Rebel Girls: This Is What A Lavender Menace Looks Like

Header by Rory Midhani

Header by Rory Midhani

Second-wave feminists, for the most part, did not like queer ladies. I don’t think it’s necessary to give you the full rehash of the story, but suffice it to say that Betty Friedan wasn’t alone when she declared us “lavender menaces,” invoking to the members of the National Organization for Women her fear that queer women would forever taint the feminist movement if they were visibly a part of it. It took her years to admit her fault and come out in full support of what was broadly known, at the time, as lesbian rights. But by the time Friedan and her crew of straight women had caught up to the times, queer women had already f*cked up their movement — and built one all their own.

The following queermos went boldly forth during the second wave as their most honest and real selves, and thus disrupted the feminist movement’s homophobia and set the stage for the LGBT activism that has rocked our world. If you think I missed a badass human, let me know in the comments!


Achebe Betty Powell

passionatepolitics

Formerly Betty Powell, Achebe got her start in the civil rights movement in 1962. She was engaged in activism through her career as a high school teacher and college professor, and both brought students to protests and found herself involved in them as she went about campus life. She organized throughout the second wave for feminist, LGBT, and racial justice from an intersectional perspective, with her mantra being that she cannot talk about one fight without talking about how it links into another. She was also a founding member of the Salsa Soul Sisters collective, now the oldest Black lesbian organization in the United States. The group formed in 1971 as its members split from the Gay Liberation Front.


Audre Lorde

Atlantic Center for the Arts

A Carribbean-American lesbian writer and activist, Audre Lorde came out swinging against Betty Friedan’s feminism from the start. She was outspoken about The Feminine Mystique‘s white, middle-class focus, and instead explored her “theory of difference” in her work — the idea that it was too simple to lump all men and all women together as if all that separated them was their sex. That turned out to be a launching point for the rest of her career, in which she often pointedly called out racism in the feminist movement.


Barbara Smith

Barbars Smith, all the way at the left, surrounded by bad bitches.

Barbars Smith, all the way at the left, surrounded by bad bitches.

Barbara Smith has been movement-building for over forty years as a champion for antiracism, women’s empowerment, and queer liberation. During the second wave, she was a founding member of the Combahee River Collective — which wrote one of the most important documents in the history of feminism and introduced the concept of interconnected oppression — and also went on to found Kitchen Table Press, the first women’s press to focus specifically on the voices and stories of women of color.


Cherrie Moraga

Screen Shot 2013-06-18 at 5.39.57 PM

A self-described Xicana dyke, Cherry Moraga lived and wrote openly as a lesbian chicana in the second wave. She often reflected on how her own marginalization as a queer person echoed her mother’s experiences as a poor woman, which led her to recognize the interconnectedness of those identities. Moraga would come out of the second wave an activist and warrior, and ultimately co-edited This Bridge Called My Back and helped found Kitchen Table Press with Barbara Smith. Her 1983 book Loving in the War Years: Lo que nunca paso por sus labios was the first published volume by an openly lesbian chicana.


Del Martin and Phyllis Lyon

DelMartinAndPhyllisLyon2

Del Martin and Phyllis Lyon are the feminist power couple of your queer dreams. They met in 1950, became lovers in 1953, and moved in together in San Francisco in 1953, as lesbians are won’t to do. Three years later, they directly confronted the lesbophobic climate of the times when they founded the Daughters of Bilitis, the first social and political organization of its kind in the nation. They ran shit together throughout the rest of the second wave, acting as alternating editors of newsletter The Ladder and forming the Council on Religion and the Homosexual to push for the decriminalization of homosexuality in the 60’s and 70’s. They were the first lesbian couple to join the National Organization for Women.


Elaine Noble

Elaine-Noble-c1974

Elaine Noble ran fearlessly for a spot in the House of Representatives in 1974, winning despite a series of ugly events including shootings, harassment, and destruction of property on the campaign trail. She was the first openly LGBT candidate elected to a state-level office in American history and the third openly LGBT person elected ever overall. Despite the backlash, she never shied from her sexuality. She was an advocate even while she served, working to raise awareness about LGBT issues in the political arena and founding an LGBT alcohol and drug treatment center in Minneapolis later in life called the Pride Institute.


Joan Nestle and Deb Edel

Dancing on the left is Joan and Deb (in the tie).

Dancing on the left is Joan and Deb (in the tie).

Joan Nestle, a femme who has activist roots in the Civil Rights movement, became involved in gay liberation efforts after the Stonewall Riots. She went on during the 70’s to join the Lesbian Liberation Committee and form the Gay Academic Union, and later on would win a Lambda Literary Award for her writing. In the years between, however, she and her partner Deb Edel opened their home and hearts in order to found the Lesbian Herstory Archives, which took years to get off the ground and out of their apartment. Their grassroots approach, however, was meant to help the project retain its connection to the communities it served — and considering how badass it is to this day, they seem to have done alright.


Maxine Feldman

feldman_maxine_3

Maxine Feldman, who described themselves as a “big loud Jewish butch lesbian” during their coming up as a musician in the second wave, wrote and recorded the song “Angry Atthis” in 1969, now known as the first openly lesbian song of the “women’s music” movement in the second wave.

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=w7VsWfFNQyo

Feldman then found audiences across the nation, sparking discussion by performing the folk song on college campuses during times of heightened political activism, and performed at the first-ever Michigan Womyn’s Festival. Later in life, Feldman came out as trans, and used he/him pronouns.


Rita Mae Brown

tumblr_lp9ihwHGaq1qghfy5o1_1280

Rita Mae Brown is the ultimate queer feminist badass. You may know her for writing Rubyfruit Junglewhich in and of itself was an act of defiance against cultural norms that sought, at the time, to erase lesbian experiences. But her activism goes even further. Brown was an employee of the National Organization for Women when Betty Friedan made her infamous anti-gay “lavender menace” remarks, after which Brown was forced to leave. She went on to take up the mantle of indeed menacing the nation and demanding rights — first, as a leader in the “Lavender Menace Zap” of the Second Congress to Unite Women in 1970, then as a founding member of the Radicalesbians and the Furies Collective, an all-woman separatist colony that published a lesbian feminist newspaper pinpointing all oppression on heterosexuality.

Also, this:

I don’t believe in straight or gay. I really don’t. I think we’re all degrees of bisexual. There may be a few people on the extreme if it’s a bell curve who really truly are gay or really truly are straight. Because nobody had ever said these things and used their real name, I suddenly became [in the late 1970s] the only lesbian in America.


Rebel Girls is a column about women’s studies, the feminist movement, and the historical intersections of both of them. It’s kind of like taking a class, but better – because you don’t have to wear pants. To contact your professor privately, email carmen at autostraddle dot com. Ask questions about the lesson in the comments!


Before you go! It takes funding to keep this publication by and for queer women and trans people of all genders running every day. We will never put our site behind a paywall because we know how important it is to keep Autostraddle free. But that means we rely on the support of our A+ Members. Still, 99.9% of our readers are not members. A+ membership starts at just $4/month. If you’re able to, will you join A+ and keep Autostraddle here and working for everyone?

Join A+

Carmen spent six years at Autostraddle, ultimately serving as Straddleverse Director, Feminism Editor and Social Media Co-Director. She is now the Consulting Digital Editor at Ms. and writes regularly for DAME, the Women’s Media Center, the National Women’s History Museum and other prominent feminist platforms; her work has also been published in print and online by outlets like BuzzFeed, Bitch, Bust, CityLab, ElixHER, Feministing, Feminist Formations, GirlBoss, GrokNation, MEL, Mic and SIGNS, and she is a co-founder of Argot Magazine. You can find Carmen on Twitter, Instagram and Tumblr or in the drive-thru line at the nearest In-N-Out.

Carmen has written 921 articles for us.

46 Comments

    • i’m glad you liked it! yay! i hope to teach the world about all of the awesome ladies via this column so REST EASY.

    • the best part is if you click the link, it’s an article called RITA MAE BROWN: HATES MARRIAGE. LOVES CATS which is pretty much what we all aspire to be remembered for, i think.

      • I just read that article literally a couple of days ago (post Rubyfruit Jungle research spiral), and spent all day telling everyone I know that “Hates Marriage, Loves Cats” is the succinct motto/manifesto I never knew I needed.

  1. p

    a great article fo sho but it’s a bit odd to say Maxine Feldman “now” uses he/him pronouns considering he is deceased.

    • oh my gosh, a detail i missed when i was condensing things for this piece, clearly! will edit this.

    • Al

      I think it’s also a bit odd to use the term rebel girl in the title since Maxine identified as male.

      • that’s the name of the column! it’s not specific to this post, it’s just what unifies this series.

  2. That’s my favorite picture of Audre Lorde. This great recap of these amazing women makes me wonder about the queer feminist movement(s) of today. Who’s ripping up the patriarchy? What do they call themselves?

  3. Keeping my fingers crossed that any of these names will show up in my daughter’s textbooks. Thanks for providing these history lessons that I wouldn’t have hated in school.

    • ahhh i am crossing my fingers for this, too! also, glad you liked the post <3

  4. Naomi

    Great piece. One additional and awesome tidbit about Achebe Powell is that she was one of the founding mothers of Astraea Lesbian Foundation for Justice back in 1977, and the organization is still going strong and supporting LGBTQI liberation movements all around the world!

  5. I like this! My gender/womens/sexuality studies program was not very queer and this is great!

  6. cleo

    Wow. Listening to “Angry Atthis” gave me the chills. Beautiful.

  7. Has there ever been a band called “Lavender Menaces”? I feel like that would be the perfect name for a queer band.

    • Rie

      I’ve known at least two queer burlesquers that went by Lavender Menace

      • i think there needs to be a band and maybe you could start it called lavender menaces, yes to this, yes yes yes.

        BE THE QUEER BAND YOU WANNA SEE IN THE WORLD

        • I would love to have a band called Lavender Menace! The only thing stopping me is my total lack of musical ability :)
          In my dreams I’m the drummer. In reality I would probably be the tambourine girl.

      • That’s pretty cool. Going to a burlesque show is on my bucket list so maybe one day I’ll end up at one called Lavender Menace.

  8. Mik

    This is my favorite column, thanks Carmen. Also I want a lavender menace shirt asap

      • Mik

        I would buy a car just for the privilege of having a lavender menace sticker forever affixed to the bumper

    • I saw the movie She’s Beautiful When She’s Angry, which was a kick-ass documentary about feminism, and they are selling Lavender Menace shirts to fund their continued distribution–I got mine there. They also have some other cool merch, like a Shameless Hussy shirt.

      (Not paid by them, just want to support their efforts!)

      http://www.shesbeautifulwhenshesangry.com/shop/

  9. Loved this peice! However, am I totally alone in finding parts of Rubyfruit jungle problematic? The part where, as a 20 something, the main character is sleeping with a 15 year old girl (and her mom!) felt gross and predatory to me.

    • Jennie T

      I accidentally hit report this user and in no way meant it. I’m sorry!

    • I happen upon things like that over and over in the lives or works of prominent queer women that make me question their integrity as people and as feminists. I was horrified, for example, to learn that Simone de Beauvoir frequently bedded her high school students.

      On top of the pretty universal sad fact that teenage girls are considered sexually available to adults, I think that, especially earlier in the century, there was an attitude of ‘well, if compulsory heterosexuality is a lie, then why should we encumber ourselves of any other regulation or custom around sex?’.

      Another thing which is still very relevant today is that it’s harder to form a same-sex pair and there are less models of healthy possibilities, and so people, especially young people, are willing to overlook something that feels wrong or destructive for the chance to be with someone. Also, lesbian sex is still seen as ‘sex lite’, and therefore non-‘deflowering’ and non-traumatizing, even by the participants.

      Although the graphic novel treats the timeline differently in this regard, the movie ‘Blue is the Warmest Colour’ definitely features a 20-something literally waiting outside a high school to get a lay (and her character is incredibly predatory and abusive). It made me extremely uncomfortable that this was mostly not pointed out by queer people (and straight people!) reviewing the movie.

    • I wasn’t fond of that part of Rubyfruit Jungle either, though I also just found the protagonist a bit annoying overall.

  10. Thank you Prof Rios, this was really great!

    Does anyone know of some lavender menaces outside the US from this era?

  11. Cath

    I wonder about this legend underneath a picture: “Barbars Smith, all the way at the left, surrounded by bad bitches”. Is it how those people self-identified or did you choose the term yourself?

  12. Can anyone recommend some good books on LGBT/Feminist books? Over the last year or so I’ve really gotten into feminism.

  13. Thank you as usual, @carmenrios – what an amazing group of rebels! It also includes a couple of authors whose poetry/creative writing I really like. Audre Lorde and Cherríe Moraga are powerful! They write the kinds of poems/prose pieces it almost hurts to read because they are so real.

  14. Betty Friedan did not declare “queer women” to be lavender menaces. She used that term to describe lesbians.

    A group of lesbian radical feminists reclaimed the term Lavender Menace and went on to protest the exclusion of lesbian issues from the feminist movement at a women’s congress in 1970. This is a significant part of lesbian history. Not “queer,” not “LGBT.” Lesbian history.

    To insist on using the term “queer” in a situation like this is to pretend that lesbians and bisexual/ pansexual women are oppressed in the same way. It is to ignore the fact that in addition to being oppressed for our attraction to women– which is something we have in common with bisexuals–lesbians are uniquely oppressed for our lack of attraction to men.

    Also, I doubt that most of the women in this article would take kindly to being referred to as “queermos.” (Given that queer was very heavily used as a slur in their time.)

    • The mainstream feminist movement of this era did not welcome any openly LGBTQ women, whether lesbian, bi/pan/queer, or transgender (of any orientation). Of course the rejection of LGBTQ women by mainstream feminism, and the activists that fought for our rights in spite of that rejection, are a part of LGBTQ history.

    • Bronwyn

      Thank you!! I was screaming at this article “LESBIAN NOT QUEER”

Contribute to the conversation...

Yay! You've decided to leave a comment. That's fantastic. Please keep in mind that comments are moderated by the guidelines laid out in our comment policy. Let's have a personal and meaningful conversation and thanks for stopping by!