The Top 15 Witches According to My Bruja Heart

Witches are the absolute best. Witches have long symbolized the power of women, resistance against the patriarchy, female community and oneness with nature. This is especially true for outcasts and marginalized girls and women who often turn to witches to find a way to feel powerful against the forces that oppress them. I’m pretty sure that most of us who were weird kids grew up wanting to be witches; I know I did.

Basically, a lot of us here at Autostraddle are big fans of witches, and I’m one of the biggest. In fact, I love witches so much that I started a Femme Witch Coven, devote a huge portion of my aesthetic to brujas and even dressed as a witch to go to my friend’s wedding.

So, here’s a list of 15 witches that we love, ranked mostly in no particular order. There are so many freaking cool witches, I’m sure I left out a ton who deserve to be on the list. Who are some of your favorites?


1. Willow

I mean, obviously she’s gonna be on the list. She’s a queer witch from one of the biggest girl power shows of the 90s and someone that seems like an awesome nerdy best friend. We’ve written about our love for her plenty of times before, so of course she deserves the first spot on this list.

Netflix "Orange is the New Black" Backstories 2. Gloria from Orange is the New Black

With the help of her tía, she did side work as a curandera out of the back of her shop back before she was arrested. Now that she’s head of the kitchen, she’s able to use her skills and knowledge to make a candle that brings protection to Maritza’s baby and then later help Norma take down Vee with some eggs, spices, oil and dog hair.

3. Baba Yaga

I remember as an elementary school child hearing funny little stories about her, and thinking that she was a goofy figure like The Easter Bunny. But when I did some other reading as an adult, she’s actually pretty badass and pretty scary. She lives in a house with chicken feet and flies around with a freaking giant mortar and pestle. She’s not just the matriarch of Eastern European witches, she’s the matriarch of half of Eastern European folklore.

William Porter trying (and failing) to burn the Bell Witch via

William Porter trying (and failing) to burn the Bell Witch via

 4. The Bell Witch

This was my favorite creepy real-life story to read about when I was in middle school. A 19th century Tennessee family is tormented by either a feminine spirit, a poltergeist or a witch named Kate Batts. Either way, a bunch of local legends and folklore and rumors got mixed up together to create one of the longest lasting stories about a haunting in America. Also, we wouldn’t have The Blair Witch ProjectAn American Haunting or a bunch of other witch and poltergeist movies if it wasn’t for the Bell Witch.

Willemijn Verkaik as Elphaba via Stage Door Dish

Willemijn Verkaik as Elphaba via Stage Door Dish

5. Elphaba

Definitely one of the most famous witches in pop culture, a lot of us loved her when she was just the Wicked Witch of the West, and then the rest fell in love after her starring turn in Wicked. She’s got the broom, the hat, the entire classic look. She’s got high aspirations, a great heart and she’s also a pretty dang good singer.

6. Misty Day

I absolutely love American Horror Story: Coven (or at least I love a lot about it, I also have some serious issues), and Misty Day was maybe my favorite part. I mean, Lily Rabe is often my favorite part of American Horror Story, but when she played Swamp Witch Misty Day, she was amazing. So many of these characters were just plain terrible people, but Misty Day was able to rise above and be a beautiful soul despite all that she had to deal with. Poor, lovely swamp witch.

7. The Witches from MisSpelled

Have you caught this funny, creative and clever webseries yet? It’s about a group of five friends who are witches and it’s created by and starring a bunch of women of color. The dark comedy series deals with how these girls deal with their growing powers, their relationships and their lives. Any time you have a cast of five diverse women of color and a product that’s this high quality, you know you’ve got something special.

via tumblr

via tumblr

8. Nancy from The Craft

Who didn’t want to be Nancy? Who didn’t have a crush on Nancy? I mean, yeah, she was kind of a jerk, and in the end she didn’t exactly come out on top, but jeez, when she said “we are the weirdos mister,” I know I never wanted to be weird as much as I did right then.

art by Robert Hack

art by Robert Hack

9. Sabrina the Teenage Witch

Of course a lot of us know her from her self-titled TV show starring the wonderful Melissa Joan Hart, but if you haven’t checked her out in the recent Afterlife With Archie comics or in the first issue of her own new Chilling Adventures of Sabrina comic, you really need to. This is some really messed up stuff, you guys. It’s like Lovecraft, old pre-Comics-Code EC Comics and The Omen had a really weird daughter. Sabrina is, as her title suggests, the ultimate Teenage Witch.

10. Ursula the Sea Witch

It’s pretty hard to not root for Ursula when you watch The Little Mermaid. She’s a shapeshifter who chooses to be fat most of the time, she’s willing to help her niece reach her dreams and get a date, and she knows the importance of body language. I’m pretty sure she’s my favorite Disney villain.

11. Kiki

Kiki is the newly independent witch girl from Kiki’s Delivery Service who moves to a new town and flies around on her broom delivering things. I also considered giving this spot to The Witch of the Waste from Howl’s Moving Castle or Yubaba from Spirited Away, but I have a soft spot in my heart for Kiki. I think there’s something special about young witches, because they give young girls people to relate to who might be weird or different, but are also powerful and have a place in the world, and Kiki perfectly embodies that spirit.

Art by Alfred Fredericks from the 19th century book A Popular History of the United States

Art by Alfred Fredericks from the 19th century book A Popular History of the United States

12. Tituba

The Salem Witch Trials are the most famous case of American Witchery, and Tituba was the beginning of all of it. She was a slave and the very first person accused of practicing witchcraft there and she apparently confessed to “signing the Devil’s book, flying in the air upon a pole, seeing a cats wolves, birds, and dogs, and pinching or choking some of the ‘afflicted’ girls.” But she must have had some pretty powerful magic behind her, as she wasn’t executed and was even released from prison after a short time, even after all of that. Right on.

13. Hermione Granger

Come on, how could I not include Hermione? She got a whole new generation of girls interested in witches. She was also definitely the most capable student at Hogwarts during the time of the Harry Potter books, and if she had been “The Chosen One,” you can be sure the series would have been just one book. Also, remember that time when she punched Draco right in the face? That was awesome.

Witchy art by Ariel Ries

Witchy art by Ariel Ries

14. Prill from Witchy

The sleeper pick, Prill is from a somewhat new webcomic and isn’t even the main character, but gosh, she is glorious. I’ve talked before about how much I love Prill, not just because she’s a trans witch of color (although that definitely helps) but also because she’s a boss. She knows who she is and knows what she wants and she always speaks her mind and gets her way. Plus she’s one of the most stylish witches around.

15. The Sanderson Sisters

Finally, these three sisters from the Halloween classic Hocus Pocus have to be included on my list. Kathy Najimy, Sarah Jessica Parker and Bette Midler are absolutely delightful: funny, powerful and just the right amount of scary. Really, when you’re feeling witchy and watching a fun Halloween movie, does it get any better than when Winifred Sanderson sings “I Put a Spell On You”? I don’t think so.

Before you go! Autostraddle runs on the reader support of our AF+ Members. If this article meant something to you today — if it informed you or made you smile or feel seen, will you consider joining AF and supporting the people who make this queer media site possible?

Join AF+!


Mey Rude is a fat, trans, Latina lesbian living in LA. She's a writer, journalist, and a trans consultant and sensitivity reader. You can follow her on twitter, or go to her website if you want to hire her.

Mey has written 572 articles for us.


  1. Magical witch girl Bunny is tragically missing from this list, which means you maybe don’t know about Charm School, the comic by Elizabeth Watasin?

    It might be tough to find, but I can’t recommend it enough.

  2. Excellent list! The only thing that would be different for me would be adding Mildred Hubble from the TV show (I haven’t read the books). I think I had crushes on some of the characters when I was young.

  3. Yes! Yes witches forever! Don’t forget about Tiffany Aching from the Terry Pratchett series…she is. the tops. The most practical witch ever, and she has the gayest boots.

  4. Perfect! I’d add Roz Batiste and Eve Batiste from Eve’s Bayou, which you should go watch immediately if you have not already seen it. So good!

  5. Mey, this is awesome. Can’t forget the Practical Magic witches though. I respect a witch that appreciates the ritual and spiritual benefits of midnight margaritas.

  6. YEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEES THIS IS THE BEST!!!!!!! pew pew pew!! (that’s the sound of me throwing spells at the patriarchy with my magic want)

  7. list! Thank you, Mey!

    Just the other day I was thinking – yet again – about how much I love witches! And for that reason I cannot possibly narrow it down to just one favourite witch :D

    When I was a kid, I always wanted to be a witch, and at some point I thought I was one, being sent out of class for casting (or at least trying to cast) spells hahaha.
    Upon graduating high school a few of my class mates made a movie about our class interviewing each other about each other, with questions like “What do you the think X will be doing in ten years? etc.”, and you can imagine how much joy and pride came over me, when I heard some of my class mates say that for sure I would most likely become a witch or, as they put it, something weird <3 To this day, that still makes me very happy :D

  8. This list has reminded me how I spent most of my youth and early twenties…and basically my life crushing on fictional witches… Thanks!

  9. I love this list so much, Mey! Little known fact: my friends and I started our own #queerwitchcru and even thought about getting matching tattoos.

    • Yeah! I’ve seen you mention that on social network! I’m super happy that other queer covens are popping up!

  10. Great list!

    How does everyone feel about the portrayal of Tituba on the Salem tv show? I like the actress and the character so far but I’m getting bad vibes about where the portrayal is going. Curious what history buffs make of it! :)

  11. We learned about the Bell Witch in school when I was like 7 and me and my best friend became totally obsessed and we would dig up rocks and shit from my backyard and pretend like it was the bones of the Bell Witch. And somehow I completely forgot about this episode of my childhood until reading this list! I blame witchcraft…

  12. I have always been, at once intrigued/attracted to and terrified by Fairuza Balk. Also, Misty Day, the poor dear. She didn’t deserve that ending just because Ryan Murphy and Co. couldn’t figure out what to do with her.

  13. I never truly thought I’d wanted to be a witch until RIGHT NOW. All of these witches have been huge influences on my life/aesthetic!!

  14. You would so totally LOVE Serenity Rose. All three volumes are fun, charming, with a bit of action and cute art. It’s from one of the guys who did character design ad stuff for Invader Zim and Avatar.

  15. This showed up in my archives list; so very, very late post, but anyway…

    My fave witches: Charmed, still in re-runs; longest-lasting all-female led show, the 3-4 sister witches

    I liked Sabrina, but I liked her mom’s show too, Bewitched, & the actress who played *her* mother, Endorra, is said to have been a lesbian, and maybe had a long-term relationship with Debbie Reynolds.


  16. What about Fiona Good from the Coven ! Played by Jessica Lange ! She was a bad ass witch . Am surprised she didn’t make this list, if she did I missed her ! She is by far my fav

Comments are closed.