What The F*ck Is Happening With DADT: Discharges Are Possible Once Again, Maybe

It would appear that although originally Judge Virginia Phillips‘ injunction against DADT had temporarily stayed the Pentagon from enforcing it, a new block from the 9th Circuit Court of Appeals has halted Phillips’ measure and DADT seems to be at least partially back in effect. No one really knows what this means, not even the people in charge of enforcing it (or not); so far the best estimation seems to be that gay people (like Dan Choi) can still go to enlistment centers and go through the entire process – there’s no law against enlisting a gay person – but they are fully vulnerably to discharge immediately upon actually entering the armed forces. (@politicsdaily)

Defense Secretary Robert Gates says this is exactly the kind of outcome he was trying to avoid with his plan to very slowly work on repealing the ban with a ten-month review process.

Last week, as the courts were busily undoing this careful strategy, a visibly grumpy Gates told reporters that he still feels “very strongly that this is an action that needs to be taken by the Congress.” Lifting the ban, he said, “requires careful preparation and a lot of training. A lot of revision of regulations. . . . [has] to be done in addition to the training.”

The question that remains, of course, is whether Gates is right about the “careful preparation” and “training” that will take so long. It’s clear that this bizarre legal limbo needs to end – but could it be ended just as easily and effectively by the government’s ceasing to fight this case and allowing an injunction against DADT to stand? Gates thinks no, and the Justice Department agrees: “The Justice Department, arguing for a stay of Phillips’ ruling, said lifting the ban now “risks causing significant immediate harm to the military and its efforts to be prepared to implement an orderly repeal of the statute.”

But the media is beginning to wonder whether the sky would really fall if this issue were over starting tomorrow, and as for what enlisted soldiers think – arguably the opinion that matters most – no one seems to know. If the military gained any pertinent insight on this from their survey, they’re not letting us know what it was.

Stay tuned, as the legal status of this issue seems to be changing literally by the hour. And as every reputable source (and the government) is telling you, if you’re enlisted now and want to keep your job, don’t come out yet. It’s looking more and more like it will be safe in the near future, but we don’t live in the future.

Before you go! Autostraddle runs on the reader support of our AF+ Members. If this article meant something to you today — if it informed you or made you smile or feel seen, will you consider joining AF and supporting the people who make this queer media site possible?

Join AF+!


Originally from Boston, MA, Rachel now lives in the Midwest. Topics dear to her heart include bisexuality, The X-Files and tacos. Her favorite Ciara video is probably "Ride," but if you're only going to watch one, she recommends "Like A Boy." You can follow her on twitter and instagram.

Rachel has written 1142 articles for us.


  1. Wasn’t even surprised last night when I got the breaking news text from MSNBC. This is like a big ping pong game. Quite entertaining actually.

  2. I can’t get my hopes up about anything anymore. It seems like even waiting a whole year to get excited is a bad idea. Sigh.

  3. Not entertaining as in let’s grab some popcorn and a coke and sit down to watch. But entertaining as in how stupid can these people be to keep voting and blocking the rights of people who deserve it. Trust me, I don’t think this is funny. I have to deal with this first hand everyday.

  4. Damn it.

    I am pretty close to giving up on this idea of equal rights. Is it ever going to happen in any form? If people are still this stupid, I just can’t picture a lightbulb moment where everyone goes, “Oh man, we have been giant fuckwads, haven’t we?”

    • People were saying that about the Civil Rights Movement in the 1960s. It’ll take some time but eventually the history books will make the anti-gay movement look like the assholes they are.

      In the meantime, hug everyone indiscriminately.

  5. Sad face.

    And please don’t give up on equal rights. We can’t give up. That’s how they win.

  6. Joe My God posted an update that the Pentagon updated orders to basically say that any discharges under DADT have to approved by some higher-ups. So its a lot harder to discharge people (I think he said extremely difficult) but still… :(

  7. This is just getting to be one big mess.

    On another note, am I the only one that thinks Dan Choi looks like he could be either a Green or a Blue Lantern? I dunno, I just sort of got that vibe from that picture.

  8. All I know is I have a huge man crush on Dan Choi and have since he came into the limelight. HUGE. I don’t ever really get star-struck and I’m not much on following celebrities, but I would go all gay in the knees in meeting that guy. He is one of the few people out there I don’t know personally that I can say I deeply admire based off of his news and media appearances alone.

Comments are closed.