives and realized that it’s only existed for 4 days. Help them out guys, submit pictures so I have cute things to look at!
In Autostraddle’s 2009 Music Year in Review, we gave Justin Bieber the “Little Boy You Wouldn’t Mind Having as Your Girlfriend” award:
JBiebs, could you get any dreamier if you tried? You’ve got shinny shiny hair, you can sing, you’re young enough to have that whole androgyny thing working for you, you dress nicely, you dance, and Ellen loves you. So maybe you secretly sing along to his songs in your car. Maybe you shamelessly make all your friends dance to him before you go out. Or maybe you’ve heard his name and cringed at the thought of a 15-year-old singing about love. But really, give him 5 minutes; I dare you not to like him. Boy’s got pipes! (And please note how gigantically cute the guitar looks on him.)
Autostraddle has encouraged you to watch Bieber’s Rolling Stone behind-the-scenes video and his video with Sean Kingston and to watch him on QVC and watch a video of him flirting with Chelsea Handler (“which I’ve watched on repeat this morning because they’re shining, adorable beacons of light.”). We did an “I’ll have what she’s wearing” about Leah, a magazine journalism student who “just wants to get her Justin [Bieber] on” and says, “I wouldn’t say I aspire to look like him, but I’d say that Justin Bieber aspires to look like me. ‘Cause I was born first.”
I have looked at our team page and counted 15 team members with Justin Bieber haircuts.
Lesbians of the world I would like to look you in the eye and punch you in the mouth. What is so confusing. We can be critical of the way we are represented in the media or how a fun trend and cool website is parlayed to the mainstream as an apolitical movement, especially when it is linked to an apolitical pop star. I will change my tune 800% when Justin Bieber stands up for the equal rights of the lesbian fans who support him, just as the ladies iconicized by gay men participate in political and social actions to further the equal rights of their fans. (For example: Kathy Griffin, Bette Midler, Cher, Madonna, Bea Arthur, Liza Minelli, Janet Jackson, Lady Gaga and Cyndi Lauper.)
Autostraddle’s Intern Hot Laura loves Justin Bieber, and also hates DADT. I assume you are the same. (If you are not, please do not tell me because ignorance is bliss). Life requires french fries but also apples. That is how life is for people with teeth.
Today Riese read out loud to me an article from bitch! magazine, which is a magazine by angry radical lesbizi commies (like Riese) about how pop culture is good/bad for feminists. The article explains the Bieber phenomenon in words we both like and ideas we agree with. “This is good,” said Riese, “It is not on the heteros to accept us like in the other article where we made them our idols. It is on us to accept the hets and recontextualize their idols for our own purposes and that is what’s really happening with Justin Bieber. Also, you should subscribe to bitch magazine.”
So please read Top of the Pops: Justin Bieber’s a lesbian hair icon–or is it the other way around?
For many lesbians these days, that binary is as outdated and useless as a pair of TV antennae, comfortable as so many of us are with the protean mature of sexuality and gender… those spaces between girl/not girl, boy/not boy, growing up/not growing up are where we queers belong, and here’s why: they’re not cramped crevices into which we are shoved, but rather spaces we have carved out for ourselves. Justin Bieber is just the normalized version of that existence. And, like Bieber’s now-famous hair, this generation’s crop of queers really knows where it wants to go.
As my final point I would like to say that what gave me the saddest feelings about The National Post article was to read that Justin Bieber was noted as a solution to the problem that “there are few young lesbian icons, especially masculine ones, for queer girls to look up to.”
I felt sad-faced and defensive because of all the young masculine lesbians who you could look up to, but cannot, because the media is saturated with images of Miley Cyrus instead. I am not an elitist bastard, although I am a bastard except that I am a girl, and also a dog. You think as a dog I like to read poetry or study books? No I like to watch reality shows about hairdressers and read large-type versions of The It Girls. I am not here to judge you. I am here with you. Riese had a Leonardo DiCaprio shrine in her teenaged bedroom.
Justin Bieber does not solve the problem of not having a young masculine lesbian to look up to. He is a good guy I am sure, but he’s not a lesbian. I want to rally behind the icons we do have, instead of claiming there are none. Here’s a starter list: Tegan & Sara, Hunter Valentine, Jess & Mary B, Deak Evgenikos, Dani Campbell, Daniela Sea, Samantha Ronson, Sarah Croce/Miss April, Hannah Blilie, Michele Cluney, Jiz Lee, Chris Pureka, Michele Fleury, Kim Stolz, Nicole Pina, Mélange Lavonne, Angie Evans, DJ Saratonin, Kate Moennig, that cute girl Amy from Anyone But Me, DJ Carlytron, Misty Odell, Ellis, Ty Greenstein, Blair Hansen, Heather Cassils, Stef Mitchell or Laura/Miss August.
Lesbians are invisible in mainstream pop culture which is hard when you are a teenager who wants to fit in and read the articles in Tiger Beat. I am not confused about that. But I do think you all should rise against the machine, love Justin Bieber if that’s what you want to do, but know that it’s not getting us any closer (or any farther away, really) from having actual lesbian icons out there to look up to.
I have an idea/solution: In addition to Justin Bieber (if you so desire), you should look up to actual lesbians doing actual things. Like Dannielle Owens-Reid, the 24-year-old girl who spotted the trend and leaped on it, and then parlayed that tumblr’s success into a site of her own, everyoneisgay.com, where she and her friend Kristin give advice to young lesbians in need of advice which let’s be honest, is maybe all young lesbians (you are all crazy!):
In conclusion: it’s the lesbians who look like Justin Bieber and aren’t afraid to have their pictures online and say so that are the real queer heroes here. It’s the 14-year-old girl who was willing to be quoted in a national newspaper, even though I think she should give Ani DiFranco a chance because of her perfect “fuck you/breakup” lyrics.
And if you disagree with me about that, well then just shoot me in the face.
i love you too, tinkerbell!
I will not shoot you in the face, Tinkerbell. I love you, and your hyperbole, and this post.
Look, you can’t shoot puppies in the face. Someone did that to one in SF last week and it was BAD NEWS BEARS, okay?
I’m just saying, more dykes should be their own Cool Hand Lukes. We could use more of those. Also more Kate Bornsteins and Dylan Ryans and Ivan Coyotes. Yesyesyes.
More Dylan Ryans and Ivan Coyotes would make the world a far more amazing place to a lot of high-schoolers.
Tinkerbell, I am honored to be included in your list of icons. i am sorry that i told Riese to get you away from me the first time we met. Robin and I saw a bunch of you for sale at a weird pet accessories store in provincetown so i’d say you are an icon too!
I’m going to have to second DJ Carlytron’s gratitude for being selected as an icon. Thank you so much Tinkerbell, I promise to work as hard as I can to be the woman you see me as and not the Whitney everyone mistakes me for.
I want to email this to my mom and be like, “See?! Tinkerbell says I am an actual lesbian doing actual things.” Thanks twentyfold for the kudos.
Dannielle Owens-Reid is amazing.
You light up my life.
I went to read this and had to immediately comment before even reading it because the ad at the top of the page is Proactiv with Justin Bieber.
you are adorable and sweethearted and made out of some kind of material, i don’t know what. In my head I assume it’s soft and fluffy.
I like your writing.
I love you and all your Bieban loving/Bieber-as-an-icon hating ways.
Stay cool, don’t ever change.
I think that no one takes Justin Beiber seriously, and there is something really fun about not taking yourself seriously. There probably isn’t more to it than that.
Oh tinkerbell, thank you for using me as the example of lesbians at Autostraddle who love Justin Beiber but also care about things. Perhaps this is because I am the only person at Autostraddle who like Justin Beiber. I think it’s a little weird that he’s a “lesbian icon” because there were so many other little boy pop stars that came before him that didn’t get nearly as much attention. Jesse McCartney, Zac Efron, I’m looking at you.
Don’t sweat it. Haters gonna hate.
Whilst chillin in the Windsor Terrace area recently, I was inspired to play the awesome game “German or Lesbian.” About 5 minutes in, we spotted a real German lesbian who looked like Justin Bieber. She won the game.
“Life requires french fries but also apples. That is how life is for people with teeth.”
I enjoyed that quote very much, Tinkerbell. I feel I may be missing something… such as a reference to a book I would definitely read, or the like. But, even my smartiness-related insecurity wasn’t able to keep me from enjoying this post and, especially, that quote.
I shoot you in the face with jollybullets made of my appreciation…or something.
Tinkerbell, you’re my favorite puppy, and I’m a girl who likes puppies.
I don’t like Justin Bieber or Ani Difranco. So there. And I think those haircuts look stupid on everyone.
my hair is cut in the style of ramona quimby. do you like that
Riese and I have that Leonardo Dicaprio Shrine-thing in common.
Also, Tinkerbell is so my icon.
Riese takes her wig off when she’s drunk.
we have that in common too ;)
Ummm…I don’t really think any of those other boy pop stars or actors had any sort of personality.Zac Efron or the Jonas bros? I can’t recall them saying or doing anything nearly as interesting as Bieber on Chelsea Handler or him playing drums with Jimmy Fallon’s band,and he does similar stuff all the time.I don’t know really if he can sing but,he’s got a big personality to go along with that haircut and that I think is where the attraction is.
Dannielle Owens-Reid is absoluely an icon. And gorgeous, too.