People die. Characters die. This is perhaps life’s most unfortunate fact: that people will die and leave the rest of us behind. It’s incredibly rare that any dramatic television series lasting over three seasons will never kill a main or recurring character, and all those deaths have driven a stake through the heart of fandom: Joyce on Buffy, Lady Sybil on Downton Abby, Charlie on Lost, Ned Stark on Game of Thrones, Jen on Dawson’s Creek, Nate on Six Feet Under — but when the person who dies is a lesbian or bisexual character, queer fandom takes it pretty hard.
The history of lesbian representation on television is rocky — in the beginning, we seemed exclusively relegated to roles that saw us getting killed/attacked or doing the killing/attacking. And until the last five or so years, lesbian and bisexual characters seemed entirely unable to date an actual woman or stay alive for more than three episodes, let alone an entire run, of a show. Gay and lesbian characters are so often murdered on television that we have our very own trope: Bury Your Gays. We comprise such a teeny-tiny fraction of characters on television to begin with that killing us off so haphazardly feels especially cruel.
Not every death listed below was wholly uncalled for. In many genres, like soap operas and shows about vampires, zombies, criminals, or games of thrones, characters are killed on the reg. That’s a different trope — Anyone Can Die. Furthermore, shows composed entirely of queer characters will inevitably kill one. But regardless, they still add to the body count weighing down our history of misrepresentation.
And, due to the recent untimely death of Lexa on The 100, this week seemed like a good one to count down everybody we have lost over the years.
This list contains every television death of an OPENLY lesbian or bisexual or queer female character on a television show. With a handful of exceptions, these are all characters who appeared for more than one episode. The exceptions were deemed exceptional because something about the characterization still fits in with the Bury Your Gays trope. Victims-of-the-week from crime procedurals (Law & Order, Cold Case, CSI, Criminal Minds or older shows) or patients-of-the-week from hospital dramas (Chicago Hope, E.R.), aren’t on this list, as that is an entirely different kind of list, but recurring characters from those shows are on this list. Nor is subtext on this list, because we’re not gonna give Xena showrunners Queer Character Credit for a character they refused to make openly queer when she was really so obviously queer. You know? [ETA: Okay, I’ve added Xena after doing further research and because if one more commenter takes up space on this thread — a thread I’m using to find more characters to add, and also to engage with thoughtful/funny readers who have opinions and feelings — to tell me that I “forgot” Xena without reading this introduction, I will become the 200th dead lesbian and the cause of death will be “Walked off a cliff with a commenter in her arms. Murder-suicide.” But Xena will be the one and only inclusion based on subtext.] Also, although I’ve done tons of research, I haven’t personally seen all of these shows, so mistakes may very well exist, and feel free to politely inform me of them in the comments, or tell me about characters I may have missed — it’s especially helpful if you can tell me the cause of death and the year.
Unsure if this needs to be said but… SPOILER ALERT.
Every Regular or Recurring Lesbian or Bisexual Female Character Killed On Television
Julie, Executive Suite (1976)
Cause of death: Hit by a car. Her love interest had just walked into traffic after realizing her lesbianism and Julie was chasing her.
Franky Doyle, Prisoner: Cell Block H (1980)
Cause of death: Shot by a police officer after escaping from prison
Sharon Gilmour, Prisoner: Cell Block H (1980)
Cause of death: Pushed down the stairs by a corrections officer
Karen O’Malley, Casualty (1987)
Cause of death: Head Injury
Cecília, Vale Tudo (1988)
Cause of death: Car Accident
Cicely, Northern Exposure (1992)
Cause of death: Shot by a gunman employed by the town’s evil overlord who doesn’t want to let the lesbians change his town. The shot was intended for her girlfriend Roslyn, but Cicely, who was already sick, blocked the bullet and died in Roslyn’s arms, thus magically healing the town’s long-simmering feuds and leading them to re-name the town “Cicely.”
Talia Winters, Babylon 5 (1995)
Cause of death: Activated a sleeper personality that wiped out her actual personality, effectively killing her
Beth Jordache, Brookside (1995)
Cause of death: Genetic heart condition, died in prison
Susan Ross, Seinfeld (1996)
Cause of death: Toxic envelope glue
Naomi “Tracy” Richards, Band of Gold (1996)
Cause of death: Stabbed herself
Lucy, The Fortunes and Misfortunes of Moll Flanders (1996)
Cause of death: Caught thieving and hanged
Kathy, NYPD Blue (1997)
Cause of death: Shot by a hit man hired by her girlfriend Abby’s ex, who wanted to get rid of Kathy so she could get back together with Abby. Abby was pregnant at the time.
Sondra Westwood, Pacific Drive (1997)
Cause of death: Murdered by a serial killer
Jadzia Dax, Star Trek: Deep Space Nine (1998)
Cause of death: Blasted by an alien-possessed alien
Sonia Besirky, Lindenstraße (1998)
Cause of death: Drug overdose from medication given to her by her ex-lover’s husband
Leila and Rafaela, Torre de Babel (1998)
Cause of death: Explosion in a shopping mall
Susanne Teubner, Hinter Gittern (1999)
Cause of death: Shot during a bank robbery (she was a customer)
Shaz Wiley, Bad Girls (2000)
Cause of death: Bomb, died in resulting fire
Laura Hall, Shortland Street (2000)
Cause of death: Heart attack
Diamond, Dark Angel (2001)
Cause of death: Used as a lab rat for research that killed her
Xena, Xena the Warrior Princess (2001)
Cause of death: Beheaded
Beate “Bea” Hansen, Hinter Gittern (2001)
Cause of death: Injuries from an explosion
Jule Neumann, Hinter Gittern (2001)
Cause of death: Suicide
Frankie Stone, All My Children (2001)
Cause of death: Murder Mystery!
Bridgit, 24 (2001)
Cause of death: Shot by a man in front of her girlfriend
Tara Maclay, Buffy the Vampire Slayer (2002)
Cause of death: Shot in the heart by a stray bullet
Kelly Hurst, Family Affairs (2002)
Cause of death: Pushed down the stairs by her lover’s husband
Megan Hartnoll, At Home With The Braithwaites (2003)
Cause of death: Electrocuted in the bathtub
Juliet Becker, The Bill (2003)
Cause of death: Stabbed
Tina Greer, Smallville (2003)
Cause of death: Impaled through the chest on a large piece of wood during a fight with a male character
Sandy Lopez, E.R. (2004)
Cause of death: Injuries sustained from fighting a fire in an abandoned warehouse
Al Mackenzie, Bad Girls (2004)
Cause of death: Poisoned
Hanna Novak, Verbotene Liebe (2004)
Cause of death: Stroke, died in her girlfriend’s arms
Ines Führbringer, Hinter Gittern (2004)
Cause of death: Throat slit, died in girlfriend’s arms
Thelma Bates, Hex (2004)
Cause of death: Murdered by a demon
Flora, Deadwood (2004)
Cause of death: Beaten by a man who then forced a woman to shoot her with his gun
Brenda Castillo, Charmed (2004)
Cause of death: Stabbed with a cursed blade by a man, causing her to rapidly age and then die
Tosha, The Wire (2004)
Cause of death: Shot during a heist gone wrong
Marissa Cooper, The O.C. (2005)
Cause of death: Car crash after being driven off the road by her drunk ex-boyfriend
Servilla, Rome (2005)
Cause of death: Stabs herself in front of her rival house, inhabited by the mother of her lover
Dusty, Queer As Folk (2005)
Cause of death: At a benefit at a gay club when a bomb went off
Dana Fairbanks, The L Word (2006)
Cause of death: Breast cancer
Helena Cain, Battlestar Galactica (2006)
Cause of death: Shot by her ex-lady-lover
Manuela Wellmann, Hinter Gittern (2006)
Cause of death: Stabbed, died in girlfriend’s arms
Maya Robertson, Hex (2006)
Cause of death: Hit by a car
Natalie, Bad Girls (2006)
Cause of death: Bludgeoned to death with a brick
Gina Inviere/#6, Battlestar Galactica (2006)
Cause of death: Set off a nuclear weapon
Eve Jacobson/Zoe McAllister, Home & Away (2006)
Cause of death: Inside a building when it was blown up
Van, Dante’s Cove (2006)
Cause of Death: Killed by the Shadows
Angie Morton, Stritctly Confidential (2006)
Cause of death: Suicide. Jumped off a building.
Pages: 1 2 3 4 See entire article on one page
Rachel Posner reminds me of Evan Rachel Wood. (Canonically, Evan’s character in Once and Again is alive.)
I know, they look so much alike!
I’m still very, very angry about Tara. Just sayin’.
ME TOO
Weirdly seeing her on there brought a tear to my eye! Tara’s death was just awful.
Being a lesbian or bisexual woman called Tara seems to give you particular bad luck – either dying, or having your girlfriend die.
Did I miss something? I thought Helena Cain was killed by a Six? I don’t remember anything about her digging chicks?
In the Pegasus spinoff/TV movie Razor, the Six who kills Cain is her girlfriend.
It was revealed in the TV movie “Battlestar Galactica: Razor” that she had an affair with a Six who posed as an engineer on the Pegasus.
The Six in question was Gina, who worked as a network analyst on Pegasus until she was discovered to be a Cylon. And also was intimately involved with Cain.
Can I say that I just about fainted when Michelle Forbes showed up on Orphan Black? She has One Of Those Voices, the kind that slays me every time.
She was killed by a version of Six named Gina. BSG Razor details their relationship more than the show did.
In the flashback movie you find out that Helena and Gina (the Six in question) were dating.
I had to go back and rewatch those episodes. I remembered why I was glad she was killed.
She was shot by a Six, Gina Inviere. It’s revealed through flashbacks (in Razor, I think?) that the two had been lovers before Cain discovered Gina was a Cylon.
Whoops, didn’t see all these existing replies.
Me neither!
She was killed by the Six she had fallen in love with, who became a prisoner when Helena found out she was a Cylon.
It was a really a “blink and you’ll miss it” relationship. The Six, Gina, was in a relationship with Cain. It was mentioned in Razor.
The 6 that killed her was her lover before the Cylon attack and until they discovered she was a Cylon. Their romance was a small plot in the Razor movie/super long episode.
That Six (Gina Inviere) was her lover. The beginning of their romance was shown on the movie “Battlestar Galactica, Razor”. That’s why, when her treason was discovered, she was so brutal allowing the constant rape and torture of that Six.
She did. She had an r-ship with a six who betrayed her and so she allowed her crew to gang-rape the six. This was part of what made her bitter and aweful.
That Six, Gina, was in a relationship with Cain. It was in the episode about the Pegasus, the Razor. I don’t know if this was a special episode that wasn’t shown with the original television showings or not, though. Gaeta was in a relationship with both an Eight and Hoshi, but you wouldn’t know that unless you saw the webisodes.
Anyway, the Razor is on BSG on Netflix.
It was revealed in Battlestar Galactica Razor that Admiral Cain was seeing Six before they new she was Cylon.
Her and Gina were together when the colonies were nuked. When Cain realized that Gina was a Cylon and she had been sleeping with the enemy, she locked her up, let her be tortured and raped repeatedly. When Gina got free she shot and killed Cain. I think it’s more explained in Razor. If I’m not mistaken it was a movie that came out in between season 3 and 4 and explored two timelines, one from the start of the series meeting up with a few episodes from S2 I think.
Didn’t see the many responses until my comment posted.
You must not have watched the movie “Razor”. It came out between seasons 2 and 3 and focused on Battlestar Pegasus prior to finding the Galactica.
You have to watch Galactica – Razor tv movie. There are flashblacks where you’ll see Cain and Gina (6) are together.
The Six who killed her was her former lover. Cain had her caged when she found out she was a cylon
There was an episode where it showed what happened to the Pegasus in the months following the Cylon attack, During this time there was in fact a ‘6’ on board referred to as Gina. Helena and Gina developed a relationship that is subtly shown…when it was discovered Gina was a cylon Helena locked her in a cell allowing her to be tortured and abused, probably out of spite, Gina is the traumatized ‘6’ that Gayus later helps, she subsequently gets freed during when there was a near mutiny and shoots Helena, This same ‘6’, Gina, goes onto get her hands on a nuke and destroys a civilian ship :D #battlestarnerd!!
The story-line about her digging chicks was in the Mini-Movie Razor. Pretty good. The relationship was before the attack by the Cylons.
Some of these are really reaching. I seem to recall a romantic relationship between Cain and the Six (who is also listed here) was implied, but that’s all it was.
D’anna Biers, when did we see her being into girls? Or Snoop from The Wire? Or Claire Bennet? Is my memory really that rusty?
The relationship between Cain and Gina was not implied, it was a small plot line to be sure, but it was definitely there in Razor. Their relationship was used to explain why Cain became so ruthless, why she let her men do those horrible things to Gina and why Gina said what she did before she pulled the trigger.
D’anna Biers/3 had a relationship with both Caprica Six and Baltar when Baltar was captive on the Basestar after New Caprica.
Was the relationship d’eanna had real with baltar or was it one of baltars hallucinations? Its been so long since ive seen the show so my memorys rusty but i dont recall that subplot in the series.
Regaring Claire Bennet, in the actual Heroes-show we never got an answer regarding whether she was bi/fluid or not. Gretchen kissed her, but when she later asked Claire whether she felt something Claire replied that she didn’t know. And within the Heroes show, the possibility of a romance between them were never brought up again, they just stayed roommates and close friends.
In an eBook called “Save the Cheerleader, Destroy the World” that are supposed to sum up the events between Heroes and Heroes Reborn for Claire, this is what the Heroes-wiki says about Claire and Gretchen: “On December 14, 2010, a picture of Gretchen and Claire at Arlington University appears on the cover of a magazine with the title “Indestructible Girl in Love Nest with Co-Ed”. Overwhelmed and humiliated, Gretchen sends Claire a text saying that she never wants to see her again. Claire sends her around 30 texts begging her to reply, but she does not. Claire finally gives up trying to contact Gretchen sometime in April 2011.”
So apparantly, they actually did become a couple after Heroes the show ended, but don’t ask me why Gretchen got so angry over that becoming public, since Gretchen on the show most certainly wasn’t closeted.
And then Claire is presumed dead in Heroes Reborn, although there were some theories that she wasn’t dead at all, but just that her father were lead to believe that she was. However, since Heroes Reborn is cancelled, those theories are obsolete by now.
This is broken down into 3 separate scenes.. (1) Cain has regular meetings with Gina Inviere (aka Six), a civilian contractor working for the Colonial Ministry of Defense. The two eventually become “romantically involved”. (2) Then Cain is deeply stung by Inviere’s betrayal, her feelings toward her erstwhile “lover” turned into hatred and scorn. (3) Cain returns to her quarters and is surprised to find Gina Inviere (Six) who escaped her cell,waiting for her. After a tense confrontation, Gina (Six) kills Cain with a shot to the head.
This is broken down into 3 separate scenes.. (1) Cain has regular meetings with Gina Inviere (aka Six), a civilian contractor working for the Colonial Ministry of Defense. The two eventually become “romantically involved”. (2) Then Cain is deeply stung by Inviere’s betrayal, her feelings toward her erstwhile “lover” turned into hatred and scorn. (3) Cain returns to her quarters and is surprised to find Gina Inviere (Six) who escaped her cell,waiting for her. After a tense confrontation, Gina (Six) kills Cain with a shot to the head.
Uh, yeah, that Six and Cain were lovers before Cain found out she was a Cyclon.
She was her lover.
Watch the episodes with the Pegasus, and the movie Razor. The Six who shot her was her lover.
She and the Six (in her persona of Gina Inviere) were lovers which is why Cain allowed her to be treated so badly as a prisoner.
Honestly, there are a lot of characters on this list where it was never mentioned that they were bisexuals or lesbians
Cain’s romance with a Six was in the Battlestar Galactica: Razor movie. It’s been explained in the comments a bunch of times already, if only people would backread before asking repeat questions….
Cain was killed by the Gina Inviere 6 (who also makes an appearance on the list). Before Inviere was revealed to be Cylon, she was a lover of Cain’s.
Oh,man half these shows I stopped watching before characters died and I am so happy i did.
under the dome is such a mysoginistic mess, i couldn’t stand it.
Yes, exactly! A lot of these shows were doing our community a disservice even before they killed the bi & lesbian characters off–and I’d love to see that quantified too.
Okay, Jenny Shechter’s description of “Murdered by Ilene Chaiken” made me giggle, just a little.
Luckily for me no one was in the store when I saw that cause I was laughing pretty hard that I nearly fell out of my seat. lol
i was like “same.”
I mean I’m pretty sure 90% of the lesbian population was begging for it to happen. And to be fair, on a show made up of primarily lesbian characters, to kill one of them off doesn’t feel as wrong as to kill off the token lesbian on any other show.
Haha. I think you they should change Lexa’s cause of death to “killed by JRat” . Just seems more accurate to me. Haha
Same, I was like wait we don’t even know what killed her but than I read that and I was like yeah ok that’s perfect
I laughed out loud when I read it too!
Circa 2002, Family Affairs – Kelly Hurst. Accidentally pushed down the stairs by the husband of her lover (and father of her surrogate baby, long story).
added, thank you!
Xena is missing from this list
subtext doesn’t count
they litterally kissed ??? On top of being soulmates and all the jazz ?
I feel excluding it is uncalled for given the people behind the show have stated how hard the network was cracking down on them about not making it a ~gay thing before the first season was even filmed and all the cast and creators have said they were bi and totally together. But hey go ahead and be rude about a show that was just as important to lots of people as the 100 was and also killed a wlw
she’s there…..
She’s there.
Xena is just below Diamond from Dark Angel from 2001.
Xena is listed. The writer says she was beheaded.
OH MY GOD read the introduction to an article and think about the comments before you decide to correct people.
Notice how in this VERY comment thread Riese (who wrote the article) says “subtext doesn’t count”? That is because Xena was not originally on the list, she was added later AFTER all the comments/discussion about her absence, as explained in the ETA in the introduction.
no she is not!
Well, looks like my decision to quit House of Cards after season two was entirely justified. Thanks for giving me that closure.
SAME.
THIS ARTICLE REALLY GOES THERE SHOUT OUT TO YOU RIESE
THANK YOU ERIN
You forgot Xena…
Xena was only ever “confirmed” gay by Lucy Lawless and well after the show’s end. There was no confirmation in the show or by the show’s writers or showrunner.
I thought the showrunner and writers DID confirm after the show ended?
Or not and
I don’t think so, and even if they said that, they never proved it in-show. :(
I just remember seeing something with a bunch of quotes from people involved who said Xena and Gabrielle were a couple.
They all but said it and they made it clear they were soulmates lol.
Although they had to play a lot with subtext that became very maintext in the later seasons they hugged, kissed and said I love you more than any other couple… Plus the soulmates concept was a pretty core concept of the show.
And a lot of the people that did the show confirmed their relationship, directors, writers and actors (Liz Friedman, Steven Sears, Lucy Lawles, Renee O’Connor, Kevin Smith, Katherine Fugate, etc).
Well, they did hire a slashfic author to be an official writer.
I saw that Xena was just below Diamond from Dark Angel from 2001.
Tamsin. <3. I've decided I'm in charge of canon there and she's doing swell.
#TamsinLives! And I’m all for #CopDoc :)
…and then they ate spaghetti.
Damn, should have realized the extremely obvious: SPOILER ALERTS! Catching up on Orphan Black is gonna be *rough*.
I’ve been seen Delphine on all these lists but I *refuse* to believe she actually belongs. Spoiler alert kind of, since you’ve already been spoiled: the survivable gut-shot happens in the waning moments of the S3 finale and we have NOT seen a body or confirmed she’s dead. I am holding out hope Fawcett and Mason are having their giggle and actually subverting the trope and she survives.
Delphine is shot in the season finale – we’re meant to assume she’s dead but she may not be!
My condolences–I was spoiled for that particular item before it happened too, and I HATE being spoiled for that show. (Though if you love the character I do think the episode is well-worth watching for her arc.)
Delphine was found to be alive a few weeks ago. At least there is someone we can remove from this heartbreaking list.
thank you for this. autostraddle and afterellen have been my fave go to sites for all things queer media and life….stuff. i felt so betrayed after reading afterellen’s recap to see them try to justify this bogus storyline of the 100 and then double down and have the show runner try to fix his mess on their site. you’re now my only source for queer content and i’d like you to know how much i cherish this site.
i would also like to cheer the 100 fandom, their response has gotten a lot of notice and i hope that anybody hoping to write/ produce queer characters will have taken this message to heart. we are a fierce minority and we can fuck yo shit up
My feelings exactly.
You know, that AE’s recap was a huge disappointment, but then they decide to add that piece of crap podcast?!!! I was raging mad. You say that there wasn’t any queerbaiting? That we should be happy because we still have Clarke? Are you kidding me?
The only good thing about this, and the thing that made me happy, is that you couldn’t find a positive comment on that podcast.
all i remember thinking is, whose interests are you serving right now? the only queer people ive seen defend the show are people who benefit from being close to the show runner and such pandering to harm being committed against ones own community, i have no time for it
The response from the feminist internet in general other than autostraddle has been extremely disappointing.
I couldn’t believe it when I read the AE article. I just felt so betrayed by it. The other day the mary sue also ran an article defending the shit show. Almost no major sites seem to get it.
Yeah, I feel you. Afterellen and autostraddle are my lesbian media guide and I always look up to it. But I’m pretty devastated that afterellen kinda try to justify it in a way. It sucks that I feel like they were holding back with what they truly feels. I don’t even know if this makes sense.
I was thinking, too: Where’s Xena? But it was not canon, after all. Still angry about Dana, sad about Tamsin and not sure about Jenny.
Xena is a lesbian icon, it is a show that pushed a lot of boundaries in TV… saying that their relationship was not canon is like ignoring 90% of the show. Specially with heavy maintext episodes like the Nordic trilogy or even the final that it’s like their big coming out party regardless of Xena’s death.
Cast, writers and directors confirmed their relationship. It was a show that ended on 2001 and that did the best they could with the boundaries they had, they even had planned a big Musical Sappho episode with a kiss between Xena and Gabrielle that never saw the light…
Oh, yes, she IS a lesbian icon and I treasure the episodes you mentioned. And they hired Melissa Good as a writer, after all :) I honestly think, too, that TBTB did the best they could back tuen, but I would still consider it subtext, albeit on the heavy site of it. Perhaps “not canon” wasn’t worded very well (no native speaker here).
I saw that Xena was just below Diamond from Dark Angel from 2001.
But you missed the ETA in the intro that explains she was added to the list after it was first posted.
Which is why you see so many comments about Xena’s absence – the comments were from before she was on the list.
Wow. And this is just the women. And just TV. I’m struck by the violent manner of death for so many of these characters. I really want to dig deeper here and compare this with the deaths of straight characters. I wonder if variables like ‘time after romantic revelation/encounter’ or ‘manner of death’ would further highlight the poor treatment of LGBT characters.
Especially since Lexa was strikingly similar to Tara – they’d both JUST had sex for the first time/first time after a break with their love interest and were hit by a bullet meant for someone else.
Agreed–the violence is really striking. It might be about general media violence growing along with the inclusion of bi and lesbian characters in recent years, but I think it’s mostly about cultural misogyny; TV loves to dramatize over-the-top violence against women.
I also would love to see the timing of romantic encounters and other factors (like whether the death was primarily about the character who died, or about its effect on another queer female character, or about its effect on a straight man) charted!
Jay Copeland – Shortland Street 2007 Murdered by the Ferndale Strangler.
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Jay_Copeland
Oh, and now I’m down on memory lane to German soap operas. Very gay and, unsurprisingly, very fond of tropes, either. Rest in peace, Susanne, Hanna, Franzi et.al.
I was kind of hoping you’d do this, lest I had to research it all for myself and drive myself into misery, as I kind of want to build a memorial to them and then tour it round TV station headquarters like “Do you realise what the fuck you are adding to by doing this” I’ve been thinking about it since Lexa got Maclayed.
So thanks for doing the hard work again Autostraddle.
I will never, ever, ever forgive True Blood for killing Tara off BEFORE THE OPENING CREDITS of their final season and not even letting Pam mourn her death!!!
The systematic de-gaying of that show (Tara + Killing off Queen Sophie, Naan, Nora, having Pam spend her last season searching for Eric- leaving her progeny unprotected and ultimately leading to her aforementioned untimely death) alwaaaaays bothered me.
But, tied to their unceremonious abuse of the “bury your gays” trope, I’ll never forgive True Blood to the erosion of Lafayette over the years. Turning this wonderfully strong, vulnerable, dark and complicated, black, femme black gay man who was unlike anything seen on tv and reducing him to a sassy “gay bestie” stereotype for Sookie was heartbreaking and unwatchable.
Lafayette and Tara were best friends and cousins and each other’s port in a storm during their abusive childhoods and complicated adulthoods. Lafayette was out for as long as we knew him, but when Tara came out at the start of season 4 and Lafayette was their to love her, accept her, and yes- tease her just a little bit- man, it was beauty.
Given that there is a small amount of queer representation on tv, want to imagine how much smaller queer of color representation is? Want to imagine how much smaller black queer representation is?? Want to imagine how much smaller healthy depictions of black queer kinship is???????
In a land of vampires, Tara and Lafayette were f*uckkng unicorns. What True Blood did to them was a sin.
(Sorry, this article took me back to my rage place. Ignore me, Carry on!!)
Oh my god, Tara’s death on True Blood pissed me off so much. Like what the fuck?! It didn’t even happen on screen and Pam barely acknowledged it.
I second all of this!!! Thank you for raging. This fucking pos show that I for some reason watched until the very end >:|
Delurking to say I 100% agree with this. Tara and Lafayette deserved so much better than what they got.
Seconded. “True Blood” really did turn to shit in the last couple of series, particularly in its treatment of of queer characters/characters of colour. That final season was unwatchable.
That said, I was startled when, after watching first series, I attempted to read the (terrible) books. I found that both Tara and Lafayette are teeny, tiny bit parts, with Lafayette basically consisting of one line of sass, a description of his nail varnish, and getting killed off by the end of book one. So in a sense, I suppose we were lucky the show runners were marginally more progressive than the author!
I’m also glad Tosh got a look in on this list. Her death is always overshadowed by the horrible mess “Torchwood” made of killing off Ianto, the second he was in a functioning relationship. That’s another show I will never forgive.
I watched season 1 of true blood and loved it for the dynamic characters. I’ve been thinking about watching the rest of it, but the fact that they kill Tara really fucks me up. I don’t know if I can watch it after that…
Damn this is real. Never getting over Lexa. Or Tara Thornton, or Rachel Posner. Generations of shows later and it never ends.
Also, thinking about Tara Thorton, Maya St Germain, and Shana Costumeshop, along with the black lesbian from “Under the Dome”, which I never watched– are there any black queer women who make it to being alive at the end of the show (or at least the end of their show arc)???
I’m not being snarky, I’m honestly curious. I’m racking my brain and can’t think of any. Right now it feels like if you are black woman who enjoys sex with women, you’ve got a 100% death sentence…
Tasha and Bette on The L Word were thankfully left alive. But that’s all I can think of off the top of my head.
Let’s all just pray that the black lady-loving-ladies on OITNB make it through.
Oh, and Lena Adams-Foster is still alive, and will likely stay that way. (FINGERS CROSSED. I really hope I didn’t just jinx that.)
UGH. And Annalise Keating, obviously.
OMG!!! YES!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!! All of these ladies. YES.
Thank you so much for taking me back to a happier place.
Glad I could help :)
But obviously none of them erase your point, I’m just saying that maybe there’s a little bit of hope for the future.
Absolutely!
As far as shows that are already off the air… Kima Greggs from “The Wire”?
Yeah, it’s become apparent that I jumped the gun (pun not intended) a bit when I started looking for a larger trend. I’ll go ahead and blame my underlying Tara related ptsd.
Also, how strange is it that, as much as I love Snoop, I often forget about Kima on the wire? I should do better about that.
Pippy is still very much alive on Rosewood and I’m not worried that will ever change. For once.
Bethany Mayfair from Blindspot is alive and well. Can’t say the same for her one episode flashback girlfriend, though. They did off another character’s straight dude love interest within a couple of episodes so that was kinda balanced at least.
Check out Masters of None on Netflix. She isn’t dead yet….
Damn, how could I forget!
I gave up around that point – just stopped caring. But the writers for better than the books :Lafayette was killed after the first so, and Tara was white. True Blood is one of the shows that should have ended much sooner.
Amanita from Sense8 is alive.
Try not to break a hand knocking on wood that if there’s a season 2 or more she stays that way.
The only show I know of who had two black queer women who didn’t die (as far as I know) was canceled after 11 episodes and I really wish I could have watched it. It’s called Courthouse (CBS 1995) and in it Juvenile Judge Rosetta Reide (Jenifer Lewis) was in a relationship with Danni Gates (Cree Summer), who was also Rosetta’s housekeeper.
in how to get away with murder Annalise is bi & she’s alive :)
Diana Barrigan made it to the end of “White Collar”.
Original Cindy from Dark Angel survives.
There are tragically few, but off the top of my head, Kima from The Wire is a major character and survives the whole show.
Maybe The Fosters and Rosewood?
Cindy in Dark Angel (the other woman in Diamond’s picture) survived both seasons before the show got cancelled.
I’m thinking of Tasha (who is black) and Alice from The L Word. Technically… Tasha does live but her character gets shipped off to war and never returns. -_-
Now we have The Fosters with Lena Adams-Fosters who is biracial (white father, black mother). I would like to think she’s not going to die considering she is one-half of the duo leading the show.
There’s Amanita on sense8 who is currently alive, however, sense8 just finished their first season and it looks reckless as hell. Who knows if she’ll even make it to the end of the show.
We also have Annalise Keating on How to Get Away With Murder. Maybe you can throw in Sophia Burgess from Orange is the New Black, but her sexuality hasn’t really been explored aside from her ex-wife.
So we have a few living black women, nevertheless, some of their fates are still undecided. I’m still keeping hope for television.
For your consideration:
A strong, beautiful, black, courageous lesbian character, who made it to the end of a series as the most redeemed of a highly compromised set of characters…
Kima, in The Wire !
(It was touch and go for a while when she was shot and critically wounded in Season 1…)
Olivia Lord – Nip/Tuck
added!
Talia Winters from Babylon 5!! Teenaged me was soooo heartbroken by that!
So,so heartbroken!
And quite flabbergasted by the “I think I loved Talia.” reveal.
Damn, these two could’ve been so good together..
I’m still not wholly convinced Delphine is dead…just sayin. I know I’m not alone.
Also, nice to see Dark Angel up there. Loved that show.
It wouldn’t be the first time they did a fake out with a character and I’m really hoping that’s what they’re doing.
And no matter what, let’s always remember Delphine with her magnificent curly hair instead of all-Dyad-business straightened hair Delphine.
Delphine lives. I’m sure of it. They’re being way too coy about it, trying not to spoil us but all the deaths on the show have been graphic and she just gets shot in the gut? Like Graeme Manson said “she was shot in the liver, right? Can you die3 from that?”
So out of 65 deaths listed here, gunshot wounds seem to be the leading cause of death among LBT women (17 total; 18 if you include Tara’s human death; 18,5 if you include Sara Lance who was shot with arrows, 19 if you include Cristina from Tierra de Lobos, who died trying to avoid being shot). Gun control people. It’s a thing.
The second leading cause of dead is car related (3 of them intentional, 3 accidental), stab wounds take the 3rd place (5, including Nan Flanagan’s staking) and 4th leading cause of death is being bludgeoned.
Unrealistically, no lesbian died because of over-processing or U-Hauling incidents. I call bullshit.
I really would have thought cancer would have been higher on this list….
“Unrealistically, no lesbian died because of over-processing or U-Hauling incidents. I call bullshit.”
I appreciated the laugh. Thank you.
Where does Ilene Chaiken fall on this list?
Wow. Also, Private Practice, 2011 – Susan Grant to cancer / cardiac arrest, and Bizzy Forbes to suicide, right after their wedding to each other.
YEP YEP! They both had reoccurring arcs, which should qualify them for this list. And they were over 50/60 years old, late in life lesbians, which is rarity.
And I was just about to congratulate Shonda on, despite her other faults, never falling into the “bury your gays” trope. :(
added!
I’ve been rewatching Private Practice lately, and yeah. Ouch.
I never made the connection at the time with Private Practice but looking at it now, holy shit. And trying to think if Shondaland has done this in any other place….I have a sick feeling that Oliver might get killed off on HTGAWM but I feel like Callie and Arizona will always remain living. That was the strangest few sentences I have ever written.
I tend to give Shonda a liiiiittle more leeway because it feels like she at least kills off straight and queer characters at roughly the same pace, overall (what even? you know you’re talking about soap operas when…)
That said, Private Practice is my least favorite Shonda show (except for Off the Map) – it felt so obnoxiously straight sometimes and often Political Issue of the week which was kinda cool and kind of annoying.
Also, I always wanted Addison to be a lesbian. I loved Kate Walsh so much and she got so watered down on PP as opposed to Grey’s where she was this great mix of ice queen and person I’d want to be besties with and also make-out with.
The one thing I did really love about PP was Amy…she will forever be my favourite Shonda character and I really, really wish with all my heart that she will discover she is bisexual
Didn’t Denny Blood’s girlfriend in Bad Girls, with the fuzzy blonde hair, die in a fire whilst high as a kite?
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_Bad_Girls_characters#Shaz_Wiley
added!
I’m currently watching season 3 of Hannibal because I was guaranteed a happy ending for the lesbian couple. BUT I DON’T GET ANY OF SEASON 3 what is happening I need help.
Me too. I don’t understanding anything in this season |D But I can’t imagine a happy end for the two tbh o.o
Really feel this comment. I was so thrilled and honestly shocked by the lesbian couple making it out alive on that show. The lesbians so rarely survive, let alone a couple!
As for explaining S3, I wish I could. It took me three watches of the first half of S3 before I felt like I was following anything and I’m still not sure I actually understand it. Good luck!
Jadzia Dax (1998)
Cause of Death: Blasted by an alien possessed alien
For Hex, you’ve mish-mashed both of the murdered lesbians – the picture and cause of death is for Thelma Bates, who dies in the first episode.
Maya Robertson is hit by a vehicle and killed later on in the series.
thank you for the correction! nice to know they killed two lesbians
Also Thelma sticka around as a ghost for most of the show – not sure how that counts? Also, the actress played George in The Famous Five and did an ep of Sugar Rush if that is of interest to anyone but me…
They both become ghosts and actually became a couple afterwards, it’s not like their deaths were the end of their stories.
Also, in Brookside there was another lesbian death: Shelley started out as a perfectly reasonable character that started going out with Lindsay Corkhill (one of the main characters). Shelley duly went batshit crazy, tried to instigate a weird love triangle with Lindsay’s mum, then started a fire in which she died.
I will attempt to find evidence of this beyond my own infallible lesbian death memory.
I looked up a bunch of synopses and couldn’t find anything saying Shelley died so I eagerly await your return and concordant evidence
I am starting to suspect that my lesbian death memory may be fallible after all, because I can’t find any evidence that Shelley actually died! (she deffo had a total personality transplant to psycho-dom though).
I may have to re-evaluate everything about my own cognitive functions, and life itself.
i want you to know that i liked both your comments anyway
Thank you Riese, that provides me with some comfort, as I feared I was to become the first lesbian to die from futile googling.
I finally tracked down Shelley’s last appearance, and she left in a taxi, not a hearse. I am going to embark on a long period of personal reflection over this mistake.
Some mitigating circumstances: it was 15 years ago, Brookside had a lot of fires, and I had a lot of alcohol.
Delphine Cormier shouldn’t be on this list because we don’t know if she’s dead for sure. #SaveDelphine
Oof.
Oh no, now I know that Charlie in Home & Away died. I only watched the Joey & Charlie parts until Joey ran away after Charlie cheated on her with a guy (if I remember correctly). My headcanon of course was that they found each other again and were happy ever after. Damn it.
yeah I had no idea…unless I actually do remember 0_0…the thing with home and away is once you get reminded of one thing it all comes flooding back
really it was joey “running off on a boat” that “killed” the lesbian storyline (or the attempt at one) if I recall charlie never actually seemed all that into the whole thing (or if she was she was really really angsty about it) I’m actually surprised they didn’t kill Joey since that would have been more in line with the running theme here
Charlie died well and truly after her “lesbian phase” was buried..its a shame because Charlie was the one and only home and away character I actually liked
Now I remember the “running off on a boat” too, what a sad scene. At least Joey didn’t die, you’re right. The pulled a “lesbian disappears in the parking lot” (stems from Erica leaving Grey’s Anatomy I think).
In my opinion Charlie was just really angsty about being with a woman and in the end her fear killed the relationship. Somehow I liked their storyline anyway (up until the cheating), it was kinda sweet and touching.
joey was also really cute :/
I think they canned it because of the controversy at the time? I mean you can’t really expect much from something like Home and Away but from what I remember it was a bit of a “how not to write a gay story-line”
like characters making joeys gayness “a thing” and Charlie being so angsty over it it was almost as if it wasn’t fully consensual. That said though it would be interesting to watch again with the perspective I have now as opposed to how I felt at the time (I would have been in highschool and very homophobic/closeted)
If Xena doesn’t get included on the list then Isabelle Hartley and Victoria Hand shouldn’t be on the list. At least Xena had subtext. Despite them being queer in the comics, they were not openly queer in Agents of SHIELD.
This is probably distasteful but damn it’s so funny how Lucy Lawless is in this list 4 times… a true ally hahaha
Some of these deaths still make me salty. >:-(
Pedantic infighting about whether or not Xena was a canonical lesbian is like having a slap fight about whether or not a tomato is a fruit or a vegetable while locusts swarm around and try to destroy all the produce. WE’RE FIGHTING THE LOCUSTS.
Well I mean, it is a fruit :p
I get your point, just being a pain the ass.
If you can’t be pedantic AND fight the patriarchy, is there any hope for us?
Heather, I’m ready to DEETspray the locusts with you whenever you’re ready. Tomato, tomahtoe. Seems like some of our fellow travellers may have missed the point.
The fact that so many of these happened in 2015 is really discouraging.
Also, RIP Lexa :(
I mean I think it makes sense that so many would happen in 2015 because there are so many more queer characters in 2015 than in prior years?
That’s pretty much what I tried to say below, though now I’m wishing I’d found a simpler way to say it.
I am still so, so, SO very mad about Tam-Tam. Tamsin deserved so much better than death by rape baby.
Tamsin’s fate shits me. Fuck that bullshit. “it’s okay, she’s my legacy” NO Tamsin should be fighting right up to the last.
I am astonished that people continue to cite Lost Girl as good representation after the rape baby plot.
ALSO thank you so much for putting this together. A friend and I were talking about LGBT FANS DESERVE BETTER and they were all “but it’s getting better…!” and nope nope NOPE it’s just getting worse.
I wonder what the statistics are of (dead lesbians/total # of all lesbian characters ever) would be.
Yeah, I’d love someone (else) to do the chances of a queer major character dying on a majority queer show (The L Word, etc); a queer major character dying on a majority hetero show; compared to a straight major character dying on either.
Same!!! Colorful charts and graphs would be divine, too.
Yes! And then broken down by year (it seems there’s a lot more queer women now, but they’re all dying, ya know?) and by cause of death (shooting, stabbing, jealous boyfriend, other). Would be fascinating/sad.
This hurts. And i haven’t even seen most of these programmes.
DELPHINE IS NOT DEAD YOU GUYS!!!!
Does Lucy on NBC’s Dracula count? The show made her canon bi, which the book did not when writing her death/change-into-a-vampire.
I wasn’t sure! Because although she was killed, she remained on the show, just as a vampire instead of as a human. Like her role didn’t change / diminish, right?
I feel like the point might be that their sexuality gets them killed, and the emphasis with Lucy on the show is definitely on her feelings for Mina. They didn’t have to make her bisexual, but they did, and she was killed.
Aside from telling the world queer folk don’t deserve happy endings, the media is screaming that we all need to get some flak jackets and helmets.
No! A protective force field generator.
Just to be sure.
Helmets and flak jackets: the new beanies and flannel.
They got kevlar hoodies.
Maybe be we can get ’em in a plaid?
Just make sure to have those nice dilatant non-Newtonian fluid impact protection pads.
I think they’re called D3o or D30.
Anyway they’re awesome and you would want to have your kevlar stop that bullet only to have impact stop your heart or send bones into squishy important bits.
That would be heartbreaking.
Literally not just figuratively.
#=$%!
Comment award !
try re-typing instead of copy-paste and make sure there aren’t too many quotation marks around the address
i fixed it for you
Thank you, Riese, you’re a darling.*spoken in HG Wells voice*
I really REALLY wanna make a sexual innuendo at this picture but I’m just gonna sit here quietly instead.
Ditto
<_<
We could totally adopt the three fingered salute as a Lesbian/Bi thing.
Honoring our fallen heroines and chuckling while doing so.
Purple middle finger.
That is what I got out of that.
Because bi pride flag has a purple stripe in the middle.
I think it is time for sleep now.
Debate if index or ring finger should be the magenta or the blue laterrr.
re-typing the I mean, not the link. but on closer investigation, I think maybe that link source just doesn’t play nice!
Let’s try imgur,then, which was so kind to change its entire layout..
Thank you, Rachel, you’re super sweet, I’m obviously just entirely incapable.
xoxo
The image is perfect, it needed to happen.
76? Oh lawd give me strength not to try to write Killed Off Queer Ladies cover of an annoying stage musical song that’s a con man’s pitch to swindle a town.
I came here to say Charlie is not just a Dead Lesbian she’s also an example of what I call Murdocking. Killing off a perfectly sweet nice character that happens to be in the life of white male hero character simply to up the Angst-o-Meter, not to develop the story.
He’s not deep in the man pain and you worry the actual plot is just too slow for our tiny minds? Kill someone nice. He’ll be sad, we’ll sad it’s all good now.
No, no it is not because we see you and your lazy writing. We see it.
It’s called Fridging! There was comic book where a woman was killed and shoved in a fridge to move the man’s story forward. It’s a whole other crushing trope.
No.
Fridging is for love interests and people very close to the hero and requires a certain degree of brutality and intent by the villainous forces in the hero’s life. Also leads to much angsted revenge plot
Murdocking is friends, associated, periphery and for angst that just adds to man pain and no plot. Even a dumb over done revenge plot.
I’ve never seen Supernatural or Home & Away so…which Charlie are you referring to and why do you call it Murdocking?
Charlie from Supernatural
Cause of the character Matt Murdock.
Because people nice or sweet in his periphery get killed off or something to make him sad an awful lot.
Plenty of fridging too, but dude is constantly being given the sads by stuff happening to people around him.
**FUCKED UP WARNING**
***************************************************************************************************************************************************************************************************************************************************************************************************************************************************************************************************************************************************************************************************************************************************************************************************************************************************************************************************************************************************************************************************************
It was Alexandra DeWitt girlfriend of Green Lantern Kyle Rayner. She was killed by the villain Major Force and her body forcibly crammed into the fridge of their shared domicile for Kyle to find.
It was just one example in a trend at the time of brutalising female secondary characters for shock value, sexual exploitation and to create a revenge plot for a male primary character.
In couple cases exploitatively brutalising a female main character for an “emotional impactful and brave” arc that would be forgotten and not touch upon ever again.
I totally agree. I’m so pissed at the show for sacrificing Charlie on the altar of Dean’s angst.
Also, I really thought they would not kill her as she’s the only recurring female character the fans didn’t hate. Her lesbianism being a big reason. She did not pose a threat to the Winchester brothers threesome playing out in their minds.
So mad at TPTB for killing my Charlie!
I may have missed it but I don’t recall Julie being queer in The Expanse TV show. She isn’t, as far as I can tell, in the books and her dating profile only displays men.
i added it after a commenter told me to, this is all i was able to find to confirm it:
Wow clearly I missed that one! Thanks
Same! I’m wondering if it was an off hand comment about her being queer. And she appeared in like 2 seconds of the show…so not sure if that counts really either way
I really dont think she was, that profile was to lure specific people to help her undermine her fathers company while working in the opa. They dont talk about her sexuality at all in the series, her existence is for something else entirely. Plus Miller’s in love with her and the writers do a weird thing with that at the end of the first book. Sorry Im just religiously reading these books right now. :P
Add Jill Marie Jones’s character from Ash vs. the Evil Dead. Zombified on Christmas and I think the zombie died the next week.
i can’t find anything about her sexual orientation, can you direct me to a source?
I unfortunately don’t even know her name on the show, but in one of the old Boob(s) on Your Tube, Heather definitely had picture of her flirting with (and possibly kissing) Xena. I remember it because everyone else was excited about Lucy Lawless playing gay, and I was excited because Jill Marie Jones was one of my favorite actors on a UPN sitcom called “Girlfriends”….. I didn’t know her character on Ash vs. Evil died though. That’s sad!
Nothing happened within Ruby and Amanda, except that heavy flirting scene.
Ruby Knowby’s (Lucy Lawless) status on the series is unknown, she could be dead. Jeez, Lucy Lawless has shit for luck.
yeah she also played #3 on Battlestar Galactica… who also died!
Hmm, thought I read something before the show started but now I can’t find it. I’ll come back if I do.
Webseries aren’t included, right?
Thank Jebus, Riese, for not including Xena, because in that case we would need a new category: “Bury Your Lucy Lawless”.
right? Mia Kirshner bringing up the rear, too
Well, it was kinda miraculous that her character on 24 didn’t ended that way.
Why is everyone saying that? She’s near the top of the list.
Didn’t read the introduction, did you? ;)
Check the ETA Riese added. Xena wasn’t on the list until commenters either badgered her into it or convinced her it wasn’t the writers’ fault it wasn’t more overt, depending on your perspective.
I forgot Hex existed!!! I was OBSESSED with that show. I don’t think 15 year old me knew why so much…I think it’s on Netflix too.
Man, this is painful to see. Also I’ve been watching Hemlock Grove (only finished the first season so far) and in the first episode a girl gets killed by a beast and near the end there’s this woman(forgot her name) who died after being skinned alive, both were lesbians I believe.
Dr. Clementine Chasseur! Riese, you should add her to the list. I can’t find the HTML for it but here’s a pic:
http://vignette1.wikia.nocookie.net/hemlockgrove/images/a/a6/Tumblr_mok21d8sAz1srr4wio1_500.jpg/revision/latest?cb=20130812063333
Cause of death: Mercy killed after being skinned alive by Famke Janssen.
wow! i watched that show and totally forgot. will add!
Sweet. I totally blanked until Alex’s comment too, which is weird because she was my favorite character.
yeah! and she’s the actress from battlestar. i mean as soon as Alex mentioned it i was like OH YEAH, I remember even when we were watching the show i was like oh god of course they are killing the black lesbian
Oh the teacher and the student relationship. yeah they were lesbians – the teacher as far as i know is canonically still alive. Her name was brooke bluebell and she was killed by a vargulf.
Man, this is painful to see. Also I’ve been watching Hemlock Grove (only finished the first season so far) and in the first episode a girl gets killed by a beast and near the end there’s this woman(forgot her name) who died after being skinned alive, both were lesbians.
It’s distressing to see how many got killed by jealous men.
On another note, they’ve had gay people on Home & Away!? This would be awesome news if I hadn’t found out whilst reading one of them died!
Adding to the list: Samantha Krueger in Ascension.
Oh, and Laure Valere in Les Revenants.
oh interesting, she didn’t die in the american version, she was shot but survived
i’m having a hard time nailing down how she died — dehydration? shot? eaten? it seems like the information was revealed in pieces and it’s hard to track down a solid answer. do you know?
Well, her death wasn’t shown on-screen (Alix Poisson was pregnant at the time of filming and didn’t appear in season 2). The police officers who fought the horde at the end of season 1 and mysteriously disappeared were found dead in season 2, presumably killed by the undead. Julie sees a poster in the hospital of Laure and the other missing officers and asks a nurse about them who informs her that they’re dead. This is all they reveal about her death, unfortunately. Safe to say she died fighting the horde, but the specifics are still a mystery.
no wonder it was hard to find! thank you.
…is it bad to say I don’t believe Delphine Cormier is dead? The showrunner teased in a Comiccon about someone being able to survive being shot through their liver if they got medical attention…
She has been officially said to be dead. The show hopefully are lying but as of now she is said to be dead so does fit the list until proven otherwise.
Showrunner interview:
Variety: “Can you definitively confirm that Delphine is dead, or is there still hope?
Fawcett: I would love to say yes or no, but this is “Orphan Black” and I don’t want to say one way or the other … We wanted to leave it in a hanging cliffhanger, so is she dead? Is she alive? I want the audience asking those questions.”
Would be worth it to mention Nadia Petrova from The Vampire Diaries (2014, death by werewolf venom) as it is an other prominent CW show and was shown having sex with an other woman and a man early in the season. Earlier on there was also Isobel Flemming (2011) played by Mia Kirshner more subtly hinted as bi (she was shown having compelled a male and female stripper, the latter of which was shown with bite marks on her thighs) and she committed suicide by exposing herself to sunlight.
To further help Nadia is seen kissing and having sex with Rebekah Mikaelson in 5×01
and she dies in 5×15
http://vampirediaries.wikia.com/wiki/Nadia_Petrova
from what i’ve heard she only had sex with rebekah in order to rob her? is there any other evidence of her queerness? sorry to be a stickler! it’s just that the value of the list dilutes if we include everybody who has kissed a girl even if they aren’t considered a queer/bi/lez character by the showrunners.
Well one could argue she was sleeping with both Matt and Rebekah for it, but in that case she wouldn’t have needed to interact with Rebekah at all in the capacity she did. The scene focused on Rebekah and Nadia as opposed to focusing on Matt. I’m not sure it dilutes the list – it only underlines the point of how narrow and limited our representation is, and how most of the time it ends in shock/tragedy (when it doesn’t go with the whole ‘bi girl redeems herself by getting with a guy’ route). I also feel personally it’s quite relevant given the CW’s particular body count in this mess.
Agreed on both accounts.
HAHAHA the first gif oh my god… the smugness and the way she checks her out. Thanks for finding those I couldn’t remember the exact episodes featuring Isobel’s gay… Nadia’s is obviously fresher in my mind. They have the petrova fire (and gay). Also is it me or does Mia Kirshner have a really specific niche/typecast? She’s basically typecast as the queer girl who dies.
I REMEMBERED ANOTHER ONE !
In At Home with the Braithwaites, Megan, the married woman who lived next door had an affair with Virginia, eldest daughter of the main family and generally excellent TV lesbian. I seem to recall they had a Bollywood-themed wedding ceremony (before gay marriage was legal) before spiralling into gin-soaked post-nuptial hell and eventual breakup. Shortly aftwards Megan is accidentally electrocuted in the bath when some appliance (maybe a TV?) falls in the water!
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/At_Home_with_the_Braithwaites#Megan_Hartnoll
added!
But don’t worry, Megan is now Rhona in Shetland, and she hasn’t been killed off (yet)…
this makes me wanna smash something tbh
Tosha (one of Omar’s crew) in The Wire was accidentally shot in a heist.
Delphine is not dead.
omg i forgot about her! i loved her so much
I didn’t realize cars have such a vendetta against queer women.
They be jelly of how we’re shinier than they are, being made of rainbows and unicorn dust aka glitter.
Like fairy dust but gayer.
And yet strangely I’ve noticed when cars are given names in fiction they’re usually feminine, like ships!
Well you know girls are catty, vicious and appearance obsessed.
Us being shinier than they are is still totally motive for their vendetta.
/sarcasm
Lillian was a recurring character in the Canadian show Murdoch Mysteries and was shot dead early this season by the husband of her ex-lover.
Dixie’s recurring lover Karen died after a head injury in the UK show Casualty.
This list is nowhere complete and there’s plenty of characters missing.
It says on wiki that Dixie’s lover was Carol; Karen is minor character from one of the 80’s seasons
What about Sophia? from Skins, the one who died by jumping from a height while on drugs and later we find out the girl who sold her the drugs also had a thing with her…
added!
Thanks Riese. Is it still suicide if she’s probably too high to really know what she’s doing?
she’s on the list
Julie Mao from “The Expanse” is confirmed queer? I missed that somehow! How was it shown?
someone tipped me off to her either on this thread or on twitter — and this is what i was able to find to confirm it:
wow i had missed this too
Wow, that’s a long list.
Since last week’s The 100, I have been thinking about queer female characters that died on German TV shows. I came up with these:
– Sonia Besirsky, Lindenstraße (1998): drug overdose, probably killed by the husband of her former lover
– Hanna Novak, Verbotene Liebe (2004): dies from a stroke in the arms of her girlfriend Carla von Lahnstein
– Franzi Reuter, Gute Zeiten, schlechte Zeiten (2008): dies in a gas explosion
At the moment, there are barely any queer female characters on German TV shows, but at least there haven’t been any casualties lately.
I still miss Hanna, sometimes. The Paula/Franzi-storyline was a mess. I might add:
– Susanne Teubner, Hinter Gittern (1999): deadly shot during a bank robbery
added!
Seeing Agents Hand and Hartley from SHIELD on this list is bitterly ironic, cause the showrunners specifically said that one of the reasons they erased both character’s queer sexualities from the show is because they didn’t want to become known as the show with two dead lesbians. Yeah, fuck that show.
I’m also wondering how many of these characters were killed because the actresses who portrayed them got better jobs and the showrunners basically went “welp!” (Lip Service, The 100, etc)
That is why I don’t understand how they made the list but some other characters didn’t
Well, I’d support them being on this list if only because it’s a big f-you to the showrunners who explicitly wanted to avoid this outcome, which is bullshit homophobic erasure.
precisely
That’s why I assumed they were being included. Glad to see I wasn’t wrong!
You don’t get to pretend that you didn’t “bury your gays”. We all know what you did- and you do too. No free passes.
Given that more than half of the entries on this list were in last five years, could be reasonably argued that lesbian and bisexual characters aren’t necessary dying with greater frequency, but than we just have more openly gay and bisexual character on TV in general. While it still possible that percentage wise they may be more likely than (presumably) strait to be treated as expendable, it stand to reason that the more of you truly exist in fiction-the more of you are bound to die in fiction too.
So maybe in morbid way…this could be consider a partial sign of progress over time? That doesn’t give writers on automatic out for killing a popular charter of course or even a poorly written killing of an unpopular character. It’s just hard to say now if gay and bi characters are still more likely to bit a bad end than strait ones. Especially since the growth of networks have made the number of reoccurring characters so much larger, even while most of them are still written as straight.
As you seem confident enough to cast aspersions on the shared experience of a group of 200+ commenters that say the exact opposite, you shouldn’t have any problems providing 90+ examples of living/happy queer women in TV. Annnnd Go:
I’m not prejudging the experience of anyone else. At not point did I mention any other commentators. All I did was offer a speculative question as to what these figures might tell us about how much visibility has gotten better or worse over time. Although I do notice there should been a question mark at the end my first sentence, so maybe there is some confusion there.
Do you honestly think that no-one else here has considered that question? Or are you to be considered the only voice of reason and logic?
Also, I’m not actually trying to be aggressive. If you really do know better than most here, a list showing proof of your theory would be very much welcomed right now.
So if you can provide a list, please do.
I honestly don’t what I wrote that led you to think I want to be consider “the only voice of reason and logic,” I’m not so delusional that I would consider myself the final voice on anything. I have no theory. It was all speculation about things good and bad.
There are far more gay and bi character on TV now than there were ten twenty etc. years ago. Along with a long of other groups are still marginalized and stereotyped. In shows where a lot of characters are bound to die anyone (crime and horror) in-particular, there are bound to be more cases where at least some of these characters are gay.
I never said that number of gay and bi character dying WEREN’T disproportionally high. I said maybe percentage wide they gotten higher or maybe they’ve gotten lower and admitted it’s hard to tell. That’s why I said that the…”growth of networks have made the number of reoccurring characters so much larger, even while most of them are still written as straight.”
FYI I agree that there should be more stories with gay/bi/trans characters in leading roles living to the end of a series and more same-sex couples with happy endings. However, as Riese pointed out not ever death listed here can be considered wholly on called for. The most offensive about the Bury the Gays trope is that the gay characters are treated as “expendable,” with deaths occurring for gratuitous reasons. I’d be very interest to know how many of these characters (if any) could be said to have died heroically.
Again with the extraneous explanations. We know all of this already.
I am past the point of caring why they die, I just care that they keep dying.
Lol
I actually wouldn’t necessarily say that lesbian and bisexual and queer characters are dying at a greater frequency than they have been in the past. I think the ratio of lgbtq characters killed to lgbtq characters that exist has remained the same over time… and that ratio has always been way too damn high! it’s uncanny.
I suppose this question could apply to change or lack of change for in the portrayal of characters who make up any minority – but do you think this is mainly due to linger prejudice or simple laziness?
To be fair to Mike, this occurred to me (a lesbian who is thoroughly frustrated on a personal level by All The Dead WLW) too – not a working theory or an opposition, just a pondering. I wondered whether the % of WLW character dying had remained the same but the number increased because there’s more of us on telly. I wondered whether the % might even have gone DOWN but there’d been a real terms increase because of improved representation. I also wondered if, with the increased representation, the % might even have gone UP due to the fact that yes, writers are inserting more WLW, but then they haven’t a clue what to DO with them, particularly once they’re happily loved-up, and they’re actually now even more disproportionately likely to kill them.
All of these things occurred to me. Mike could’ve phrased his comment more carefully given his position as a dude in lezspace, but reading over it I don’t think he meant to be a voice of authority. He was just struck by a thought that I know I’ve been wondering about, on and off, since this article was published. I don’t have any answers either but I don’t think the question is offensive in and of itself…
(PS: I am usually the one crucifying mansplainers; I stg)
Mayor Carol Blanton from Neon Joe, Werewolf Hunter
cause of death / year?
Actually she survived the spacecraft crash, but she was bitten by Neon Joe’s dad, so: cybot + werewolf.
Thank you for bringing this show to my attention, it was funny as hell.
Kate’s death in Last Tango In Halifax made me so angry. As did the whole planned pregnancy by sex with a man thing. That programme did all the other storylines really well and theirs really badly.
Yeah, me too. That couple had such storyline potential, but Kate was “not integral” to the plot. She was much more than a plot device, especially to older lesbians viewers. . So proud of the leskru’s activism. They are schooling the rest of us in who it make an impact: over $30,000 raised for Trevor!
That was the lesbian death which finally tipped me over the edge to say – enough.
Sally Wainwright has three kills to her name on this list: Kate, Helen Bartlett in Scott & Bailey, and Megan Hartnoll in At home with the Braithwaites. Is that a record for one person?
Also – what about unlucky in love Sophie Webster’s girlfriend Maddie Heath? There’s an explosion in a building yard as she’s passing. She dies a couple of days later from her injuries.
Ryan Murphy has quite a few on the list
Occurs to me now that there were a couple of occasions where it is suggested that Clara Oswald isn’t entirely straight and we all know how last season of Doctor a Who ended…
She didn’t really die though.
Well, she did, then she turned into an immortal time traveler, so…
Clara is canon bisexual, as is River Song, they should both be on this list.
There’s a longstanding tendency in the gay/lesbian community to require much more proof of bisexuality than of being lesbian/gay… which is a lot like the way straight people want way more proof a character is a lesbian than that she’s straight.
It goes right along with phrasing like “gay or *at least* bisexual” to make us seem like… in our community’s eyes, we barely count.
Please, everybody, hold bi characters to the same burden of proof. If you would have read Clara, for example, as queer for all her Jane Austen innuendo if she HADN’T had a boyfriend, read her as bi now.
I agree with both of these. Clara in 2015 and River… confuses me lol.
Also that is the best way I’ve ever heard how to read someone as bi explained, thank you! :)
Yeah, this. I 100% read Clara as bisexual, and the text of the show supports it (she mentions kissing and loving Jane Austen, seems pretty clear to me). But if they’re sticking with their “no subtext rule” with a broad definition of subtext (which is weird, considering Talia is on here) then River should at least “count.” She mentions having a wife.
Is there a happy ending list?
Please, for the mental health of the staff I hope there is.
May it be long and glorious.
They Don’t Die is a Tumblr blog working to document queer women couples that get happy endings in media (not just TV, but also games, movies, webcomics, and the like). It’s pretty new and they’re taking submissions.
Thankyou, Riese, for doing all the hard work for us and putting this list together! Seeing quite a few of these dredged up some painful TV memories (Pepsi! Why??). It helps put this past week in context. It’s not a nice list, but important, nonetheless.
I hate to be a stickler but Marissa from All My Children was played by Sarah Glendening not the girl you have in the picture. Yes the girl in the picture (Brittany Allen) DID play Marissa but she wasn’t the Marissa that was part of the MINX pairing.
Personally I was a huge BAM fan (I actually went to events for them) and I only shipped Eden Riegel’s Bianca with Liz Hendrickson’s Maggie. I also became a huge MINX fan because it was now Christine Lind’s Bianca with Sarah Glendening’s Marissa. I basically considered them 2 separate couples not the same character (Bianca) with different women.
fixed the picture, i think!
I’m with you I was a huge BAM fan in the day. Eden and Liz had amazing chemistry!
um Jadzia Dax was not a lesbian. At best, she was bi. But one kiss with a woman does not make her a lesbian.
Title of list includes bisexual and her case is not cut and dry as just one kiss with a woman.
She was a joined Trill.
Which is why the article is named 65 Dead lesbian AND **BISEXUAL** characters on TV and how they died.
There are some days when I wonder why I watch Supernatural, and some days when I wonder when I’m going to outright hatewatch it. Killing Charlie felt like one of the biggest fuck yous from that show. She was only in a couple eps this current season, but there was also a cute queer cop lady that was killed off after her soul was sucked out.
Jenna Nickerson I believe was her name. She revealed on the show that her first kiss was with a woman.
She had her soul sucked out by a demon baby and was then killed by being tossed around by another character until her neck breaks.
I will be forever bitter about Charlie.
But I’m also not entirely convinced she’s dead. It IS Charlie we’re talking about here.
They could definitely find a way to bring her back. Which I hope they do.
you know when i first saw that you had updated the article i jokingly thought, watch this get to a hundred. we’re at bloody 85 and i didnt think it was actually possible for it to be this high. guess what? i have another queer casualty, from a Brazilian show called happily ever after? felizes para sempre? ( a freakin question mark should be all you need to know about how it ends.) anyway, denise/simone is shot and killed. denise and marilla were amazing together. ive included a link in case anyone is interested
Nadia Petrova on The Vampire Diaries, bitten by a werewolf.
Seeing Lexa made me feel a lot of fresh things. Ugh.
Are Vastra and Jenny on Doctor Who still alive?
Also, River Song was bisexual and they killed her, yeah?
was river song actually written as bi, though, or just said to be bi on twitter? i hesitate to include characters that were essentially queerbaiting, because i don’t think they fit in as examples of this trend
River Song is bi on the show, she mentioned in the last Christmas episode that she had been married to a woman (Something about her 2nd wife).
Clara Oswald is bi on the show as well and technically dead, but just removed from time at the moment of her death.
yeah i feel that. i actually don’t recall – i only watched the episodes when amy pond was on because, actually, she is my root – and if river canonically did anything gay it was after i stopped watching out of spite. so she may well have been a queerbait character, and unworthy of this list
She mentioned onscreen having had two ex-wives.
Jenny died and was brought back twice in the same episode, The name of the Doctor, and it was fucking brutal watching Vastra break down. So yeah Jenny died, but then undied because Doctor Who. I feel like if Thelma from Hex counts, Jenny counts because Thelma then spent 2 seasons as a ghost and even got a ghost girlfriend.
Thankfully yes! Jenny did die, but then they went back and fixed it, so it doesn’t really count. River Song died the first time we met her, and we have seen her lots since because of timelines and things. As a side note – Jenny and Vastra should have their own spin off. Love them so much!
I second Jenny and Vastra having a spin off, I flaming love them. I feel like a Victorian Torchwood type thing would be brilliant.
How could I have forgotten about Vastra and Jenny?
Vastra and Jenny are still alive, well in the 19th century so they are probably dead by now but not in the show.
As for River, she died in her first episode, before she was known as bisexual, and she’s kept coming back since so I don’t know if that should be on the list really.
Wasn’t River Song killed off before she was revealed as being bi? Or for that matter, became a recurring character in the first place. She died in the episode with Ten which introduced her as the Doctor’s future lover.
susan on seinfeld died after licking some bad envelopes
She was engaged to George Costanza and was licking the defective envelopes for their wedding invitations. how can she be considered openly gay if she was engaged to a man?
This list isn’t only for gay women. Bisexual women count too, and it is mentioned in an episode that Susan has a history of dating women as well as men.
Original Cindy’s girlfriend hurt. I’ve been a robot ever since.
There is also Piper Perabo ( as Paulie) in Lost and Delirious when she jumps out of the roof!
that’s a movie
this is about tv shows
also does anybody want to hear me talk about how much i hate lost & delirious
If I can counter it with how much I loved that movie as young teenager and the twisted reasons why.
It will be terrible.
Like watching that movie again as an adult with none thanatotic worshipfulness of a terribly short sighted depressed adolescent.
That movie scarred me as a kid. It was like one big anxiety festival.
That means you were totally sane as a kid.
I toast to your continued sanity.
But it’s okay this world can be maddening after all look at that dead count.
It’s 135 at the moment.
Can you imagine the numbers if you add movies to the list? Endless.
Lesbian and bisexual characters ON TV…
This list would be more interesting if someone could compile and compare all of these deaths with two additional lists: A) how many lesbian and bi characters are still currently alive on series or survived full run of a TV series, and B) how many heterosexual characters have been killed off of series.
That would be interesting to me. Maybe only to me; I like quantitative analysis.
i think it would take at least a year to do that!
I think it would be extremely hard(well time consuming) to compile a list of heterosexual characters who have been killed considering that hetero characters have always made up the overwhelming majority of tv characters and there are a shitload of tv shows, past and present, to sift through.
It’s much easier to make up of a list of lesbian and bi characters(dead or alive) when they only account for like less than one percent of tv representation. Even less in previous years.
yeah, exactly!
i mean y’all know there is nothing i love more than analyzing data, counting things, and making lists and graphs of those things, but oh man there have been thousands of tv shows!
The list of dead heterosexual characters seems pretty impossible, haha. A list of lesbian/bisexual women that have survived the full run of a tv show (so no currently airing shows would be on the list) would be a lot easier to do, I think.
That would be beyond time consuming. I mean taking just Buffy, for example you’d have a good 100 that were killed off alone. But I suppose that also depends on who you include…
I am comfortable with Skins Fire never existing, so Naomi is alive and well in my mind.
I know she was loathed by the fandom, but I really liked Cat from Lip Service. The show went off into an entirely differently direction, one that I didn’t appreciate. So I think the showrunners made a mistake killing her off.
Dahlia from Legend of the Seeker. Was in 3 episodes. Pretty sure she died from confession by Kahlan. Was love interest for Cara.
Dahlia was resurrected afterward, though.
I know this has been answered before and it may seem abit silly for some people that we are arguing over whether Xena counts as canon or not, but her death in particular has affected me the most out of all the lesbians and bi women I’ve seen killed in fiction and I’m sure I’m not the only one whose been affected deeply by her being pointlessly killed off.
It just seems wrong to not recognize this fact and the pain it has caused women like me over something as small as not giving the showrunners credit for a show older than most of the things on this list which limits what they even could do. I think the number of people pointing out how they feel Xena missing from the list enough for her to be put on it.
Also supporting Xena and Gabrielle being added to the list are the numerous interviews with Xena herself, Lucy Lawless, stating outright that she herself felt that Xena and Gabby were a couple at the end of the series. One could add the numerous lesbian in-jokes added deliberately to the series by the writers once they discovered that the show had a large lesbian following, but I could argue that as being merely circumstantial evidence. (I could, but I won’t, since I’m a hetero guy who felt all along that Xena was bisexual and, up to the point where I stopped watching after Julius Caesar showed up and the writers went on a crucifixion kick, didn’t want to force herself on Gabrielle but respected Gabby as a friend enough to let Gabby discover her gender preference for herself.)
I may be just slightly wrong about this as well but I believe that Gaia was actually murdered by Lucretia who was Batiatus’ wife. Gaia knew one of Lucretia’s deepest secrets and threatened to reveal it causing Lucretia to murder her.
No, Gaia was definitely murdered by a dude and Lucretia was super-duper broken up and over it and started wearing Gaia’s wig or one just like it afterward like the weirdo she was.
Gaia was killed by Tullius. He was causing trouble at a party held by Lucretia and Gaia tried to seduce him both to help Lucretia and to hopefully get Tullius interested enough in her to consider marrying her, but instead he kills her in order to essentially send a message to Lucretia and Batiatus.
Gaia was murdered by a senator who was trying to send a message to Batiatus and Lucretia and kinda derail their ambition.
Here is a (likely incomplete) list of LGBTQ characters in TV and radio. It might be worth cross-referencing this list to see if there are any names we’re missing.
I’m trying to find out if local Asian media has snuck in queer characters solely to kill them off for the purposes of making a point about how homosexuality is an evil sin. I know there’s been at least one case in theater but that’s all I recall.
Oh don’t worry I have already gone through that entire list backwards and forwards. That’s where I started — that Wikipedia list, and four other wikipedia lists organized by show (one of dramas, one of soaps, one of situation comedies, and another of tv episodes), and the tvtropes bury your gays. That was my first step. :-) I have those lists bookmarked.
Actually what’s been super interesting to me is that I did sort of assume those Wikipedia lists were fairly comprehensive — and it turns out that they definitely aren’t, if the additions offered in the comments today are any indication. I mean I literally clicked and went through the bio of every queer female character listed.
OK, so from a cursory look, from the ones I could find that have LGBTQ women characters…they all LIVE HAPPILY.
The Big F and Yudh both from India have pretty stable queer women relationships. Daughters of Club Bilitis from Korea features THREE multi-generational lesbian relationships and they all live happily ever after. I’ve yet to find one that involves trauma, let alone death.
@[email protected]
well, that’s good news!
Whereas Asian Media is concerned; Attack on Titan had Ymir, an openly lesbian character who was given a major plot arc then immediately removed from the story after it was concluded. She’s confirmed to have been killed off-screen.
I dunno if a big, mainstream series with fans all over the world like Attack on Titan could be called “local” but Ymir’s death fits all the hallmarks of the trope.
Emily (TEEN WOLF) wasn’t mauled by an Alpha Werewolf. She was pretty much attacked by a shit ton of bugs as the SECOND virgin sacrifice for the Darach.
Plus, we don’t know if Delphine is actually dead so she shouldn’t be on the list
I think that Martha’s suicide in The Children’s Hour (1961) should count. This trope has been around a long damn time. :(
that’s a movie
this is a list about tv
yes it should count!!!
Chloe from life is strange dies infinite times XDDD but its a videogame and if she dies at the end is your decission.
Does videogames,animated movies,series count? cause there is A LOT. And i think those media are a very big representation, just like TV.
Not be a jerk but I’m dyslexic and I have managed to read the title that says “All ## Dead Lesbian and Bisexual Characters On TV, And How They Died” to come away with the information that the list is about TV characters, lesbian AND bisexual characters.
NOT all LB characters in live action or JUST lesbians.
Are you neurotypicals just very confident and never double check anything when you read before responding to something?
I’m not suppose to do better than y’all at this kinda stuff that bitch from elementary school said so.
I mean I always be glad to make her wrong, but what…what is this thing with failing at reading comprehension?
Explain this to me.
I am confused and not for the first time about this comprehension fail in neurotypicals.
TAHNK YOU, THANK YOO, THANK YOU…
PD: and about Xena, in the holy name of god, can you all please read the 5th paragraph of this post.
Yes, the conclusion paragraph in the intro. I have hypotheses for the missing of that bit.
But titles are much shorter and should be easier to maintain comprehension for people
Right?
But I would not know as I am not normal.
Maybe the thing is that we live in a very visual world nowadays? Maybe we need to replace words for pictures? This is a TV…?
It says all dead lesbian and bi characters. And they’re all dead lesbian and bi characters with their cause of death listed. Maybe I’m missing something because I’m also not neurotypical, but I don’t see the conflict.
The Lizzie Borden Chronicles has Adele (Kimberly-Sue Murray) in 3 episodes. She appears to be bisexual at least, kissing Lizzie in one of the episodes. Lizzie locks her in a coffin, later pulls her out and slits her throat to frame her for a murder.
ah yes, good call !
it bums me out how funny this is.
Some more on AHS – in Freak Show there is a woman who is involved with Neil Patrick Harris but also with a woman and then he kills either one or both of them.
In Hotel, I think Angela Bassett’s character dies too (at least, in the way that the countess does). And Sarah Paulson’s character Sally is the dead the whole time (we see her death in a flashback) and she is revealed to be queer eventually.
Oh also, the wife of one of Finn Wittrock’s characters is involved with the countess… Natacha Ramobva, she dies too.
I can’t you forgot one of the most iconic characters in TV history, Xena Warrior Princess, who was definitely bisexual if not gay. I am really disappointed by this gross omission.
“Nor is subtext or queerbaiting on this list, because we’re not gonna give Xena showrunners Queer Character Credit for a character they refused to make openly queer when she was really so obviously queer.”
It’s from the intro paragraph.
Did you read the paragraph at all?
Not trying to be mean, just curious.
The view that Xena was more than subtext isn’t uncommon, especially showing in how many people are commenting to say they think she is missing from the list.
Yes but wording of the poster’s sentence suggests she was not disputing whether it was more than subtext or not, but that she had not read the reason for the Riese’s omission of Xena from the list.
“Forgot” does not imply a disagreement with Riese’s reason, it implies the poster was unaware of the reason.
I am not on the subject of more than subtext or not in Xena the Warrior Princess
I am on about the subject of reading comprehension and whether or not people choose not to read paragraphs when they are an introduction to a more quickly consumable work like a list.
Is this clear?
Does it really matter if they haven’t read it or not, from what they have said it sounds like they disagree with Riese anyway, so arguing that they should of read it if they haven’t is kinda off point.
The thing is that Riese decided that this post should have those standards: no subtext, no queerbaiting.
I do personally considered Xena and Gabrielle canon, but I know that my consideration is built on subtext and if I use Riese’s rules, Xena can’t be on this list. Xena: Warrior Princess had very heavy subtext, heavier than the one you can find in things like Rizzoli & Isles, but still it was subtext.
Believe or not, I think that reading comprehension is a key in this matter. This week AS posted a couple of articles titled “The Seven Most Influential…”, related of course with AS 7th anniversary. In those posts you can find several movies/TV shows suggestions that have more than 7 years.
“Does it really matter if they haven’t read it or not, from what they have said it sounds like they disagree with Riese anyway, so arguing that they should of read it if they haven’t is kinda off point.”
as lex and freakazoid have said … yes, it does. the OP’s comment did not indicate disagreement, it indicated that the OP honestly somehow thought, after (not) reading the post and (not) reading the comments, that I had, in fact, FORGOTTEN, to include Xena. Your comments, erin, have been disagreements with the rules we laid out for the list. The OP’s comment is not a disagreement, it’s a condescending and hostile reminder to me for having somehow “forgotten” to include Xena.
Anyhow look, I’ve never seen Xena, I’ve only read about it. But I made this list in consultation with my team and also, I personally HATE queerbaiting and hate giving credit where no credit is due. Buffy, Friends and ER were on during the same era as Xena, and those shows had majority hetero audiences, and still debuted queer characters. Meanwhile Xena, who I imagine had a following that was pretty damn queer, knew they could keep their audience engaged without having to be brave and like them back. What you said about the impact of their death on you personally has given me pause, so I’m considering it, but I still feel weird about it.
“Does it really matter if they haven’t read it or not, from what they have said it sounds like they disagree with Riese anyway, so arguing that they should of read it if they haven’t is kinda off point.”
And I quote myself
“I am not on the subject of more than subtext or not in Xena the Warrior Princess
I am on about the subject of reading comprehension and whether or not people choose not to read paragraphs when they are an introduction to a more quickly consumable work like a list.”
YES, clearly it matters to me.
And it is not an argument that they should have read it.
It was a query, a question if they read it.
I even used a question mark.
Look:
“Did you read the paragraph at all?
Not trying to be mean, just curious.”
and
“Because I wonder about the way minds work.
Like if the main body of a work is a list and there is paragraph to introduce it do people skip the paragraph completely and go straight for the list?”
Another question mark.
I understand that rhetorical questions are used to belittle people, but my question was an honestly a question.
It could certainly be argued that my query is off topic, but the way people absorb, comprehend and interpret information plainly given to them is an interest to me. The comments to this post with a clearly displayed title and an introduction before the body of work show a dissonance of reading comprehension from people who I can assume are not all dyslexic and therefore should not “miss” details so easily.
Or so I have been told as dyslexic person.
My “superiors” are failing to be superior to me which is extra interesting, so I was curious. Took a chance to make queries on it and attempted to have them answered.
After this I will not have any discourse with you on this because I cannot make myself any clearer. And if you continue to attempt discourse on this I can only assume you’re trying to fuck with me.
I must suggest if you have such an issue with Riese’s view that Xena the Warrior Princess is only subtext and not more. You take it up with her, not me.
Unless picking on the weird kid is more your taste than taking on the Editor in Chief. But if I were you I’d try to argue with Riese, she’s much nicer than I am. Even when she’s agitated.
As neurodivergent person with cognitive problems that make it hard for me to read a lot of the time honestly you are just coming off as patronising, even if you are dyslexic, which is why i wrote my first reply. But i may have missed your point or misread things so I’m sorry.
Because I wonder about the way minds work.
Like if the main body of a work is a list and there is paragraph to introduce it do people skip the paragraph completely and go straight for the list?
yes people do it all the time, this is a chronic problem
I absolutely believe you and your voice of experience in this.
Still I want to science the shit out of this.
The what is clear but it’s the why that has my curiosity parts aflutter.
I am extra careful about reading stuff like directions or an introduction to a body of work because I don’t want to make avoidable dyslexia mistakes.
This phenomenon of skipping intro and going straight for the list by neuro-typicals is it confidence or is it the pretty light of digital devices making them less attentive?
What ever the why, I’m sorry you have wade into stuff because of it like a parent into the backseat of the kids during a long road trip because they are fighting over whose juice box has the most juice when the box clear states 6.75 FL OZ and they both know what FL OZ means because you told them last week.
No science whatsoever, but let’s play a little game.
Let’s assume that all the people skipping headlines and paragraphs, not understanding a single freaking word of what they’re reading and all that kind of shit, are all American citizens and registered voters, and, of course, a presidential election is coming.
Doesn’t that scare you shitless?
Maybe I’m just sleep deprived… But I can honestly not think of one les/bi woman in swedish TV. Living or dead.
So much for progressive country. I would gladly stand corrected though!
The only ones I can think of are the priest and her gf/wife from “Äkta Människor”, if you’ve seen that? She was played by, hmm, Bach. Sophia Bach I think? But she/they were only in season 1 (I was terribly disappointed when they weren’t in s2 tbh), aaand I don’t remember if they both made it out alive or not. I think so?
I don’t watch a lot of Swedish TV, so I can’t say if we have a lot more than that. Doubtful though. Ugh. >.<
EXCUSE YOU DELPHINE IS NOT DEAD ;_;
Emily from teen wolf wasn’t mauled by werewolves their tent was being infested with large bugs and she ran out and i think she was take by the darach (Jennifer)
oh and emily was the third sacrifice not the second
Kristen Bell’s character Flora on Deadwood is in a couple of episodes of the first season, she gets beaten and shot
I was confused by her addition. Does Flora ever say she’s queer? She talks about scamming Joanie by playing on Joanie’s lesbianism, but doesn’t imply that she herself is gay or bisexual.
Any chance of changing the last All My Children listing to Marissa Tasker instead of Chandler? It’s the one they used at the end, the one the reboot put on her grave ( http://www.afterellen.com/general-news/107209-all-my-children-recap-apr-29-may-3-bianca-is-back-bitches/3 ), and not the one that comes from her ex-husband/murderer.
Thanks for making the change :)
no problem!
Zora from The Shannara Chronicles – Eretria’s ex, had her throat slashed (the circumstances were really unclear to me in the show, perhaps someone could elaborate??)
Actually, Charlie Bradbury (Supernatural) was not only stabbed, but by a neo-nazi, who dumped her body in a bathtub.They Kill her off for shock effect AND they did it in the most tasteless way ever!
Awww man that I think that maybe upgrades her death from a simple case of Murdocking to actual Fridging by tasteless shock value points.
This list completely missed Xena of Xena: Warrior Princess (Dies at the hands of an army, attempting to save 30,000 souls).
I know a lot of people claim she and Gabrielle were lesbians, but that completely overlooks the MANY men both women loved throughout the whole series.
They were both very much bisexual characters. They weren’t faking their love for those men, and they weren’t faking their love for each other. Xena was bisexual, Gabrielle was bisexual. At the end of the series, Xena dies.
From the introductory paragraphs:
It wasn’t just her relationship with Gabrielle which they fully confirmed only after show has ended, but with other women too. Her most influental relationships were with women. Xena said Akemi broke her heart, Xena’s whole life changed after she watched M’Lila die and Lao Ma taught her love. So Xena belong to lesbians or bi.
Ana and Teresa from Amar en Tiempos Revueltos (2014) The couple had left the show together and happy in 2012 and they killed them offscreen in a fire just to give Hector, Teresa’s ex-husband who was still on the show, a plot.
Did they kill both of them? I thought only Ana and their son had died. That was really messed up.
all i can find online is that they faked their death so they could stay together? was that something that happened earlier and then they died in a fire later? (i would’ve just gone by that you said in your comment but b/c of zookie’s i wanted to double-check i had all the info right, and now i’m confused!)
Don’t know if anyone has commented this before but from what I could see “Lost and Delirious” was not on the list. Pauli Oster (played by Piper Perabo) committed suicide (jumped off the school’s roof) because her girlfriend didn’t want anyone to know they were together (they had broken up because of that and Pauli was unsuccessful in winning her back).
IT’S A MOVIE
THS IS A LIST OF TV SHOWS
jesus fucking christ
Shut up! We don’t know Delphine is dead yet! *ugly sobbing*
More dead lesbians:
Ivy, “Poison Ivy” (Drew Barrimore) 1992
Pushed off a balcony by her lover’s daughter and lover
Chloe, “Chloe” (Amanda Seyfried) 2009
Pushed out a window by her lover
this is just a list of characters who have died on TV, not in movies
thank you hailey
Plus (Warning Spoiler) in the case of Chloe there is sum suggestion that the character only existed in the imagination of her Julian Moore’s character, so it’s kind of iffy.
THOSE ARE BOTH MOVIES
THIS IS A LIST OF TV SHOWS
IT’S IN THE HEADLINE
if movies were on this list it would have 200 entries
Heck the number of vampires with lesbian tendencies who die in movies would probably be an impressive sum alone!
Laura Hall from Shortland Street in 2000
Died of a heart attack soon after her lover left her, became pregnant to, and ran away with her ex-boyfriend.
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_Shortland_Street_characters_(1999)#Laura_Hall
Thank you, added!
Just a quick note. The picture you have there is the actress Laura Hill who plays Toni Warner who is straight.
Dr Lauren Hall (played by Larissa Matheson) is the one you’re after. :)
i fixed it!
For some reason I thought Laura killed herself, but nope, just a regular old heart attack. Times were also pretty bleak when she was alive, according to Wikipedia:
‘Caroline started to date Alan Dubrovsky (Malcolm Murray) and the two soon got engaged. However Caroline soon realized she was in love with bridesmaid Laura (Larissa Matheson) and dumped Al for Laura. The two dated for several months until Caroline fell back into the arms of Greg, who impregnated her and drove her off into the sunset.’
O_0
This was really fucking heartbreaking. :(
Here’s a twist: a man who is attempting to murder his bisexual ex-girlfriend dies instead; bisexual ex-girlfriend walks off into the sunset (alive) with her (living) girlfriend.
Which is almost the plot of “Bound”
Leslie Shay was my first lesbian TV death. I cried. I never cry at TV/Movies/Books but tears of rage ran down my face that night.
I have another one: Naomi “Tracy” Richards (played by Samantha Morton) in the UK show Band of Gold(1996) .
She stabbed herself to death and was found by her gf (played by none other than Lena Headey). Their story was a big part of season 2.
Come to think of it. This relationship is probably one of the very first f/f relationship on tv, even before Tara & Willow. Although it was not a very healthy one and both characters were damaged and violent, there was also something sweet in their connexion; they were each other’s saving grace (before the tragic demise of one of them at least).
Good shout – I loved their storyline in season 2 (although I have a feeling that maybe Samantha Morton’s character slit her wrists in bed rather than a stabbing per se?), because the whole of Band of Gold was really a rough ride for everyone. I seem to recall that in season 3 there was a significant storyline with a trans woman of colour, who also ended up dead, and my mum was really upset because the character was so sweet. That’s for a whole other list though…
Also, thank you for using the spelling variant “connexion,” it made me briefly feel like we were in a 19th century novel.
Thank you, thank you. It was an amazing show.
It took my all this time to find them, but I can’t believe my Band of Gold’s VHS still works after 20 years. Convertion to DVD begins.
About Lucretia – it’s Spartacus: Vengeance and it wasn’t Lucretia’s baby, it was Ilithyia’s. Saxa from Spartacus (Vengeance and War of the Damned) should also be on here (stabbed with sword in battle by unknown killer).
Does Servilia from ‘Rome’ counts? She did have relationship with the woman and died….
I have an idea for another list and another twitter campaign: #WaysNotToKillLesbians (or #WaysNotToKillLexa, or #WaysNotToBuryYourGays).
There is a big discussion right now about how many lesbian and bisexual characters die (often unnecessarily), and how exactly they are killed off.
I think it would be great if there was also a big discussion, or a list, or a campaign, suggesting all the ways we can think of in which those characters can be written off, if necessary, or involved in some serious dramatic plot development WITHOUT KILLING THEM OFF.
We could list actual examples of characters who were removed from shows, temporarily or permanently (when the actor had to leave, for example) without dying. When David Duchovny took a break from “X-files”, did the creators kill Fox Mulder? No, they introduced the abducted-by-aliens storyline. When “Star Trek: TNG” removed Wesley Crusher, they also did not kill him, they made him start an exciting journey to another part of the Universe. But, yeah, those are straight male characters. Some secretly or openly lesbian/bisexual shows have also managed to remove some female (bi, gay or otherwise) characters without killing them. When “Xena” wrote off Eve, it was via her insisting that she should go on a spiritual quest, and go alone in order to find herself. When “The L-word” removed Carmen from the series, they didn’t kill her, they simply made her move after the break-up.
I don’t watch “The 100”, so I don’t know how this particular character could be written off without dying. Some of the creators insist that it could not. So, it would be great if someone made an article, or a twitter campaign listing all the ways it could be done, which would not only prove them wrong, but also create a pool of ideas that other showrunners could use for their future characters (unfortunately, I am not on Twitter for personal reasons, but I’ll just leave this idea here in case anyone else likes it).
So, go #WaysNotToKillGays!
P.S. Unless, of course, such campaign or list already exist, and I just don’t know about it.
P.P.S. Thank you, Riese, for the article. It really made me think and even comment, which is rare.
Erica Hahn wasn’t killed she just walked off in the parking lot of no returns !
For a show that kills so many of its characters its pretty fucking amazing that Greys Anatomy hasn’t killed a single lesbian / bisexual woman ! woooh
Not to say that they haven’t tried pretty damn hard (see: Callie and Arizona). Then again, just being on the show actively triples your risk of dying in a random and unusual way, so it’s more of a “how high can we make the body count before people complain?” trope than a “bury the gay” trope.
Leila and Rafaela “Torre de Babel” (1998) Brazilian telenovela. They both got killed in a explosion of a mall.
Xena wasn’t queerbaiting. The only thing Xena/Gabrielle didn’t do was sleep together on screen.
Absolutely correct in my opinion. The producers of the show were threatened by cancellation if they portrayed X and G as lovers. They took a brave stance and super-subtexted the show!
I have never been so affected by a pointless and heartless tv show “death” as X:WP and the decision to thereby leave G abandoned by her not returning to yet one more death. I still refuse to watch the last two eps of that series because X:WP is not dead and she and G are together “for all eternity” just as the entire series depicted as a main premise in the show.
In the UK soap Doctors there’s been two deaths. Freya died in a fire and a recurring love interest Catriona killed herself after being attacked in a hate crime.
added!
Cecília and Laís – “Vale Tudo” 1988 Brazilian telenovela. Cecília dies in a car accident. I think it was the first lesbian couple of Brazilian TV and, of course, killed.
There’s also a german telenovela called ‘Unter uns’ with a bisexual police woman – who of course died (in 2012) because she was accidentally mistaken and was hit with a metal bar.
welp…guess I won’t be getting around to reading the expanse series
which is a shame because its always a pleasant surprise to see a character is actually bi/lesbian
Obviously you know what you can handle but I still really recommend reading it. There are a lot of queer characters in the books and while some do die (the books have a pretty hefty death count at some points) many/most don’t so none of the deaths have felt at all ‘bury your gays’ to me.
Not to get you upset, but don’t dismiss the entire series because of Julie Mao. There are other lesbian characters in about book 4. and I’m not done with book four yet, but they canonically have a child together and the only reason they’ve separated so far is so that their infant daughter can go to earth before it becomes to late for her to be able to be there.
Julie isnt even gay in the books, or pan, they dont discuss her sexuality at all. Her dating profile was created to lure a very specific clientele for her own opa reasons.
There is a happy lesbian couple in book 3 who have a child together and neither die. Their love isnt tarnished or lessened and their love keeps the main character alive and motivated in her darkest times.
In book four there are many gay characters that are married and yes some die but a fuck ton of people die in book 4, literally everyone is fucked in that book.
I think the expanse does a great job of portraying homosexuality as it is, a fucking normal aspect of life that doesnt deter from how badass a character can be. Having an lgbt heroine who kinda saves the day in book 3 was so refreshing.Dont discredit the expanse!!!!
I actually think the way you’ve disregarded Xena is pretty ignorant. The showrunners were not to blame for the subtext; they were forced to keep it at that level because the studio explicitly gave them a “no gay” warning. In fact, if anything, the showrunners and the cast should be praised for putting as much subtext in as they did – basically going against the studio and running the risk of being cancelled because of it. And when they did get cancelled? They went all-out. They pushed it as far as they could. It wasn’t subtext anymore.
Xena meant just as much as any of the characters listed above – if not more so in a lot of cases – to many people. I’m wondering now if you even watched the show, or know anything about it: otherwise, you would already know everything I’ve just said.
Equally, it’s irresponsible for you to say queerbaiting isn’t included in the list – the reason you dismissed Xena, which I do not believe was queerbaiting – and then include Lexa. Lexa’s relationship with Clarke was most definitely queerbaiting because fans were more or less promised everything would be okay; that the couple would thrive, that the show would be different. Obviously that wasn’t the case.
I think you aim to make a good and valid point with this article, but boy have you done it poorly with these examples. Dismissing Xena – an icon that still matters to many people and that many people do not see as queerbaiting, and also putting invalid blame on the showrunners – and including Lexa – an example that was both queerbaiting and a fault of the showrunners. Very irresponsible and unfair. If anything, it just makes you look biased.
I think you’re missing the definition of queerbaiting used here. All the characters I recognised on the list were 100% confirmed lesbian or bisexual. While I won’t deny knowing little about Xena (Young Hercules was my jam after all), I imagine that the view in this case was similar to Destiel, the show runners keep playing it and dangling it in front of viewers to keep them watching. Where as the Alex’s scenario was more like…randomly killing off Booth or Brennan from Bones, or …I can’t actually think of another straight couple off the ti
I accidentally hit done while writing my above reply because I’m working on my phone. Sorry! So as I was saying, I’m actually having a hard time thinking of straight couples off the top of my head. But yeah, my point is, queerbaiting is open to interpretation, see: Destiel, where as the people listed were confirmed to be in relationships and their outcome doesn’t depend on the promises of the writers and producers.
i don’t know why y’all think that the meaner and more condescending and disrespectful to me you are about not including Xena, the more likely I am to include it. you could’ve made your point a lot more kindly.
I’m going to add her because of research I did last night to change my mind after reading literally the TWO commenters on this entire thread who have managed to talk about Xena without being total jerks, but seriously. “Biased”? Against what? Warrior Princesses?
Riese, you are a treasure. This is an excellent reply.
thank you <3
In defense of the Xena fans, the part where you wrote, “…we’re not gonna give Xena showrunners Queer Character Credit for a character they refused to make openly queer…” (before the ETA) felt very dismissive of a character and show that meant a great deal to a lot of queer women and paved the way for more openly queer female characters. I, personally felt a little combative after reading it, so I think that’s why a lot of the comments came off as asshole-ish. (I was ok with Xena being left off because while I accept her queerness as canon, I do not accept her death. Xena ALWAYS finds a way back from death.)
That being said, the fact that you chose to listen to your audience even when they were expressing themselves in a more hostile manner shows that you really do care about this subject matter, and you have a lot of class. I really appreciate you making this whole list to begin with and continuing to expand it. Thank you.
Y’know I almost never comment, but I have to say that it’s pretty obvious that Riese worked her butt off to create this list. I mean the least y’all could do is, um, say thank you?? Instead we get a smackdown about who’s on the list and who’s not – which totally misses the point!
For those of you who managed to miss yet another brilliant metaphor from the brain of Heather Hogan, above, the whole point here is that lesbians and bi women are more visible than ever – but the characters who represent us on the teevee are still getting killed off at ridiculous rates! All the time! In horrible violent ways, no less! Yippee! Instead of showing that we’re, y’know, normal people who deserve to do the same things as everybody else, including the radical act of continuing to breath.
The wider world seems to have few fucks to give as to whether we’re represented fairly in the media. Can we at least show some kindness to one another and aim our guns instead at the people who so sorely deserve it??
AMEN
Also Denna from Legend of the Seeker, shot with an arrow.
Could you make a list of lesbian characters who lived until the end of the show – shows not entirely composed of queers characters ?
But this is the thing. There are just very few because they all died before or the show is still airing.
Blindspot 2016 – Mayfair’s lover, suicide
(Vikings or Black Sails? Sorry, I haven’t watched those.)
what was her name?
The character’s name was Sofia Varma, played by Sarita Choudhury. But she was only present in one single episode and it was a flashback (Persecute Envoys, 2015).
gotcha, won’t include her then. thanks!
Something tells me that while Sofia (Mayfair’s lover) doesn’t qualify, Mayfair’s gonna be killed off fairly soon. Probably by the Project Daylight spooks, because drama.
Then again, she’s kind of a double-whammy token minority, so *shrugs*
Speaking for Black Sails, so far we have 1 lesbian and 2 bisexual female characters that are still alive. For now.
Paulie from Lost & Delirious – commited suicide
i swear to fucking g-d you guys
THIS IS A LIST OF TV SHOWS NOT MOVIES
not only that, but four other commenters with low reading comprehension skills on this very thread — the thread you had to scroll through to leave your own pointless comment, have already, for some ungodly reason, told me about Paulie from Lost & Delirious
Word of advice to anyone who frequents comment sections: If the number of previous comments are already in the hundreds, you might want to skim through whats come before to see if someone already made the point you have in mind (or in this case just reread the title!).
As a side note (and this is going to sound way bizarre) when I so Lost and Delirious I couldn’t help but wonder if Paulie just faked everybody out into thinking she going to jump since a) Why would everyone be looking up at that damn bird someone was now dead or injured right in-front of you b) when I played the DVD in slow-mo it looked like someone was still on the roof while the bird was taking off. Yeah I know it was probably an animal trainer and my alternate interpretation is probably bonus, but wouldn’t that have made for a much better ending!?
LOST AND DELIIROUS CONSPIRACY THEORY
I have another conspiracy theory with all the comments about that movie.
You said this in another I-can’t-read-shit comment: “also does anybody want to hear me talk about how much i hate lost & delirious”. Well, I think that some people REALLY want to hear that and they’re trying to trick you to do it.
i want to make a pancake dinner for this theory
Also Rachael Murray from Scream who was brutally murdered by a serial killer
she’s on the list
Adele from the Lizzie Borden Chronicles. I’m not sure if she was confirmed lesbian or bisexual (she was a prostitute, unsure if she was into the men she was pimped out to) but she and Lizzie kissed in one of her first scenes in the show. She then witness Lizzie killing a guy who tried to rape her (Adele), was locked in a wooden coffin by Lizzie, released by Lizzie, and later had her throat slit by Lizzie while staging a murder scene so it looked like her former pimp had slit her throat while she shot her former pimp.
on the list!
If you count “dead, then resurrected” then you missed Helena Wells in Warehouse 13. Sacrificed self saving the rest of the team, then time was rewound to before her death during the season premiere.
Sara Lance is only included because when she died, she was dead, as far as the fans knew. And she came back — but on a different show, much later. H.G. Wells was never actually REMOVED from the show, she was back in the next season. Also I feel like her character is pretty classic queerbaiting, which was unacceptable for 2013.
This list is also known as the list of TV shows I’ll never watch [again].
Tosh from Torchwood was the death that hit me the hardest. That’s one of the reasons I stopped watching. Honestly, I’m kind of glad the queer characters on shows like Agents of SHIELD weren’t major characters or very visibly queer; at least I didn’t get attached.
As for The 100, I was really excited about the show and just days before they killed off Lexa, I was saying to my friend how I wanted to start watching it this summer. Not anymore.
Destiny Rumancek should be on this list – hit her head on a glass coffee table after confronting Roman Godfrey. – Hemlock Grove 2015
Why should she be on this list – she is either bisexual or pansexual – it is never fully stated in the show – but she had an encounter with a man and a woman in season one, and an encounter with Clementine. Along with a long list of other people off screen.
she has sex with clementine right?
i’d consider that proof of being bi.
yes she was definitely bi and is on the list!
I thought of another one while defrosting the freezer!
In Scott and Bailey there was a recurring character in one season called Helen Bartlett (played by Nicola Walker from Last Tango in Halifax) who was a lesbian that was plausibly fucked up by her parents murdering loads of people when she was a kid. Things all get a bit much, and she ends up hijacking the chief cop’s car (containing chief cop), before committing suicide.
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Scott_%26_Bailey
http://www.afterellen.com/general-news/106745-scott-and-bailey-recap-31-lady-detectives-plus-lesbians
Also, I think that makes her Sally Wainwright’s 3rd dead bi/lesbian – she’s outdoing Ilene Chaiken!
A+ introduction to comments :D
Could have been better if I’d said “I found another one while defrosting the freezer.”
These pesky dead TV lesbians, they get everywhere.
You’re memory of dead tv lesbians is highly impressive. I commend you.
Just because of the “…another one while defrosting the freezer!” Sally deserves comment award.
It was hilarious, priceless and the perfect combination of words.
Lucy and Alice were also killed in American Horror Story, freak show(2014), murdered by Chester.
added! guess that happened after I stopped watching the show
When I have tried to explain to my straight friends why it can be so gut-wrenching to watch someone like Lexa die on-screen, I can tell that even though they try to understand and be sympathetic, they just cannot understand why watching these characters die all of the time can be so hurtful.
Because it’s true! Characters die on TV all of the time. But the reality is, so few shows have any LGBT representation at all. When they do decide to throw us a bone and add a few LGBT characters, to have these characters so often be among the first to die, or to have deaths that are so unceremonious and barely mourned or remembered, you just begin to feel numb.
Yes, straight characters are killed off on TV all of the time, but when that happens, it literally never means that there are no other straight characters or straight couples left on the show. There are always a plethora, so while one character may die, there is no shortage of straight protagonists or straight love interests that straight people can identify with, even in some small way. In so many of these shows, when the LGBT character dies, LGBT representation on the entire show dies with them. Or, worse yet, if a LGBT character’s love interest dies, the show often moves on and pretends that “phase” never even happened, more or less acting like the surviving protagonist was straight all along!
I’ve thought a lot about this since Lexa’s death, and most of the time I don’t know how to put into words why so many LGBT viewers feel so betrayed without sounding petty. None of these deaths on their own are that devastating, but knowing that the few characters or relationships that we can finally see a piece of ourselves in are rarely safe (unlike the inner circle of straight main characters who often survive until every possible story arc of theirs has been explored), it’s easy start to feel like these TV networks don’t prioritize LGBT representation in a meaningful way.
Nadia on Lost Girl was also possessed by the garuda ugh
Nadia on lost girl was also possessed (by the Garuda)
If you re-scroll through all of the images and imagine it’s a dating app, it helps with the trauma.
Lessons learnt: dont date men you get killed thank god im a lesbians, dont date women who has or have a relationship with men, dont hace babies, dont reject men or theyll kill you and if you are a lesbians on tv or movies youll die anyway
Saxa from Spartacus (2013). Died on the battlefield.
Danny (Carmilla). Stabbed to death.
Oh, and Uriel from Dominion was killed off-screen between season 1 and 2.
Danny was resurrected (as much as I hate to admit it) :)
Danny actually comes back as a vampire in the end of the season, on a post credit scene… I’m not sure if she fits here…
Beate (Danica Curcic) – Bron/Broen (The Bridge), Season 2 (2013)
Accidentally murdered by a poisoned needle in her girlfriend’s hospital bed.
Jesus Christ.
Pretty sure there was a murdered lesbian/ bisexual on season 3 of The Bridge as well. Its a police crime drama, not really a procedural like CSI so perhaps could be included?
yeah i mean i will definitely add any dead lesbians or bisexual characters from shows that are procedurals, just not the victim/witness/partner-of-the-weeks.
added!
Xena and Gabrielle’s relationship was confirmed by the writers, directors and actors themselves. Just because Robert Tapert and RJ Stewart (producers) never confirmed it’s irrelevant, since they were written and portrayed as eternal soulmates / lovers.
Also, when Paige Turco was in NYPD Blue, she played a lesbian whose pregnant girlfriend (Kathy, played by Lisa Darr, who also played Ellen’s TV girlfriend for a while) was shot dead in front of her. Bonus points for double trope of pregnant lesbian AND dead lesbian storylines!
Evidence, via AE (more bonus points if you tear up from Sarah Warn doing proper analysis over there): http://www.afterellen.com/tv/4322-lesbian-characters-get-promoted-on-fourth-season-of-nypd-blue/2
The only picture of her I can find is here, where Kathy and Abby are sitting with Medavoy, discussing him giving them sperm, as happens at every lesbian dinner party: http://www.afterellen.com/columns/61331-best-lesbian-week-ever-october-23-2009/9
How did I not know that Paige Turco played a lesbian cop, and also, how could I not have known that she played a lesbian in a relationship with Sherry Stringfield?
THANK YOU SALLY
P.S. – I vote we only include Xena if we get stuck on 99
So while she was not a recurring character, and was in fact Victim of the Week on a mystery show, I think Daisy Murphy from episode 1×10 of Miss Fisher’s Murder Mysteries warrants a mention because she was the lover of recurring lesbian character Dr. Elizabeth “Mac” Macmillan. The fact that we had to have Tragic Lesbian Death, when we’ve never seen Mac with a lover who was alive, feels a lot like killing a queer character for “furthering the plot”.
On that note, join me in my campaign to GIVE MAC A GIRLFRIEND 2k16 (if we get another season of this show, which I still adore despite its lesbian-killing ways)
I love that show! I love Doc she’s my favorite. I feel like it’s too much of a procedural to include, though, as a victim? Because there’s a murder every episode.
At the risk of sounding argumentative, I think that perhaps Daisy Murphy does count…? Yes, she was “victim of the week,” but she was also the girlfriend of a main character, so it’s reasonable to assume that if she hadn’t been offed (as part of a “lesbian love triangle” of all things) then it’s reasonable to assume that she could/would/SHOULD have been an ongoing part of the show. Killing her as soon as she appeared in person was simply a way of making Mac’s queerness canon without actually having to upset any viewers at 8.30pm who might not have wanted to have to *see* her with a live woman.
The only picture I can find of her is here: http://cinemorgue.wikia.com/wiki/Maria_Coviello
It was 2012 and she got pushed into a machine in a factory by another woman, but I can’t remember why.
I am on board with GIVE MAC A GIRLFRIEND 2k16 for both Miss Fisher and Veronica Mars. I’m just putting that out there.
I came down to comment about Daisy Murphy, honestly that death was so sad. The show kept emphasizing how horrible and gruesome her death was in the machine, and then poor Dr. Mac had to look at the body… So upsetting. I know it was a “death of the week” but Mac has now had no other girlfriends, and her time with Daisy was never recorded on screen.
Code Black: Dr. Carla Niven (Malaya’s ex-girlfriend), died of cancer earlier this year shortly after giving birth
Should we really be counting shows like True Blood and AHS? I can see AHS bc the narrative changes and an actor’s character that was gay in one season may not be in the next. But in True Blood, death was so common it might as well not mean anything.
I’m glad you put in Teen Wolf tho. Especially with their track record of killing off a woman and replacing her with like 15 blond white men.
Riese did say in the opening paragraph that she acknowledges the “Anyone Can Die” trope but she wanted a list of every character.
also for ‘true blood’ specifically, a list like this would not be complete without a record of what they did to tara thorton
Thank you for including Xena on this list!
You’re welcome! <3
All My Children had Frankie Stone, who was murdered by one of her aunt’s henchmen. There’s also Marissa who was killed when JR shot into a crowd.
Yup, they’re in there!
I’m just going to point out that Lucy Lawless in on the list 3 times…not complaining though.
I think it’d be pretty interesting to see how many of these characters were 1) written by men and 2) killed by male characters.
Let’s see how much they really hate us for being unavailable to them.
Exactly! Seeing this list is sort of hilarious. Internalized misogyny and homophobia at it’s most rampant. These showrunners will literally go to their grave saying it was necessary to the story and that they love their gay and bi characters, like HOW ARE YOU SO BLIND?
Dusty from Queer as Folk was 1 of 4 killed in the Babylon bombing in season 5. Some of the male cast were injured in the bombing but this queer lady was the only character killed.
added!
So what?? Sorry, it’s absolutely ridiculous. It was a gay club that exploded. Of course gay people died. More than that – gay men also died, you can see them lying dead when Brian walks around searching for Justin. It was an important event that changed the narrative and affected all characters, not just something aimed to kill a lesbian character.
Destiny, also of Hemlock Grove, is bisexual and died in s3 of Hemlock Grove. (She fell on a glass table and then her neck was snapped)
Also Nurse Delia Bubsy on Call the midwife.
Oops you beat me to it!
Insufficiently dead (yet)
she’s not dead though i thought
No? Delia is very much alive.
Not dead and currently living happily with her girlfriend :)
Does Delia count? http://metro.co.uk/2015/03/10/after-shocking-call-the-midwife-finale-fans-ask-why-is-bbc-killing-off-lesbian-love-affairs-5095753/
Nope, she got her memory back and resumed lesbianing with Patsy
:o I must catch up
How i’m i still alive. It seems to be i should have been stabbed, shot, bludgeoned, beaten and set on fire by now.
This is horrible.. AND THE DAMN NUMBER KEEPS INCREASING! I wonder what percentage this is of all lesbian, bi and pan women on TV..?
Deputy Jenna Nickerson in Supernatural– her soul was consumed, and then her body slammed into the ceiling, officially killing her. She was on the first two episodes of season 11. (2015) Funny how they introduced a queer girl character just to kill her!
They did the same back in season two when they introduced Lily, one of the potential demon blood kids like Sam. Her only real line was a throwaway about how she’d accidentally killed her girlfriend. She died five minutes later so it was a twofor.
added!
A) Thank you. This is important.
B) Delphine is not dead.
C) Kathy from NYPD Blue wasn’t pregnant actually – her girlfriend Abby was. Still tragic.
D) Lesbians who get happy endings list plz?
Someone is compiling a list, so feel free to add to it: http://100percentshipper.tumblr.com/post/140482816861/queer-female-ship-reference-list
Hmm.. okay an earlier commenter said that she was pregnant?
Legit impossible to read all of these comments (how do you do it?!?!) … but for sure her girlfriend Abby was pregnant. My wife and I just watched the episode the other day. Abby does go on to have the baby (so at least there’s that), but then her character is just kind of forgotten about. Sigh.
Good for you for updating this list continuously!
Not sure about one of your Shortland st ones…? Laura Hill is the name of the actress who played a character called Toni Warner who I don’t recall being queer and her character didn’t die until 2008.
I think the actual name is Laura Hall and she was played by Larissa Matheson who isn’t well known so pics ae hard to come by but I think this is one:
http://nzlads.tripod.com/images/Laura.JPG
Keep up the good (if rather depressing) work on the list!
Laura Hill played Toni Thompson (married name, Toni Warner) and as far as I know there was never any queerness. Certainly her relationships listed on wiki is straight and although I didn’t follow too closely I was in NZ for most of her time on TV and would have jumped on anything gay. Must check out Laura Hall. Worse was Jay who betrayed her wife WITH A MAN another tired overdone trope. Would love to see how many canon lesbians betray their female lover with a man. Verbotene Liebe jumps to mind there…
this is the link the commenter told me about:
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_Shortland_Street_characters_(1999)#Laura_Hall
Homura Akemi from Puella Magi Madoka Magica sort of dies… she becomes the devil because of her desire for Madoka (this is in the movie. In the show ending only Madoka dies/becomes a deity).
Thanks for the work on this list.
Sadly I can add two more from German tv, the same show no less (it was our version of “Bad Girls”).
_______________
Susanne Teubner, Hinter Gittern (2000)
Cause of Death: shot off-screen during a bank robbery
http://i0.web.de/image/162/30618162,pd=2/gittern-cheryl-shepard.jpg
____
Beate “Bea” Hansen, Hinter Gittern (2001)
Cause of Death: died of her injuries after an explosion
http://www.sonia-farke.de/ImagesHinterGittern/wb10.jpg
thank you!
A question. How about a miniseries in which every episode is about an individual, particular case?
I’m asking because in Argentina we had one called “Mujeres Asesinas”. Each episode was based in real life cases and, as the name implies, it was centered on women as the perpetrators of the crime. 5 episodes of that show ended up with a dead lesbian or a dead bisexual.
I know that this doesn’t actually comply with “these are all characters who appeared for more than one episode”, but each episode was an open/closed case. The show wasn’t a crime procedural either, because it was centered in the killer and her victim/victims; the only place where the miniseries was developed as a crime procedural was in the US (Killer Women, ABC, 2014).
Just to clarify, because it looks worst than Ilene Chaiken and Sally Wainwright put together, they were 5 deaths in the course of 4 seasons and 78 episodes.
i mean the real question is; does that fit in with the trope? and i would say no. even if it technically wasn’t a procedural, there was a victim-of-the-week, so that wouldn’t be included here, no.
Thank Jebus. Mujeres Asesinas was messing with my stats. Now I can say that all the lesbians couples in my country had happy endings.
Sorry! But I was thinking the same thing, about queer lady characters in Argentina and, while I wasn’t able to find many I was happy that at least they survived.
But then I remembered El Tiempo No Para, the character played by Lucrecia Blanco (Florencia), who was having an affair with the character of Julieta Cardinali was ‘accidentaly’ murdered by the main group, while falling from a balcony after trying to blackmail them. She was a recurring character and main antagonist.
It would be interesting to know, how much LGBT female characters were around in these shows during this time (from 1976 – 2016). That would make it easier to see what part of a shows LGBT cast was killed. If it was most of all of them, that would make even more of an impression.
To this list you can add:
Amar en Tiempos Revueltos: Teresa Garcia
Cause of Death: died in hospital from her burns from the fire
Amar en Tiempos Revueltos: Ana Rivas
Cause of Death: burned to death in a hotel with her son (born of a rape by ex husband)
Happened off screen after the couple had departed for their happily ever after and they killed them off to advance the love plot of Teresa’s ex-husband and his new woman. Sigh.
Coronation Street: Maddie Heath
Cause of Death: Fire explosion
Sorry forgot to add: Amar en Tiempos… happened in 2014 and Coro st. happened in 2015
maggie heath has always been on the list, and i added ana & teresa this morning!
Is there also a “Grieving Lesbian” trope?
Cause a lot of these deaths came with the extra emotional punch of a bitterly grieving partner.
Speaking of: Costia. The queer girl who was already dead before we even met her.
Costia never even had the dignity of an onscreen appearance and they beheaded her anyway. So sad and ironic and sick to think now that that moment serves doubly as Lexa’s coming out and as the point at which we all should have started suspecting treatment of queer women on the 100…
I have a few to add that sort of count:
Irene Adler on Sherlock was shown killed, later revealed to be alive, but hasn’t return to the show.
Thirteen on House was given a terminal disease, and left the job/show to live out her last days with her girlfriend.
Vampire Willow from the Buffy wishverse was only in 2 eps from memory, but given that she was more obvious with her sexuality than our willow at the time it felt like kill your gay doppelgangers.
13 from House M.D. was diagnosed with Huntingtons Chorea, so even though we don’t see her die on screen we know she was given a death sentence.
In an episode of Law and Order: SVU, a woman named Ann Jackson comes home to find her partner being raped by a home invader. The attacker beats brutally beats Ann until she is in a coma. A later episode reveals that she did not survive.
we’re not including one-episode victims from procedurals, it’s in the intro
Also!! Salome Agrippa in True Blood. She died at the end of season 5. She wasn’t a full on regular but she was in basically all of season 5. She was staked by Bill in a fight to become the most powerful vampire.
This list is appalling. It shouldn’t be this long. Especially when a list this long is basically the entire list of lesbian/bisexual women on TV.
Was Salome queer? I know she died but I don’t remember any lesbian proclivities outside of the assumption that all vampires are bisexual. (True Blood is one of the shows on this list I’ve actually seen from start to finish, but my memory is fuzzy)
Thanks for adding Xena! One thing, you spelled the name wrong of Tamsin of Lost Girl. I’d like to mention two more Lucy Lawless characters (and nominate her for “winning” the most Dead Lesbians/Bi women): D’Anna Biers (#3) from Battlestar Galactica-had an affair with #6, died a couple of times, was “boxed”, & ended up dying on earth (2009); Countess Marburg from Salem (stabbed by John Alden Jr.),plus the other two witches Tituba (pecked to death by crows) & Mary Sibley (blood loss to revive John Alden)-they all had lesbian sex as part of their magic rituals (2015).
http://zap2it.com/2015/06/salem-season-2-finale-death-toll-mary-sibley-countess-marburg-tituba/
i think there’s a difference between having lesbian sex as part of your magic rituals and actually being a lesbian character? i want to be really specific about who we include here or it dilutes the value of the list. Tituba was a queer character, absolutely, but I’m not so sure about the others.
Well, I have a little, tiny question about “having lesbian sex as part of your magic rituals”.
Where can you find that religion? Asking for a friend, of course.
Magical applicator does not lesbian (bi or pan) sexuality make in my opinion, but trust me pestles are very unforgiving and best “applied” after some warming up. Sometimes literally as in the pestle it self not just the receiving orifice.
Can you believe none of the seven queer women on Wentworth have died yet? It probably won’t be long…
I know, I was like, one of them must be dead… but everybody who has died so far is straight! If only they’d left Ferguson behind in the burning building…
The fact that every time I come back to this article there seems to be more names is indicative of either A) we are so very aware of when we have representation that we will fight for inclusion of people we saw ourselves in or B) TV really, really hates us.
Actually, it’s probably both.
Thanks to this list, I finally figured out who Olivia Wilde as 13 reminds me so much of: it’s Mischa Barton’s Marissa Cooper on The OC.