“The Good Fight” Season 6 Gives Carmen a Girlfriend

The Good Fight has been barreling through its sixth season, doing all the things this series does best: stellar performances from powerhouse actors (Phylicia Rashad, Andre Braugher, and John Slattery are notable additions this season), bizarrely memorable one-off side characters, and a general air of narrative and tonal chaos. I’ve never before seen a show as simultaneously sincere and sardonic as this one. It exists in this constant paradox, its characters complex and even sometimes contradictory but in a way that ultimately feels real and not like lazy writing. The whole point of this show is to feel extremely of-the-moment, and that can sometimes result in episodes that veer into cringe territory by boiling really complicated political and cultural contexts that we’re literally currently living through and grappling with into a digestible hour-long television format. But when it does hit the mark, whew does it hitThe Good Fight knows what it is, and what it is is actually one of the most accurate televisual reflections of what it feels like to exist in the world right now. It’s confusing, scary, and always shifting. Violence, racism, policing, and surveillance are baked into all parts of life. Far-right political movements once framed as fringe are gaining more and more power. Systems are broken beyond the possibility of reformation and need to be blown up altogether. Season six of The Good Fight makes all of these things very explicit.

This has been a pivotal season in particular for second-year associate Carmen Moyo (Charmaine Bingwa), who has been wandering deeper and deeper into the morally murky waters of Reddick and Associates as she becomes increasingly entangled with some of the firm’s criminal kingpins. But increasingly, it seems like Carmen is on perfectly equal footing with some of these nefarious players. She knows how to play their game — almost too well. Carmen is a bit of a scary mystery, and that reminds me of one of my favorite television characters of all time, also from the same narrative universe as The Good Fight: investigator Kalinda Sharma. And as it turns out, Carmen and Kalinda do have something very important in common: THEY’RE BOTH QUEER.

A morally complicated queer character who likes to play power games? Sign me right the fuck up. The more we peel back the layers of Carmen, the more of an enigma she becomes. There have been a few scenes set in her apartment this season, and it looks like this:

A sparse apartment with a bed on the floor

What on earth is going on here???? A nearly empty, unfurnished, undecorated apartment with a frameless mattress on the floor???? Carmen lives her life like she’s always ready to run, and I simply need to know why!

Under that lump on the floor, Carmen is frolicking around with a woman who emerges with a mop of dark curls.

Carmen from The Good Fight in bed with someone with dark curly hair

My genuine first thought upon seeing that mop of curls was: IS THAT MARISSA GOLD?

And folks, it is not, but I was not alone.

Carmen is dating a Marissa lookalike. Jay immediately points this out to Marissa when Carmen’s girlfriend shows up at the office.

Jay says: "Marissa you are defying the laws of physics right now."

Marissa says: "I'm...what?"

Jay points

Carmen and her girlfriend kiss

Marissa makes a face.

The Good Fight is so good at conveying absurdity at all levels — whether in the over-the-top form of Diane’s increasingly wild hallucinations this season or in the everyday form of your friend dating someone who looks exactly like you.The Good Fight‘s sense of humor can really go off the rails, but it’s is sometimes as straightforward as this. It’s weird that Carmen is dating a Marissa doppelgänger, but it’s also normal-weird. And it’s gay as hell. Complicated relationships between coworkers are the source of a lot of The Good Fight‘s interpersonal drama — and The Good Wife‘s before it — and this is a very specific take on that. It’s such a small subplot within the packed episode, but it stands out as something just slightly surreal. Coupled with Carmen’s sparse apartment, it’s actually a little unnerving. Who is Carmen and what does she want?

We don’t learn much about Marissa 2 aka Mindy other than the fact that Carmen apparently keeps her at a distance from her work, which Mindy does not seem to love, but hey, considering the company Carmen keeps these days, she’s probably protecting her! Mindy teases Carmen, asking if work doesn’t know she’s gay, and Carmen replies: “They don’t know I’m anything.” I read this as Carmen indeed wanting to be a bit elusive to the people around her but also possibly being a little adverse toward explicit labels, much like Kalinda was.

Marissa, being Marissa, of course approaches her lookalike and names what everyone’s thinking. Carmen’s at a distance, watching them nervously. And, I mean, they are literally wearing the same pants:

Mindy and Marissa wear matching camo pants

Mindy agrees with Marissa that they indeed look similar and then reveals she’s not at all happy about it, which, okay, I do find it hilarious that Carmen is dating a Marissa 2, but I think Mindy is being a little silly thinking that automatically means she wants to fuck Marissa. My reaction to her sudden flash of jealousy is the same as Marissa’s:

Marissa looks weirded out.

I hope we haven’t seen the last of Mindy, and I hope we keep peeling back Carmen’s layers, even if they only open up more questions.


Before you go! It costs money to make indie queer media, and frankly, we need more members to survive 2023As thanks for LITERALLY keeping us alive, A+ members get access to bonus content, extra Saturday puzzles, and more! Will you join? Cancel anytime.

Join A+!

Kayla Kumari Upadhyaya

Kayla Kumari Upadhyaya is the managing editor of Autostraddle and a lesbian writer of essays, short stories, and pop culture criticism living in Miami. She is the assistant managing editor of TriQuarterly, and her short stories appear or are forthcoming in McSweeney's Quarterly Concern, Joyland, Catapult, The Offing, and more. Some of her pop culture writing can be found at The A.V. Club, Vulture, The Cut, and others. You can follow her on Twitter or Instagram and learn more about her work on her website.

Kayla has written 458 articles for us.

4 Comments

  1. This story was everything! Not only did it confirm that Carmen was gay–something I’d hoped for since Bingwa’s casting but was increasingly afraid might not happen–it also gives me hope that something might be done with Marissa before the series is done. And it was funny and provided character development to boot!

    (GOD, Marissa’s scene with Maia at the bar is still one of my favorites. THE BETRAYAL. Best Judas moment since actual Judas.)

  2. You know Carmen has a sledgehammer somewhere in that bare apartment ready to be used to break down drywall to grab a go-bag out of the wall with various types of currency and passports.

    The difference with Kalinda is that Carmen isn’t sitting in a chair with a gun trained on the door, awaiting her ex husband turning up. Yet…

Contribute to the conversation...

Yay! You've decided to leave a comment. That's fantastic. Please keep in mind that comments are moderated by the guidelines laid out in our comment policy. Let's have a personal and meaningful conversation and thanks for stopping by!