“Orphan Black” Episode 507 Recap: Eye of the Storm

Hi and welcome to Denial Town where I refuse to admit that there are only three episodes of Orphan Black left and am going to carry on like my heart isn’t breaking.

Let’s do a clone check to start:

Helena is hiding out with a nice, tongue-less nun. Alison is on a retreat to find herself. Cosima and Charlotte are getting the hell out of dodge. Or the dodge out of hell, as the case may be. Rachel is losing her grip. And Sarah is probably missing her brother but mostly doing her best to protect her daughter.

So I’m pretty sure I was right in thinking we’re going to get a single-clone-themed episode for everyone, and this week it’s Rachel’s turn.

We open on the startling sight of Leekie with hair, and he has little Rachel Duncan with him. She recites things like ID tags to the DYAD board, picking her nails all the while. The board is impressed, and honestly I can’t tell if it’s because a young girl is rattling off science details with clear understanding, or if it’s because a clone is. Either way it makes me about as comfortable as it makes wee little Rachel.

Young Rachel looks uncomfortable

“This is fine.”

Present-day Rachel is sitting at the head of this same board, talking science at them and calling upon PT, who credits her for finding the “Eve” of their new experiment. And by Eve of course, she means Kira.

Kira, who is done with Auntie Rachel time, and would like to go home, but that’s not on Rachel’s agenda. She won’t even let Kira call Sarah before bed. Kira hasn’t lost sight of her hustle though, so she gives Rachel a friendship bracelet. In a moment that succeeded in making me feel worse for Rachel than I ever have before: She had a best friend in summer camp once, who she made friendship bracelets for! Kira asks if they’re still friends and Rachel’s unfeeling “no” stabbed me in the heart a bit, I won’t lie. After her parents faked their deaths, all nurturing went out the window. And it shows.

Rachel is told that Cosima’s boat was found drifting but Rachel knows better than to count her sestras out and tells them to continue looking for her as though she’s still alive.

Sarah hates all of this, by the way. She’s pacing around, furious Rachel won’t let her talk to her daughter, despite having been mostly compliant with all this testing nonsense lately. Mrs. S is even angrier though, since Kira was taken on her watch, and Sarah has to remind her of her own advice to not go in guns blazing.

Sarah looks distraught

Unless we run into PT. Then we can punch him.

Across town, Wizardface is leading Scott to the basement of the comic book shop and it’s because he wanted to surprise him because COSIMA IS HOME! Cure and all.

Cosima smiles at Scott

Now please don a bulletproof vest and maybe take another dose of the cure JFC

Charlotte is also there, being cute af. I’m so happy that sweet baby angel is safe.

Charlotte beams from her warm spot on the bed

Ready to spill some PTea.

Cosima Skypes Sarah to tell her about DYAD’s plans for Kira and how they only have about 24 hours to get her out of there before they’ll harvest her eggs for the new cloning experiment. Sarah says they need leverage, and Cosima suggests perhaps revealing that PT Westmoreland is a liar, liar, cult on fire.

Sarah smiles at her sestras

“Get it?”

Mrs. S doles out orders again; Felix and Adele are on the Neolution money trail, so Cosima and the boys are to find out who PT was before he was the mythical 170-year-old head of Revival.

Alison Skypes in form her retreat; she’s coming back from California tomorrow. I don’t know if pre-retreat Alison would have ever let us see her without full hair, makeup, and wardrobe, so maybe she’s a new person.

Sarah's screens shows Cosima and Alison and Ali is in a towel


Oh and Cosima has one more bit of news: Coady is on the island, which means probably Susan no longer is, in one way or another.

And sure enough, cut to Rachel arriving at the island and bringing flowers to her mother’s grave. Unsurprisingly, Ira is buried beside her, and whether he glitched to death or was helped along his way is anyone’s guess.

As she stands on her birth mother’s grave, the woman she thought had died when she was young, but who had just purposefully extracted herself from her daughter’s life, and who left her to be raised by men who pretended to be father figures without actually being father figures. Including PT, who went so far as to tell Rachel he considers her like a daughter.

PT takes Rachel to meet Coady, who says she’s looking forward to working with her and Kira, but also mentions Helena, which can’t end well, and I don’t mean for Helena. Rachel is told she’s going to be examined to check how the cure is doing and she looks less than pleased that this plan wasn’t cleared with her first. In fact, she’s so displeased that she has a flashback to when PT had her sign a waver saying she was free from the experiment, that she was no longer DYAD property, that she was no longer just 779H41.

But now, as she changes into her hospital gown to get ready for this surprise examination from this woman she just met, she sees her file up on the computer and there it is, clear as day: 779H41.

Coady comes in to examine her, calling the LEDA clones a baseline again, basically admitting to killing Susan, proving that she’s one of the ironic players in this game who is studying/trying to shape and create literal human beings and direct the evolution of the species, but has no humanity herself.

Rachel is reminded of an examination Leekie gave her when she was younger (when she started to lighten her hair, maybe to separate herself from some of the other subjects, but not before she went to full bleach, which maybe was born out of her desperate need to control everything; everything clean, crisp, in its place.) They’re doing a biopsy on her and Rachel knows enough to realize this has to do with a few other clones who are sick; Leekie even goes so far as to call it a disease.

Youngish Rachel is in a hospital gown and has bad hair

“Is this disease called Bad Wig Syndrome or?”

She’s still picking her nails when Leekie tells her that just because she’s aware of the experiment doesn’t exempt her from study, and that they’ll have more information as more clones get sick.

At Mrs. S’s house, it’s looking a bit like a conspiracy theorist convention, papers strewn about as they try to put the pieces together about Neolution, the DYAD board, anything, and stumble across a consulting firm a DYAD shell pays. Similarly but a little more modern with their clear boards, markers, and computers, Cosima and the boys are using college records to try to figure out who PT might have been before he was the man, the myth, the legend.

Cosima looks at the computer thoughtfully

This is neither crazy nor science but she’s still super cute.

Across town in the suburbs, Donnie cleans up the house for Alison’s returned. Her goofy happy slightly warbly theme plays in the background and the door swings open and our favorite neurotic soccer mom is—

Alison is home but her hair is totally different


She immediately starts talking about Kira like her hair isn’t short and black and purple until Donnie interrupts her. I can’t help but wonder if Donnie thought for a moment that it might not be Alison, knowing there are people with her literal same face running around out there. But no, it’s the same old Alison Hendrix, at least technically. She’s spent time learning how to be present and “live deep” which she has tattooed on her body and I’m sorry but sounds VERY DIRTY TO ME.

New Hair Alison beams

“You know, because you have thrust deep into life.”

In the Revival mansion, Rachel overhears PT questioning her conviction on the phone and when she pops in she sees him tuck away a weird looking tablet. She tells him she wants to choose her own physicians and schedule her own appointments and he agrees. She gives an update on Kira and swears she’s not attached to her and can be objective but when PT tests her by saying she wants Kira on the island, Rachel questions why this is necessary. Frankly even objectively this is a bad idea, because she even later calls Sarah the “nuisance clone” and Mrs. S hasn’t exactly been staying out of their way, so why would they want to risk that by breaking their agreement? But PT insists, again probably just to see if Rachel will do it. So Rachel concedes and says, “You know best,” as a nod to but potentially a mockery of his perceived role as a parent to her.

In the basement of this very mansion, Coady is meeting with long lost Mark, who is here for a cure, because he doesn’t want to glitch like his brothers. So of course she’s blackmailing him, because she’s about as good a mother figure as any of Rachel’s supposed fathers.

What Coady wants in exchange for giving Mark the cure is Helena, and unfortunately it seems Mark can deliver…with a little help.

Gracie looms over Helena's bed like Chuckie's bride

“Surprise, bitch.”

When PT is gone, Rachel sneaks back into his office and steals the tablet and turns it on. What she sees is an endless loop of the tablet, like when you stand in a hotel bathroom vestibule and there’s a mirror in front of you and behind you and there’s just you forever and ever until your brain hurts and you have a mini existential crisis. But this is worse because what Rachel realizes is that the reason she’s seeing this effect on the tablet is because her synthetic eyeball is a fucking CAMERA.

Talk about a violation of one’s body, privacy, and entire life.

When PT comes back she doesn’t flinch or reveal that she knows anything or confront him at all, she just says goodbye.

We’re given another flashback now, and I think it’s probably one of the more pivotal turning point moments in Rachel’s life: she killed a clone so they could autopsy her and learn more about the disease.

Rachel stands over the dead clone's body talking to Leekie

“But did she DIE—oh, yes, no I see how that argument doesn’t work here.”

She sees her as a subject in an experiment, and even Leekie is a little horrified; unlike Rachel, he knows more about her than her call number. And actually interestingly, after Leekie calls the deceased clone creative, Rachel calls her homeless and says her mother was a drunk and in THE SAME BREATH says she’s objective. Leekie doesn’t help things by asking her literally, “What are you?” as if she hadn’t been questioning her own humanity since the day she learned her ID number.

Rachel returns to DYAD (annoyingly fast, considering how long Sarah and Cosima were stuck), and Kira tries to chat with her but Rachel isn’t having it this time. She does allow her to call her mother though, but she tells Frontenac to make sure he watches them closely.

Also happening at this time is possibly the cruelest death of the season. Alison murdered her craft room! She even throws away the glue gun she used to torture Donnie in the first season! (Which he flinches when he sees, in a subtly hilarious moment.) She’s talking like that one weird music teacher you had for like 3/4ths of sixth grade who you sometimes wonder if you made up, saying she has to face her shadow self or it will manifest into bad habits, and that she’s now going to jam on her keyboard and follow the music and not tell Donnie what to do anymore.

Alison is at the keyboard looking up at Donnie

“I’ve also ordered a glockenspiel off Amazon.”

It’s all very strange.

Kira, smart little cookie she is, tells Sarah a story using the code words they made up, complete with drawings of Elephant Rachel stepping on Mouse Kira’s tail and telling her she has to go to Wonderland. Sarah uses this same metaphor to comfort her daughter, telling her they’ll be together to write their own ending soon.

Sarah skypes with Kira

“It’s just, you could have fit more information in there if it didn’t rhyme.”

When she hangs up, Sarah tells Mrs. S that the story means they’re taking Kira to the island, and she knows they’re running out of time.

Sarah tries so hard not to cry


Rachel, armed with the knowledge that PT can see everything she can see, takes some gin and a martini glass and goes into the Room of Erised, watching that one memory of her and the Duncans rolling around in the leaves over and over and over. PT calls to check in, and Rachel knows for sure that his promise she was monitor-free was the opposite of true; she is the most monitored now. She has a resignation in her voice and God it’s not even like she snapped as much as she…deflated. It’s kind of heartbreaking.

Kira comes in and asks, “Who hurt you?” and Rachel looks her square in the eye and tells her, “All of them.”

Rachel tells Frontenac that she’ll be the last face Kira sees before she leaves DYAD, whether for the control or because she knows it will be a small comfort to Kira, who knows. Then PT comes on the screen to talk to Kira for a bit.

Back down the rabbit hole, Cosima and the boys finally find PT’s original identity.

Cosima looks surprised at her computer

PT killed Jenny?!

Sarah emails it to Rachel, who immediately calls her to tell her that no one is going to listen to her if she spreads this information. Out loud she makes it sound like she doesn’t believe it, and what we know that Sarah doesn’t is that PT can hear her. Sarah tries to get to her by reminding her PT took her family from her and used her as an experiment, but what we know that Sarah doesn’t is that she is consumed by this knowledge and doesn’t need reminding.

So it’s with tears in her eyes that she hangs up on her sestra.

Sarah is pleading to Rachel on the phone

“I can’t go out. *cough* I’m sick.”

Rachel's eyes are filled with tears while she's on the phone

“Boo, you whore.”

Rachel goes to give Kira her sedative juice and they have a conversation; Rachel says she doesn’t remember how she felt at Kira’s age but eventually got used to being studied. A combination of Rachel’s gin intake and mental breakdown causes her to hallucinate her child self and she asks the little girl why she doesn’t run. But the little Rachel answers that she has nowhere to go.

PT watches as Rachel forces Kira to drink the OJ sedative and hears as Rachel gives Frontenac the hit on Sarah and Mrs. S and tells him not to hesitate. But as soon as he’s gone, she focuses her eyes on her necklace spinning while she also holds her phone in her good eye’s periphery and sends a text message.

Turns out that message was for Art, and he busts in to warn Sarah, and GUYS I HAVE SUCCESSFULLY MOSTLY HATED RACHEL ALL THIS TIME WHY DO I WANT TO HOLD HER NOW.

Rachel goes to her meditation spot and closes her eyes, which PT would know is not unusual these days, and then she slips on her eye patch and goes to wheel Kira out of her room.

Frontenac finds an empty house when he goes to kill Sarah so PT starts pushing images into Rachel’s eyeball. But her job is almost done now, because Art, Sarah and Mrs. S are there and they take Kira from her. As the elevator closes and they leave her behind, Mrs. S mouths a “thank you” to her, but no one even asked her if she wanted to come.

The elevator doors close on Rachel


Rachel emails the information Cosima found to the board, then pours herself some more alcohol, making sure her eye is getting a good long look before she takes a good long swig.

Rachel finishes off the gin in her martini glass

I just feel like not using olives was torturing herself for no reason.

When the glass is empty, she smashes it, leaving only the stem behind. And then, my friends, she SHOVES IT INTO HER EYEBALL. When I watched this episode the first time I was just wailing “nooOOooo” like some kind of Moaning Myrtle. Then I watched this episode with my parents, and decided to watch them instead of this scene again, and it was pretty hilarious. My mother fully covered her eyes and shouted, “THERE’S GOT TO BE AN EASIER WAY!” and even my dad, who laughed with almost a sick delight when he realized she was going to poke her eye out, started to make grossed out noises and eventually nervously exclaimed, “She’s going to POP IT OUT.”

And reader, she did. She had to sever the tendon and everything. It was awful. Then blood was just POURING out of her eye socket. But PT can’t see what she can see anymore. She might die from this injury, but this was her choice, her decision.

I was going to show you guys pictures from the “next week on” that I got on my screener but then when I watched it live it said it the episode was TOO INTENSE to show any of it so now I’m stressed out and I’m afraid the short clip I saw was a decoy and EVERYONE’S GOING TO DIE.

Before you go! Autostraddle runs on the reader support of our AF+ Members. If this article meant something to you today — if it informed you or made you smile or feel seen, will you consider joining AF and supporting the people who make this queer media site possible?

Join AF+!

Valerie Anne

Just a TV-loving, Twitter-addicted nerd who loves reading, watching, and writing about stories. One part Kara Danvers, two parts Waverly Earp, a dash of Cosima and an extra helping of my own brand of weirdo.

Valerie has written 550 articles for us.


  1. I flat-out refused to watch the eyeball scene and hid under my duvet until it was over!

    But yeah…Rachel is such a compelling character. I can’t believe I can still have compassion for her after everything she’s done, but those flashbacks to her little self and the “where would I go?’ straight up broke my heart.

  2. Dare I say I liked this episode even better than Cosima’s?? Rachel has never been one of my favorites either, but she felt so human and vulnerable this week.

    And I knew better than to even try to watch the last scene. I would never play myself like that lol.

    (Also unrelated but humbling requesting a space to vent about Game of Thrones’ latest skulduggery.)

  3. 1. I didn’t close my eyes but I tried to cover my screen with my phone but I still felt….eeekk LOL
    2. How cute is little Rachel’s (the actress playing Charlotte) British accent, eh? LOL
    3. Scott’s sigh of relief and “You’re home” to Cosima is all of us, warmed my heart
    4. I applaud Rachel’s texting capabilities, I have 2 eyes and I wear glasses and I still have minor typos when I text and I have the phone in front of me.
    5. I was hoping Ira was still kinda alive but knew he was dying but seeing he was buried still kinda shocked me?
    6. Kira crying saying she misses her Mum broke my heart like I know these 2 monkeys kind of have a rough relationship but that scene reminded me that she’s still just a kid who needs her Mother
    7. Alison coming back would have been more funnier if Felix was there, too LOL
    8. Can’t wait for next episode!!!! AAAHH!

  4. The short clip also was on amazon prime and iTunes!! If it was a party scene that you saw, anyway… my bet is on a hallucination of some sort because that looked altogether too peaceful and happy for a clip where there’s still 3 episodes left

  5. I don’t think Ira is dead!! On this show, if I don’t see a body then I don’t believe they’re dead. Fool me once, etc.
    Since her dad killed himself in front of her (if I remember right?) Rachel’s backstory has been probably one of the most heartbreaking to me. But this episode just made that so much more sad.

  6. Next weeks promo is so amazing that it scares me. I’m sure something terrible is going to happen.

  7. Rachel is a terrible person (the murder of Miriam Johnson, plus all the Helsinki clones, and MK, not to mention that one time she raped Paul) but good GOD she is a fascinating, fantastic character to watch. This was easily the best episode of the season. I LOVED getting this insight into Rachel’s head and history. I’ve complained more than once over the years that Rachel’s motivations have been a mystery to me – her objectives seem to change from episode to episode, season to season, depending on what the plot needs from her at the time. But this episode FINALLY gave us her character’s thesis statement that has been missing since she was first introduced.

    As I said, Rachel is a terrible person. But the whole point of the Leda experiment, as we learn in this episode, is “understanding the human genome and the environmental impact on genes is the holy grail of life extension.” Rachel is a terrible person because she was raised to be a terrible person, just as Helena was raised to be an assassin, and Cosima was raised to be a scientist, and Sarah was raised to be a hustler. Nurture over nature. Rachel is a terrible person, but she is a product of her environment. It’s not entirely her fault, and this episode, like Helena back in season one, is her finally breaking free of the environment that raised her.

    I don’t think Rachel can truly ever be redeemed, not in the way Helena has been. I don’t think I could stomach seeing her sit down to dinner at Bubbles with the rest of the sestras, not after MK. But I would really, really love it if in the end, she sacrificed herself for the rest of the Leda clones. I think that would be a very fitting ending for her.

    • IDK she doesn’t have to die.

      I can see Kira forgiving her, and insisting that she be allowed to visit “auntie Rachel” in a happily ever after future, and Rachel and Sarah would, like, tolerate each other for the sake of Kira.

      • I think the Laws of Television are going to require that at least one clone dies in the final episodes, and I would really rather it be Rachel than any of the others.

        • No no no just this once I want the 9th Doctor to come out at the end of the finale shouting happily “JUST THIS ONCE. EVERYBODY LIVES!”

    • The thing this episode did for me, and I don’t want to put words into your mouth but it sounds like it might have done for you too, is make me understand her properly. I can never truly sympathise with her, although she was a victim of abuse just as much as Helena was, albeit in a more insidious fashion, Rachel seemed to take the lesson that the only way out to become an abuser herself.

      But the episode made me understand that and see behind the facade enough that it became clear what made her tick, and showed there’s still a bit of basic humanity, that she could choose a different future for Kira than the future she’d had.

      I think a ‘turned’ Rachel will be a truly dangerous thing – she knows all their darkest secrets, all their levers of power and she hasn’t really got anything left to lose any more. If I was John not-really-Westmoreland, I’d be sending assassins after her right away.

  8. I don’t know why but I feel like Rachel and S will die before finale. I agree, I think the show is telling us nurture over nature since pilot. Sarah would have been Rachel if Susan had her way.

    I always wondered how Rachel turned into corporate raised clone from happy child with her parents. I’m glad we finally got to see it (just like I always wondered what happened between Cosima and Delphine between Season 1 episode 10 and Season 2 Episode 1 and how they got there. I’m glad for it too.)

    But I also wonder how Cosima and Beth met, how Cosima reacted to whole clone thing (I’m sure she was adorably geeky), Cosima’s life in “San Fran”, Mika’s life in Helsinki and her relationship with Niki, Sarah’s life as a hustler… Well pretty much everything.

    • PS: I don’t need to see Sarah’s abusive relationship with Vic though.

      And speaking of Vic, where is Cal? I know he’s too busy being every other character in ASOIAF universe but they could mention him.

      • Yeah it’s super weird that Cal is massively absent from all the shit that’s happening in his DAUGHTER. Ugh

  9. I loved this episode so much. Rachel really broke my heart this week.

    I really like Mark and Gracie so I hope the show isn’t gonna make me hate them by having them turn on Helena and her babies :/

  10. This was honestly one of the best episodes of Orphan Black and EVERYTHING I’ve been waiting for. They’ve finally tied up all of the loose ends with Rachel and while I’ve been banging on about wanting it for so long, I’m glad they waited until they did to provide us with such an in-depth look at her.

    Did you guys know this episode was the first TV episode ever for writer Renée St. Cyr? Unbelievable!

  11. “PT killed Jenny” had me howling with laughter, at work, and I got some looks. Yes I should be working.

    I have the worst, worst, WORST feeling. Listen, I’ve been saying this in the comments every damn week, but I’m having trouble dealing. I liken Rachel to Snape (without knowing her fate the next three episodes), who I refuse to like even though I accept him.

    God damn, how does this show leave me so emotionally unsound every week.

    • I think the Snape comparison is a good one. Bad people can do good, brave, and selfless things. As I said above, I actually really hope Rachel gets a Snape-type ending. I don’t think she can be totally redeemed, but I think dying to protect the other clones would be a good ending for her.

  12. Fantastic episode (and recap) again… And yes, that eyeball scene was– gory to say the least. If Rachel survives this, PT would have to hide away on the moon, as I don’t think Rachel would let him off the hook. Just thinking of how she ended Evie Cho, but then again Rachel was still believing in Dyad / Neolution’s terrible vision for mankind (which has always been built on a big fat lie). I wonder if she still does now, or if she lost all purpose in life again. She may want to seize control of the overall operation though…

    Ugh, 3 more episodes, and it’s not going to be pretty.

  13. If PT killed Jenny, it makes up for at least 70% of his past sins in my opinion.

    To this week’s murdered clone: I’m glad you enabled us to behold Tatiana Maslany with a blue mohawk. May you rest in peace.

Comments are closed.