The Ones Who Got Away: Two Men Who Left Their Churches On Behalf of the Gays

This weekend, announcements came about that Brian Ellison, a pastor in Kansas, and Colonel Timothy Wagoner, a military chaplain, were leaving behind their positions at religious institutions that bound them to silence about homosexuality and, in many ways, an inability to support queer people at all.

Brian Ellison announced to his parish that he was gay in June, sending letters to the congregation to announce that he would be leaving them to begin at the Covenant Network of Presbyterians, a group devoted to LGBT inclusion in the denomination, as Executive Director. He sent letters in an effort to be transparent and honest. He sent letters to announce he was in a relationship with a man he loved, and had been for nine years. And he said goodbye because despite having spent 13 years with his parish, and despite having been there straight out of seminary, he could no longer go without talking about his own life and his own happiness. His last day was July 15, and he begins at the Convenant Network on August 1.

brian ellison via the kansas city star

Ellison called the letter “the end of a long period of discernment.” He added, “by the time I got to this, I was so clearly doing the right thing, there wasn’t any question left in my mind.” He began at Parkville, his parish, in 1999. In 2003, he began dating Troy Lillebo, who moved to Kansas City one year later. They began living together in 2005.

“I worried a lot about being caught,” Ellison said, noting that what he feared for most was hurting the church. “Once I accepted that this is actually who I am,” Ellison said, “then I had to move on to making that choice of what that would mean for my continuing self.”

For Wagoner, however, the political was slightly less personal. A military chaplain and member of the Southern Baptist Convention, Wagoner was caught in between the repeal of Don’t Ask Don’t Tell and his church’s beliefs regarding same-sex marriage. Although Wagoner refused to officiate same-sex ceremonies because of the regulations of the SBC, he attended a New Jersey ceremony on his base bringing Sargeant Erwynn Umali and his partner Will Behrens together in holy gay matrimony following DADT’s repeal. “I wouldn’t miss it,” he said. He described the ceremony as “beautiful.” But his conservative denomination didn’t agree, and questioned his decision to attend. A week after the AP ran  a story about Wagoner’s attendance at the ceremony, the Southern Baptist Church’s official news service “ran an article conveying the message that South Baptist military chaplains do not support same-sex civil unions or marriages.”

“My intention,” Wagoner told the SBC, “was never to embarrass or misrepresent the Southern Baptists, whom I have faithfully served for 30 years as a pastor and military chaplain.” His intention was merely to support the men on his base. But on July 20, Wagoner would officially announce his departure from the convention. He is now a member of the Cooperative Baptist Convention, which is more moderate on LGBT issues. Professor David Key, director of Baptist Studies at Emory University, thinks his resignation will be the first of many.

For Ellison, his decision to begin on a new path toward a different solution for his church came with good responses from his parish. This kind of ending suits a man who doesn’t necessarily identify as an advocate but has already made waves about where LGBT people stand in his church. “I think the church doesn’t have to see the inclusion of LGBT people as a radical alternative idea,” Ellison said. “I see it as the church doing what its always done, which is proclaiming the good news of Jesus Christ and God’s love for everybody.”

Alternatively, Wagoner’s departure from the SBC was less amicable, who questioned his decision to attend the marriage and frustrated him so deeply. On Friday, he emailed the Associated Press, saying, “I find very little that is more important and nothing that is more exhilarating than providing for the religious freedoms and spiritual care of all service members and their families — and will joyfully continue to do so.”

For both men, the decision to leave was difficult and not all their own. Ellison and Wagoner had options: conform and stay silent, speak out from within the system, or apologize for their own lives and beliefs. But those choices do not do enough. Ellison and Wagoner’s departures show their own communities, and their churches, that homophobia cannot be ingrained into our religious patterns anymore. That anti-gay churches are being proven wrong even by those who most deeply believe in them, even by those who lead them. The Presbyterian and Southern Baptist churches have lost two great men, but the fault is their own. Isolation and alienation and hate drive away valuable contributors and important voices, and sometimes even the ones we love.


Before you go! It costs money to make indie queer media, and frankly, we need more members to survive 2023As thanks for LITERALLY keeping us alive, A+ members get access to bonus content, extra Saturday puzzles, and more! Will you join? Cancel anytime.

Join A+!

Carmen

Carmen spent six years at Autostraddle, ultimately serving as Straddleverse Director, Feminism Editor and Social Media Co-Director. She is now the Consulting Digital Editor at Ms. and writes regularly for DAME, the Women’s Media Center, the National Women’s History Museum and other prominent feminist platforms; her work has also been published in print and online by outlets like BuzzFeed, Bitch, Bust, CityLab, ElixHER, Feministing, Feminist Formations, GirlBoss, GrokNation, MEL, Mic and SIGNS, and she is a co-founder of Argot Magazine. You can find Carmen on Twitter, Instagram and Tumblr or in the drive-thru line at the nearest In-N-Out.

Carmen has written 920 articles for us.

4 Comments

  1. I was really impressed with Brian Ellison when he presented the MRTI report at General Assembly this year. It was a complex and difficult debate, and he managed it with a lot of poise. I really look forward to his leadership of Covenant Network.
    I would hesitate to say that he left the church on behalf of the gays. Rather, he is moving onto his next step in ministry. He’s not serving a church, but he’s still a pastor in the PC(USA). He has not, in any way, left the Presbyterian church, he has left Parkville.

    It is really sad that pastors like Wagoner have to choose between faithfulness to their gay parishioners and faithfulness to their denominational leadership.

  2. This article made me reflect on my own life. My dad left his church on behalf of the gays. He was a member of a congregation that was more conservative than he knew, and when the conversation turned hateful and ignorant, he left. This was particularly striking to me because he had connected with religion after a 50+ year search for spirituality with this church and had been attending for 4 years, and he was feeling really connected to his church. And also, I wasn’t even identifying as queer then. He just did it because it deeply disturbed him morally. Way to go Dad!! I am a lucky gay.

    “Never doubt that a small group of thoughtful, committed, citizens can change the world. Indeed, it is the only thing that ever has.”
    ― Margaret Mead

    That’s what these men are doing.

  3. Aww! Exciting to see someone local getting some Autostraddle love :) And actually, Ellison is/was a pastor in Missouri, not Kansas. Kansas City is mostly in Missouri, and slightly in Kansas :) I live near Parkville and I’m hoping to move there this winter. It’s too bad he’s no longer a pastor there.

  4. True fact: Freedom of individual conscience started out as one of the key distinguishing characteristics of the Baptists. Policing the denomination to enforce doctrine used to be the exact opposite of what they stood for. Really, Col. Wagoner hasn’t moved; it’s the Southern Baptist Convention that has left the Baptists.

    (Separation of church and state was another tenet! Since 150 years before the First Amendment! Not joking!)

Contribute to the conversation...

Yay! You've decided to leave a comment. That's fantastic. Please keep in mind that comments are moderated by the guidelines laid out in our comment policy. Let's have a personal and meaningful conversation and thanks for stopping by!