The World's Most Popular Independently-Owned Website for Lesbian, Bisexual and Queer Women
Leave a Comment

//

60 Comments

Reviewing Lady Gaga's Fame Monster: Track-By-Track

a;ex

Posted by and

6. Telephone (featuring Beyonce)


beyonce

STEF: My #1 feeling about this song is that Carly and her roommate Cesar have DEFINITELY already choreographed a dance for this song in their living room. There is nothing I love more in this world than the moment in "Telephone" where Beyonce busts through the door like the Kool Aid guy, all huge diva hair and sequins and RIGHTEOUSLY PISSED OFF about some bullshit her man is pulling. Sasha Fierce is NOT GETTING HER FUCKING COAT ANY FASTER, OK!?!?!

ALEX: Our lady of terrible/AWESOME gives us our anthem (possibly) with "Telephone" which in my opinion has its share of terrible lyrics ("Just a second, its my favorite song they're gonna play, And I cannot text you with a drink in my hand, eh" - really?) but the absolute most awesome hook(s) and melodies. Gaga's job is to make me wanna dance and this does it for me.

I have so many good feelings about this song and the future: I'd like to see the video stat and it better make up for the crap that was Beyonce's "Video Phone" (featuring Gaga herself) that I so patiently anticipated -- for nothing.

Also I'd like to dance to "Telephone" in public or on a dance floor sometime really soon. Something tells me I won't have to wait long...

7. So Happy I Could Die

STEF: For a song that starts out talking about masturbating over a girl, this is a surprisingly bland track. "So Happy I Could Die" is another Space Cowboy/RedOne track, which is even odder - these three haven't written a boring song together um, EVER. Sure, maybe it's harder to get your average bubblegum pop star to sing about touching herself at night, but this just doesn't sound like Gaga. It could be anyone. I wish they'd stuck to their tried-and-true method of crafting perfect pop hits, 'cause this one sounds like it could be any girl on the radio.

ALEX:

"I love that lavender blonde,
The way she moves,
The way she walks,
I touch myself can’t get enough"

Gaga clearly wrote these lyrics cause she knew Autostraddle would find them AND HOLD ONTO THEM WITH ALL WE GOT. Gayest song we have on this album right here, so I appreciate the subject-matter. "So Happy I Could Die" is chill. Like you can groove to it and sing along while driving or something. I'm cool with it but the song is just alright... she even says it herself in the chorus. ("So happy I could die and it's alright...")

8. Teeth

ALEX: It's really hard to review a song that you can't even listen through more than once honestly. I tried, I really tried! I love Gaga, you guys! I love her with the fire of a thousand suns but I'm just not into this jam at all. She's just going to have to prove to me otherwise when she performs it live cause you know everything Lady Gaga does live turns to gold-plated unicorns.
So uh... I'll let Stef take it from here!

fame monster lady gaga 1STEF: Oh, Gaga. No matter how weird she got on "The Fame," Gaga's weaker material was somehow always acceptable. I always wondered what it would sound like if she did something that actually fell flat, and "Teeth"... well. It sounds like it could have been a cute segue piece in between songs, like perhaps leading "Alejandro" into "Monster," but as an album closer it falls flat. It's SO theatrical and cabaret that the overwhelming visual in my mind is of Christina Aguilera in her dark underground lair, seething that her "Back to Basics" schtick has been stolen. The thing is, this song is just WEIRD. I'd love to see it live, perhaps with a stronger hip-hop beat and some crazy-lookin' Where the Wild Things Are dancers, but as it stands I can only picture it as a Colgate commercial.

Final Thoughts...

ALEX: What draws me to Lady Gaga's brand of dance-pop music (and certainly the songs on The Fame Monster) and what makes them so fresh and ingenious seems to be her combination of great pop beats and harmonies with real fucking emotion. It's why when I dance in the dark I can sing "cause when he's lookin' she falls apaaaart" at the top of my lungs and feel it in my heart as well as my bones.

I'd say Holy Trinity of The Fame Monster is made up of: "Bad Romance", "Monster", and "Telephone". I think my personal favorite at the moment is "Dance in the Dark" and I probably won't listen to "Speechless" or "Teeth" ever again or for awhile. Just saying.

STEF: The genius of "The Fame Monster" is that it isn't REALLY a whole new album; this is just Gaga cranking out a few more singles before she starts work on her actual second album. Lady Gaga has always been able to write a brilliant pop song, but when she's given access to the world's greatest songwriters and producers, she's able to create increasingly bold and refreshingly strange music that pushes the envelope of what pop music can be. "The Fame Monster" is just a sampling of a thousand directions she could move in. In a world where most pop singers are merely bland, autotuned actresses who don't write their own material, Gaga's hands-on approach is completely refreshing. While uneven in places, "The Fame Monster" isn't afraid to be weird.

fame monster lady gaga 4

You can buy the regular edition mp3 version of The Fame Monster for $7.92. Also: The Fame Monster album (regular) The Fame Monster [Deluxe Edition] or the The Fame Monster Limited Edition, which has extras and comes out on December 15th.

60 responses to “Reviewing Lady Gaga's Fame Monster: Track-By-Track”

  1. Jess

    Stef, all I see is bow and hair but that’s the greatest pic.
    -
    I’m surprised by the lack of enthusiasm for Speechless. It has some of my favorite lyrics between the 2 albums.
    -
    And I know that it’s complicated
    But I’m a loser in love
    So baby raise a glass to mend
    All the broken hearts
    Of all my wrecked up friends

    Thumb up 0
    1. Mark in Iowa

      I liked Speechless a little more once I found out she had written it influenced at first not by a lover, but by her dad. He was sick and in the hospital. That made me at least give it a second listen.

      Thumb up 0
  2. carlytron

    YOU WILL DEFINITELY HEAR TELEPHONE TOMORROW NIGHT. it is my favorite thing right now. well, that and the fact that janet jackson performed the entire dance break in “if” during her medley at the AMAs but that’s neither here nor there.

    Generally I like this album and cannot fucking wait to see it performed live (that is, if I can manage to scrounge up tickets. DAMN YOU TICKETMASTER!)

    also Cesar and I really need to start choreographing this…

    Thumb up 0
    1. Lynne

      I stubhubed and now I am poor.

      Thumb up 0
  3. Lynne

    THIS. Monster def. gets stuck in my head the most and I can’t wait to hear Telephone at a gay club.

    Thumb up 0
  4. Crystal

    Ace breakdown, girls. I haven’t exactly warmed up to Lady Gaga, but seeing all of this passion has convinced me to try again.

    Thumb up 0
  5. marya

    I bought the deluxe edition on iTunes, and there’s an additional 4 new songs (Starstruck, Paper Gangsta, Retro Dance Freak, and Disco Heaven), plus the all of the tracks from The Fame (excluding Again,Again).
    Money well spent!

    Thumb up 0
  6. intern Daphne Duck

    I don’t get Lady Gaga like i don’t get milk.(the stuff cows deliver, that is)
    -
    I’m not the huge Gaga fans most of you are(yet). She writes catchy songs, that’s about it for me.
    -
    I have to admit, though, that there’s some really good stuff on this album. I’m starting to realize how not so wtf Bad Romance is. It’s actually a brilliant pop song, if you think about it.
    -
    I mostly second Stefs brainflow on this one.

    Thumb up 0
  7. stef

    Really? Nobody has any feelings about Beyonce Mr Kool Aid? It’s only the greatest Photoshop achievement of my life, no big deal.

    Thumb up 0
    1. Lynne

      I LOLed and showed my roommate. I’m a fan.

      Thumb up 0
    2. carlytron

      i just realized i omitted that from my comment. i LOLed for A WHILE over that one.

      Thumb up 0
    3. Rachel B

      That was, for me, the best part of this review. I have a lot of feelings about that graphic and the anecdote it accompanied. And they all center around “THAT WAS THE FUNNIEST/MOST AWESOME/BEST THING EVER.”

      Thumb up 0
    4. Heahter

      Every time I close my eyes for the rest of the day, I will see that image and laugh. It’s the way you said it that makes the picture that much more hilarious.

      Thumb up 0
      1. Heather

        Yeah, I misspelled my own name there. Some body help me.

        Thumb up 0
  8. Haviland

    this is GREAT, girls! the first time i’m hearing most of these songs.
    also, can we talk about how fabulously in shape she is?
    we all need craig ramsay, obvs.

    Thumb up 0
    1. Christine

      obviously I want to marry all of lady Gaga, but I’d totally marry her legs if I had the chance. Nicest legs EVER.

      Thumb up 0
  9. stacey

    HE ATE MY HEART THEN HE ATE MY BRAIN
    BEST LYRICS OF THE WHOLE ALBUM

    Thumb up 0
    1. stef

      agreed.

      Thumb up 0
  10. Emily

    I’m actually really digging Speechless. Bad Romance is still my favorite of the album though. Good review ladies!

    Thumb up 0
  11. Robin

    Thanks for reviewing and posting ladies! This was truly hilarious and enjoyable and informative and I’m digging each and every one of her new tunes. I have my special addition Lady Gaga The Fame Monster [Super Deluxe Limited Edition or whatever] pre-ordered. (Doesn’t hurt that I have some photos from The Fame launch in the booklet, EEEeeeeeeeee)

    Thumb up 0
  12. ric

    omg beyonce kool aid man is the coolest thing ever

    Thumb up 0
    1. ric

      can I get a big image of it to make it my desktop background? lol

      Thumb up 0
  13. wasteunit

    Thanks for the break-down, ladies! I did a legit spit-take when I saw the Beyonce Kool Aid picture. I’ll be billing you for my new monitor.

    I may or may not have been naughty and used magic to listen to the album for the past 2 weeks straight. I DID NOT like “Teeth” the first 100 times I listened to it, but it really grew on me. It’s definitely not my favorite song by far, but I like it.

    When I heard “Telephone” I wanted to hate it. But I couldn’t. No matter how hard I tried. It’s. So. Good.

    As for “Speechless,” I’m fairly disappointed. GaGa hyped it up so much, and I thought the reason the song was written (to convince her dad to get surgery) was interesting and sad. I certainly don’t hate it, but it’s kinda meh to me.

    I really, really love the album overall. And I love you. Yes, you.

    Thumb up 0
  14. MsNJS

    *Raises hand during the class discussion, hopes no one throws anything*

    Ahem..I love Lady Gaga! I really do but I have to say I don;t like this album. Bad Romance is AWESOME!! But the other tracks just fall short. They feel like demos that didn’t make the Fame and for good reason. However, I do like the unrealsed/unmentioined track “Filthy Pop” its stuck in my head.

    Thumb up 0
  15. Elizabeth (aka Elli)

    I love Lady Gaga the persona, the spectacle. Her performances and videos are crazy awesome weird. But I don’t think I can sit and just listen to more than a few of her songs straight through in one sitting. I actually really like Speechless, though. And Bad Romance is pretty awesome and will stuck in my head forever and ever amen.

    Thumb up 0
  16. Sarah

    I saw the tweet about this article and was really hoping it would be Alex & Stef doing uke versions of all the songs. But this works too.
    How great is Monster?? I also like how she recycles certain lyrics in the this album, like free bitch. Tegan & Sara do that, too.
    I didn’t even catch the Kubrick reference until you guys mentioned it. Between that and Sylvia Plath and her love of performance art, well I feel like I could have really great conversations with this woman. But she also loves to dance! I love her so much.

    Thumb up 0
  17. Carly

    Y’alls is crazy, “Teeth” is a hot track. It’s like a Gaga song birthed by the creative genius of Poe and Roisin Murphy. AKA “a dream come true.”

    Thumb up 0
    1. kimbit

      YES I was trying to remember who “Teeth” reminded me of. Roison Murphy for sure- it’s such a good song! It’s become integral to my morning-walk-to- the-bus-stop playlist.

      Thumb up 0
      1. carlytron

        there’s a little Xtina in the vocals too. i love this song!

        Thumb up 0
  18. itsbrittany

    Am I the only one who cracks up at “Teeth” everytime? I can’t listen to it without laughing. Just thinking about the way she says “show me your teeth” cracks me up. Just the whole song…oh god. Maybe I’m crazy. I do like the track though. And of course, I LOVE her.

    Thumb up 0
  19. foist

    “You cannot resist The Gaga” – love it. I resisted for a long time for one reason or another but now I can officially declare that I am a Lady Gaga fan. Thanks AS. So… I’ve listened to “Dance In The Dark” the most out of all the new tracks. IDK, there’s something about it that sticks with me. And A;ex, you pretty much summed up what I think about “Fame Monster” – great review.

    Thumb up 0
  20. riese

    ME TOO! But maybe you’ve brainwashed me: “What draws me to Lady Gaga’s brand of dance-pop music (and certainly the songs on The Fame Monster) and what makes them so fresh and ingenious seems to be her combination of great pop beats and harmonies with real fucking emotion.”

    Thumb up 0
  21. tanya

    So happy i could die sounds JUST like ‘pocketful of sunshine’

    Thumb up 0
    1. carlytron

      THANK YOU! I’ve been trying to place that melody for days now.

      Thumb up 0
  22. About album, buy, fame monster, lady gaga’s fame, gaga fans, pizza | Find me About

    [...] Autostraddle Gaga-Expert Stef and our designer/Gaga-Lover Alex break down “The Fame Monster” track-by-track, including full songs for your listening enjoyment! Hello little monsters! Alex here! As you know, Lady Gaga’s sophomore album “The Fame …Read Original Story: Reviewing Lady Gaga's Fame Monster: Track-By-Track – Autostraddle (bl… [...]

    Thumb up 0
  23. ric

    work your blond benet ramsey – we’ll haunt like libearce – find the freedom in the music – find your jesus – find your kubrick.

    love that song

    Thumb up 0
  24. Laurence

    The Beyoncé Kool Aid made me actually laugh out loud I kid you not.
    Mega kudos on that one and the very amusing review.

    Thumb up 0
  25. wasteunit

    I touch myself all through the night
    And when something falls out of place
    I take my time, I put it back
    I touch myself ’til I’m on track

    http://www.sphere.com/2009/11/06/woman-reveals-health-horror-my-vagina-fell-out/?icid=main%7Cmain%7Cdl1%7Clink7%7Chttp%3A%2F%2Fwww.sphere.com%2F2009%2F11%2F06%2Fwoman-reveals-health-horror-my-vagina-fell-out%2F

    Thumb up 0
    1. stef

      AAAAAAHHHHHH WHYYYYYYYYYY

      Thumb up 0
  26. Alex!

    Dancing to Telephone, in the car, really late, with friends, at an incomprehensible loudness, is my new favorite thing. Seriously, where’d Beyonce come from? She hit it hard! I surely hope we can see Carly and Caesar’s choreography. Love the review.

    Thumb up 0
  27. Nicole

    so like, I can only speak for myself but I very vividly remember being at my friends bday party and her mom had games with prizes and I won an Ace of Base cassette tape and it was like the most exciting thing ever. I was probably… 8 and Lady Gaga & I are the same age and there is honestly no point to this comment at all except me telling that story because the Ace of Base influence thing made me think of it. I cant’ put coherent thoughts together today or ever.

    Thumb up 0
  28. bryan

    i really liked this album, and your review was awesome, but there’s something i’m wondering about the backing track for ‘Teeth’. i’ve looked at lots of reviews for this album, and NOBODY has mentioned it, but the backing track is traditional Native American music! i’m part Native American, so it’s weird to hear something like that, something quite personal to me in that song. but anyway, i’m just wondering if anybody knows where i can find information about the background track and who recorded it originally, who gave permission to use it, etc. because i know Lady GaGa’s fans are very important to her, i would like to know if she thought about what her Native American fans might think if she used a backing track like that, and if she didn’t think about that, i don’t know if i want to support her anymore. i know this is off-topic, but i haven’t found anything about this anywhere, and i don’t know where to ask about something like this. i’m not trying to make a big deal…i just thought the people posting on here seemed nice, and liked Lady GaGa, so i thought it would be a good place.

    thanks for reading

    Thumb up 0
    1. texastwospirit

      I have been playing it over and over since it came out, and yes, we have to be correct on that hunch. We need to find out where she got her music from. It sounds like a familiar native too, it sounds like a pow wow I went to, I just can’t remember the song and place. If I could place it, this would be awesome!!!!!!

      Thumb up 0
  29. Gabby ...   x

    OMG … I love Lady Gaga … and this album is just great !!!!! … x Luvs youu Lady Gaga !!!!!!! … x ♥♥♥♥♥♥

    Thumb up 0
  30. Brad the Dad

    Yo.
    I am a musician. I am a music lover. I love Madonna, Michael Jackson, but also love Coltrane, Wes Montgomery, Louis Armstrong, Classical symphonic Orchestra recordings, Guns N Roses, AC/DC, Indigo Girls, Beach Boys, Living Colour, The Melvins, TOOL, and many many more.
    I saw one Lady Gaga video, and then her SNL performance, and was excited to buy the album ‘The Fame Monster’ and share it with my children and my wife!
    My wife warned me that she thought my judgement had flown the coop, but I persisted that GAGA struck me as an intelligent, empowering female, with great musical abilities, and that the album would show this.

    Umm,
    NO.
    This album is absolutely one of the largest meltdown letdowns of the last three decades.
    Nowhere in this album is there a sound that produces a reaction in me that says, ‘Wow, they put some effort into this.’
    In fact,
    My six-year old has created a plethora of more unique, talented, ear-loving catchy tunes with her radio-shack keyboard and her voice alone.

    Lady Gaga,
    you owe me one, big time,
    and I’m not talking about sex, baby. My wife does that thing with me all day and all night for realz,
    not with a damn disco stick- (whatever that is).

    You best take this money,
    fire every human involved in this album,
    head to L.A. or even Kansas City,
    find a bass player, a drummer, a guitar player,
    and perhaps a synth-keyboard master,
    get a new producer,
    and write some songs with some real emotion.

    You remind me of someone who has had their soul scared out of them,
    and now only lives to prove to the world that
    nothing much matters to you anymore.

    You dont empower anyone or anything,
    except your wallet.

    And, Lady-
    even in America- that will NOT BE GOOD ENOUGH
    over the long haul.
    I surmise all the males who ‘love’ her ‘album’(parenthesized because it has no musical qualities),
    are all secretly pedophiles,
    or worse.

    If you dont own up to the community, Lady Gaga,
    I suggest you find a new day job.

    I am very disappointed in you,
    we put a lot of faith in you,
    that you would knock our socks off.

    Instead,
    you have pissed off the all-knowing consciousness,
    and will be punished accordingly.
    Prepare to bend over.

    Thumb up 0

Leave a Reply