An Open Letter to Amanda Bynes

Dear Amanda,

Firstly, I’d like to thank you for the work you did in the 2006 Shakespeare-inspired cinematic masterpiece, She’s The Man. Your portrayal of the cross-dressing soccer-loving Viola Hastings touched my life in ways I cannot explain — although I’ve tried, both on this website and on my blog.

But Amanda Bynes, I’m not talking unicorns and double-rainbows today. I’m writing to ask you to stop fucking with my heart. Seriously.

When you suddenly announced your retirement 33 days ago, I was in shock and then denial. I waited for your “jk” or whatever, but it never happened, and then my denial turned into anger. Can you even retire on twitter? Does that even count? What does that even mean?

You don’t like working? Hey, we all do things that we don’t like doing. That’s life, you make sacrifices for the people you care for, like how just last week, I bought Hairspray on DVD. While in the States for Pride, Laneia & I made everyone late for Cubbyhole just so that you wouldn’t be bored in retirement.

But then, as if on the seven-stages of grief clockwork, my anger transformed into reasoning, like a single rainbow into a double rainbow. Your career wasn’t fun anymore. I can relate! Just this morning I wrote 2,000 words on infrastructure management, and I’m willing to bet that my enthusiasm for storage networks is on par with yours for stage cues. So you said f*ck this, and you quit! Good work!

Sadly though, my acceptance was fleeting. The sun came up after that aforementioned Cubbyhole trip and the vodka-tonics wore off, and I found myself back in a dark, dark place. The one where She’s The Man, Again will never see the light of day.

So just imagine the confusion I felt when you recently announced that you’ve “unretired”! On twitter!

Actually I don’t follow you on Twitter so I got the news way after everyone else did. Generally your barrage of cryptic tweets about matters of the heart make me feel crazy, and not even your avoidance of gender pronouns is enough to pique my interest in your feed. But that’s neither here nor there.

But what’s behind this sudden Retirement Remorse?  Were you having a bad day, did you get caught up in a moment and say some things in the cybersphere that you knew you couldn’t take back? I understand that feeling. I anticipate feeling that feeling as soon as I publish this open letter, which may or may not be fundamentally ridiculous.

But you did take those words back. Now I don’t know if I can trust you. Are you just doing this to promote your latest film?

Regardless, I’m gonna offer you my help. That’s right. As a workaholic, I feel like I could help you assimilate back into employed life. Now that Hilary’s stopped working I’ve been looking for a new actress /singer/fashion designer to emotionally invest in.

So think about that, grasshopper, as I sign off with some words of wisdom: leave the retirement/un-retirement shtick to the professional athletes. Anyone can kick around a soccer ball – but it takes a true artiste to do it in drag.

Keep doing what you do! Really please. Don’t retire again.



Before you go! It takes funding to keep this publication by and for queer women and trans people of all genders running every day. We will never put our site behind a paywall because we know how important it is to keep Autostraddle free. But that means we rely on the support of our A+ Members. Still, 99.9% of our readers are not members. A+ membership starts at just $4/month. If you’re able to, will you join A+ and keep Autostraddle here and working for everyone?

Join A+

Founding member. Former writer. Still loves Autostraddle with her whole heart.

Crystal has written 320 articles for us.


      • i thought you were my girlfriend kelsey; you aren’t, but i do have a particular kind of affection for you nonetheless.

      • brackishtea



        Amanda Bynes, I love you but you don’t know my name.

  1. i liked ‘what i like about you’!

    amanda bynes looks like someone i know but i can’t figure out who.

    those are my feelings re: amanda bynes.

  2. e

    oh god, i was so relieved that she unretired. talk about edge of your seat.

  3. I am excited for her new movie, but mostly because of Emma Stone and Penn Badgley. Hm, but maybe I’ll watch She’s the Man later, I do love that movie.

  4. She’s totally queer. Avoidance of gender pronouns + raving about Rihanna’s “Te Amo” music video = gaaaaaay.

  5. this is so amazing. so very.

    also: “Now that Hilary’s stopped working I’ve been looking for a new actress /singer/fashion designer to emotionally invest in.”


  6. Amy

    I would just like to share that I opened the unretirement link in a new tab in Safari, & when I look at it from a different tab, it reads, “Actress Amanda Bynes Comes Out…” & I wish that were real.

  7. Bri

    Really, I’m just confused as to why no one is discussing the brilliance of “Sydney White”.

  8. Rockets

    Umm, you expressed a lot of feelings I had as well. I’m glad I’m not alone. That, and the fact that this was pretty much the funniest thing I read today! Thanks! If it wasn’t for the fact that she’s a little bit (but not quite) too young for me I probably would have talked about these feelings earlier… If there was a glitter god in heaven, she’d let Amanda be my gf. She certainly would.

  9. PlainAyn

    I’m about 87% sure she’s gay. Ever since I was a kid I’ve liked gay things/people before I even knew they were gay and I believe Amanda Bynes is just another check mark on my list.

    • 87% homo huh. Even though I made that gag about avoiding gender pronouns, to me she comes across as 110% hetero. Anything is possible though right.

  10. You know why Amanda Bynes looks so familiar? Check her out in She’s The Man…in drag she’s the ORIGINAL lesbian who looks like Justin Beiber…back when Justin Beiber was just a lesbian-like twinkle in his mother’s eyes.

  11. bronzed cjay

    in all fairness I don’t believe in repeat performance, but yes, yes I did buy she’s the man on DVD once upon a time.. and yes I did have sexual relations with a girl that looks like her.. and said girl is now retired for the gay team..

    …hold the phone! queer’ets, this just twated.. @amandabyneslookalikeghostfromchristmaspast is now back in the game.
    whether it’d be for promotional use or some other ficticious reasoning like michale jordan back to the bulls, is unclear at this time.

  12. i know this is like a year late, but whatever.

    Amanda bynes was my first girl crush. And she will be mine.

Contribute to the conversation...

Yay! You've decided to leave a comment. That's fantastic. Please keep in mind that comments are moderated by the guidelines laid out in our comment policy. Let's have a personal and meaningful conversation and thanks for stopping by!