30 Days of Carol: Day 28 – The Original Carol

click for all 30 Days of Carol

I’ll start by saying that this is not the original post I’d planned to (and did) write. The original post I wrote was about seeing Love, Simon – the new teen coming out dramedy/comedrama – last weekend with a group of gays, and how its normalcy made me reflect on what queer longing looked like for me as a person who came of age well before this byproduct of the Carols and the Moonlights and the Call Me By Your Names, and how differently my life would be if I’d had them. This post had it all. It was hittin’ the highs and the lows, the sweets and sours. It had questions. I revealed a very embarrassing fact about myself!

Then, I brought it masterfully back to this series, and wondered what my Carol was. While considering potential movie candidates (based on my affinity towards them growing up despite them having zero explicitly gay content or even subtext, which I now know is because I was placing myself squarely in the role of the female lead’s love interest), I decided to investigate the 1996 film One Fine Day starring Michelle Pfeiffer. Pfeiffer was my root from her Catwoman days, and I remembered her seeming generally repulsed by most of the men in One Fine Day, so I figured it was a good place to start. But the more I deconstructed the movie, the more I realized that this wasn’t “my Carol” in a world starved for gay content, this was… Carol.

Okay, sure, yes, the opposing romantic lead is a pre-glow up George Clooney, but I didn’t register him when I was younger and I certainly don’t have to now. Besides, you can’t tell me the other evidence doesn’t make up for it. Let’s investigate, once again:

It’s main character?

A blonde-bobbed single mom recently split from her child’s father who spends a lot of the movie out on the streets of NYC dressed for success and looking at men like she wished they were dead.

Scene transitions?


Riding in cars.

Its most recognizable song?

Another Doo-Wop Classic, The Chiffons’ “One Fine Day”.

Remember Carol’s looks directed at men?  Here are Michelle’s:






Michelle’s mom is the movie?

Holland Taylor. AKA Sarah Paulson’s girlfriend. AKA ABBY, CARL’S BEST FRIEND.

Remember Carol’s other looks? Well here are a couple from Michelle’s without a target:



Michelle’s son in the movie?

Sure, he has basically the same haircut as Rindy.

“Hm, Michelle probably didn’t have Carol’s enterances though.” – You


… being wrong.

Are there also too many white people?




There are also too many white people!

But DOES she have a makeup moment?

Oh, she has a makeup moment.

There’s probably no way there could also be a MECHANICAL TOY element in this…



I wonder if there are other looks?



Autostraddle cannot exist without the generous support of our readers. We're running the fundraiser through March 29th! We're out of immediate danger...but we had to ask...what if we could survive for longer? Will you help?

Go to our Fundraiser!


Los Angeles based writer. Let's keep it clean out there!

Erin has written 208 articles for us.


  1. Hang on

    I have a small but serious issue to report

    With this image:

    I’m concerned that this is either wilful misrepresentation or some Carol fraud has been committed because yesterday there was not some Carol.

    Hopefully this can be resolved quickly because we wouldn’t want the Shenny class action suit turning into a criminal negligence case.

  2. Shopping Carol, shopping Carol,
    It’s Christmas time in the city,
    Store speakers sing, registers ring,
    Soon it will be Christmas day

    City sidewalks, busy sidewalks,
    Dressed in holiday style,
    Will take us to a fateful meeting,
    Carol laughing, Therese sighing,
    eliciting smile after smile,
    And on every street corner you see

    Shopping Carol, shopping Carol,
    It’s Christmas time in the city,
    Offering lunch, on a hunch,
    Soon she will be joined by Therese

  3. Is it just me, or in the red coats walking down the sidewalk pics, doesn’t George Clooney look freakishly like Kyle Chandler? On the other hand, Harge wouldn’t be caught dead walking down the sidewalk, he would insist on being chauffeur-driven.

    I figured the answer to “What do you (Erin) do on (Easter) Sundays?” was either a) take the day off or b) play cruel April Fool’s jokes on the needy. I didn’t even find 30 Days of Carol until day 24 and I registered just so I could take the Carolhead Trivia Quiz. I don’t want this to end either. Hopefully the April 17 anniversary will kick off another round of Carol revelry!

Contribute to the conversation...

Yay! You've decided to leave a comment. That's fantastic. Please keep in mind that comments are moderated by the guidelines laid out in our comment policy. Let's have a personal and meaningful conversation and thanks for stopping by!