“Anne With an E” Is Even Gayer in Season Two (but It’s Still Not “Anne of Green Gables”)

Major spoilers below for Anne With an E season two. 

I really hated the first season of Anne With an E, which I wrote about in scathing detail on this very website. The short version of my loathing is: The remake hammers the soul and spirt out of Lucy Maud Montgomery’s beloved town and beloved characters, and mangles their tried and true storylines in the name of grit and edginess. There is, however, canonical gayness in Netflix’s reboot, and even more in season two, which landed last week. I like canonical gayness. I especially like it in a story that’s been read for a century as queer by lots of queer people. I didn’t like that it was expressed at the expense of feminist icon and probable also gay lady Marilla Cuthbert in season one — but that’s enough complaining out of me.

#BosomBuddies

Last season Diana explained lesbianism to Anne and it looked like this:

Diana: [My aunt Josephine] is disinclined to stay at home since her companion died.
Anne: Her companion?
Diana: Her best friend forever and ever. Aunt Josephine never married. Neither of them did. They lived with each other their whole lives.
Anne: I’d live with you forever if I could, but I know you’ll leave me the day you get married to some wealthy and handsome gentleman. I hate him already.

Turns out Diana didn’t actually didn’t know Aunt Josephine and Aunt Gertrude were lesbians, despite the fact that they shared a home and a bed and everyone calls Josephine “Jo,” which, as you know, is the shortest short-hand way to call a person “gay.” Aunt Jo invites Anne and Diana to her house for a party in season two’s “Memory Has as Many Mood as the Temper” and things go from slightly canonically queer to heckin’ queer. Right out of the gate, Jo reveals to Anne that she and Gertie were, “in their way, married.” In fact, Gertie’s books are still on her bedside table, just how she left them. Anne picks up Jane Eyre and Jo asks her to take over Gertie’s tradition of reading a passage from a favorite book at the party.

Alternative lifestyle haircut! Nice!

Anne worries that she’s not going to fit in, because she’s not like everyone else. “Then you’ve come to the correct party,” Aunt Jo assures her. And it’s true! It’s a very queer party full of very eccentric people, including men wearing makeup and women wearing tuxes and a lot of artists. Anne even bumps into another girl with a pixie haircut who declares to Anne, “Love your pixie haircut!”

Toward the end of the evening, Aunt Jo stands up to give a toast, and really it’s a love letter to Gertie. When she’s finished speaking so beautifully about their love, one of their be-tuxed women friends hold her glass of champagne high and says, “To Gertrude, to the most wonderful couple, to my romantic ideal!” And everyone toasts, “To Gertie and Jo!”

And, look, I cried.

To Anne, this deceleration is no big deal, having cracked the lesbian code the second she walked into Jo’s house — where, I should also add, there are at least two sculptures of naked women canoodling. To Diana, it’s a shock that sends her reeling for several episodes. They can’t be, it’s unnatural, etc. To their friend Cole who tagged along, it’s a miracle. He’s gay too. He’s felt out of place his whole life. Meeting Aunt Josephine, hearing about Gertrude, it changes the shape of his world. (Oh he’s obviously also an artist.) He tells Anne about his revelation with just a shy smile, which she reciprocates. He tells Aunt Josephine with his mouth, right out loud. And she promises him a life of bumps and bruises, but of so much fulfillment and love.

Just be careful getting invested in Ryan Murphy shows, honey. It’s not all season one Kurt Hummel.

And, look, I cried again.

There’s one other slightly gay thing I should mention about season two and it’s Miss Stacy. Here she is arriving into Avonlea on a motorized bicycle that runs the Cuthbert’s horse off the road. She wears pants.

Uh-huh, honey.

Diana finally shakes off her shock about Jo and Gertie and gets over it, Cole ends up moving in with Aunt Jo, and Anne goes out into the world to preach the gay gospel, telling Marilla and Matthew on a picnic at the beach: “Love doesn’t look the same for everyone. It can come in so many forms. How can there be anything wrong with spending your life with the person you love?”

How indeed!

Anne With an E continues to use characters shoehorned in from 2018 to explain race and gender and sexuality to people on Prince Edward Island in 1908 as a way of explaining those things to people watching television on the internet in 2018. It’s clunky and weird and sometimes embarrassing. The dialogue sometimes feels like it was written in an alien language and run through Google Translator. The drama is so overwrought it’s ridiculous. The characters remain unrecognizable. But give me some elderly lesbians in love their whole lives, mentoring a couple of queer kids, and I’m gonna cry like a little baby-gay baby (which I, like Anne Shirley, will always be in my heart).

Before you go! 99.9% of our readers don't support Autostraddle. Still, it takes funding to keep this indie queer publication running every day. And the majority of our funding comes from readers like you. That's less than 1% of our readers who keep Autostraddle around for EVERYBODY. Will you join them?

Heather Hogan is an Autostraddle senior editor who lives in New York City with her wife, Stacy, and their cackle of rescued pets. She's a member of the Television Critics Association, the Gay and Lesbian Entertainment Critics Association, and a Rotten Tomatoes Tomatometer critic. You can also find her on Twitter, and Instagram.

Heather has written 1222 articles for us.

11 Comments

  1. Thanks for this! When I saw the new season was up I almost decided to try again, but this helped me remember how…traumatic it was trying to watch the first few episodes of Season 1. This does make me want to look through my parents’ VHS collection for the Megan Followes version they recorded for me from PBS :-)

  2. I don’t mind the changes so much. I’m comfortable with them living in my head as separate entities: the books, the definitive on screen version, and the vaguely Anne-like version we have now that while it does have its awkwardness and melodrama (well, that’s always been there in some form) reminds me that gay and women’s rights weren’t invented in modern times. Queers and women and queer women have managed to carve out space for themselves and their “family” wherever they are (to varying degrees).

  3. I never watched the series, but did for this episode. After about 5 min. in it was like a slightly cringeworthy AU fan fiction crossover of Glee and Queer as Folk, set in the 1900s.

    It’s also not very believable that Anne immediately gets that they were in love. At the time, most gay people could barely identify their own emotions, it often took them years because the whole concept of homosexuality was unthinkable.

    Also that “metaphor” of the bird cage head dress.

    Otherwise, the actress playing Jo was pretty great, and the flower decoration astonishingly accurate.

  4. I just got caught up on all of the episodes, and I really connected with this series. I didn’t really have anything to compare it to, because I never read the books (I get the feeling that my parents were already worried about me being too bold, imaginative, and sapphic). As a fellow survivor of childhood trauma, I saw a lot of myself in Anne from the episodes of post-traumatic stress to the way that she experiences transcendent joy. I have dedicated a good portion of my summer to processing and going to therapy, and it has been so healing to engage with a character who hasn’t been “broken” by her experiences and retains a sense of empathy and wonder. I know that this version of Anne is not the Anne that most people fell in love with, but this version of Anne was just what I needed at this point in my recovery. PS: Hooray for the friendship between baby bi Anne and baby gay Cole! Hooray for Marilla’s character development in season 2!

  5. I’ve never read Anne of green gables; I quite like this series, although there are probably too many things,too many prejudices and wrongs which Anne sets out to set right. They could have just chosen a couple. The list is a bit too long: women’s rights, gays’ rights, racism (against two ethnicities) am I forgetting anything? But what can I do, I liked it.

  6. I actually read every book that the author ever wrote.

    Anne shirley no doubt was an activist. So i can be flexible acting as such in the new series

    But i think we are looking for the gay content when it simply doesn’t exist in the original source material.

    And sure im cool with changing some things. Like the inclusion of lgbtq? Characters.

    But it’s wrong to then stereotype them..

    Like quiet,artistic boy equates gay…
    Women who ride a motorcycle,wear pants,have a pixie hair do ( which anne shirley would never get)..
    Etc equates lesbians.

    It’ what i call hollywoods’ overt stereotype of what lgtbq?
    Are.

    Then to imply anyone that is a whimsical dreamer like anne must be lgbtq is just wrong.

    Anne didnt want to be with diana berry( her whole life) because shes a lesbian.
    Anne hates change and doesn’t want to grow up.
    Anne knows one day their friendship will end.

    Like one reviewer said its like they tried to ham fist “glee” into 1900 p.e island canada.

  7. This show was the epitome of cringe. I’ve been an Anne fan since I first read the books when I was 8, and this series is one of the most disappointing adaptations of *anything* that I have ever seen. It seems to think its audience is so stupid that they have to be clubbed over the head with the writer’s message like a metaphorical brick. Subtlety and nuance need not apply, apparently.

    It also tried much too hard to have its cake and eat it, too; on the one hand, it wanted to embrace “realism” (which translated to “grim melodrama”), but on the other, it struggled to shoehorn in things like Miss Stacy and her trousers, which would mostly likely have gotten her arrested on obscenity charges in the real world. It tried to pull itself in two wildly different directions that only had one thing in common: neither were anything like the actual story L.M. Montgomery wrote. If the mess we were given was the story the show writers wanted to tell, they shouldn’t have called it Anne of Green Gables.

  8. It’s true that, some things were a little forced in Anne with an E, not because Montgomery didn’t wrote them (It’s not meant to be the same), some progressive stuff were just a little… too ahead in time or just forced, but still, i fcking love the series, i became emotionally attached by it.

Contribute to the conversation...

Yay! You've decided to leave a comment. That's fantastic. Please keep in mind that comments are moderated by the guidelines laid out in our comment policy. Let's have a personal and meaningful conversation and thanks for stopping by!