“Supergirl” Episode 421 Recap: You Are My Sunshine

Previously on Supergirl, Alex voluntarily got her mind erased to protect Supergirl’s true identity, Kelly went with Alex when she thought she was going to get to adopt a baby but then it fell through, Lena and Kara found out about Kaznian Kara aka the Red Daughter, and Kara went to tell the president about Lex’s nefarious plans and instead of getting a Pulitzer she got black-bagged.

We open in Midvale, in 2007, when adorable teens Alex and Kara are walking through the forest, clapping to some music on their iPod. Kara is trying to convince Alex she can’t go to college, but Alex is sure Kara will make new friends. Kara says no one will understand her like Alex does, but their conversation is interrupted when Kara’s clapping gets a little too enthusiastic and she accidentally thunder-claps them off the cliff.

Before she hits the ground though, Alex wakes with a start. It seems she fell asleep watching TV after her heart-to-heart with Kelly. Because Kelly is still there.

Kelly on Alex's couch

Maybe she lives there now? Did they U-Haul before they even started dating?

Alex tells her that she had a dream or a memory of Kara, and Kelly thinks it’s probably her brain changing; she has suffered a trauma re: adoption, and her brain is making connections with the parts of her life deeply affected by adoption before. Specifically, Kara.

Alex can tell something is happening in her brain, because she’s starting to feel off again, like she did during the interrogations. Right after her mind was wiped, though she doesn’t know that part. All she knows is that is has to do with Kara.

Alex looking thoughtful

“…and then I was at the DEO, but it didn’t LOOK like the DEO, it looked more like my elementary school, but I KNEW it was the DEO…”

But before she can figure out what’s going on in her brain, Brainy calls. She’s needed at the DEO.

When the black bag is removed from Kara’s head, she finds herself in a room with some men who clearly don’t know what they’re up against. She easily takes them out, but as soon as she opens the door to make her escape, Kaznian Kara is there with some Kryptonite to knock her out.

Red Daughter holds a box of kryptonite

Worst Promposal ever.

Back at the DEO, Brainy and Lena tell Alex about how Lockwood took the Harun-El, Kara thinks Lockwood and Lex are connected, and about the found a Supergirl clone called the Red Daughter. They break to do their tasks, Alex to find the Red Daughter, Brainy to get J’onn to save the aliens being rounded up for Lex to harness their powers, and also to tell Dreamer loves her. That last task got Lena good.

Lena looks amused

“Telling the girl you love how you really feel? What a concept!”

Lena is going to talk to Lockwood and see if she can find out where Lex is. Before she leaves, Alex asks Lena where Kara is, and Lena assures her she’s just in DC and is totally fine.

But in actuality, Kara is slightly less than fine, being held captive by a girl who has her face and an intense wig.

Kaznian Kara faces off with our Kara

As someone who is obsessed with Orphan Black and currently making my way through The Vampire Diaries, this delights me.

Kara tries to reason with her, to tell her Lex is a liar and will turn on her, but the Red Daughter is sure Kara is the villain here, protecting this corrupt country rife with ugliness and gluttony. But while she’s giving her hero’s speech, the Red Daughter is starting to feel weakened by the Kryptonite. And lucky for Kara, she’s built up an ever-so-slightly higher tolerance to it, so she uses this opportunity to break free and fly away.

Kara shows up at J’onn’s door, injured and so… defeated. She really thought she was at the finish line, evidence in hand, putting down her cape and winning the fight with her research and journalism. But then everything fell apart around her. What’s more, Lex knows that Kara is Supergirl, which means Alex is in more danger than usual, and she really wants to tell Alex the truth so she knows the stakes. But J’onn warns her against that. Telling Alex the truth after J’onn so carefully tucked it away in her brain could cause her to go insane. The only way she can know is if the walls he built in her brain come down on their own. Kara is so, so sad.

Kara's eyes are filled with tears

This exhausted cry is so relatable it hurts.

Brainy comes by and tells them what everyone is up to, so Kara runs off to join the fight.

Before Lena goes to see Lockwood like she said, she goes to see her mother, who is in her lab. Because Lena bought her prison and got her a weekend off. Because of course she did. Lena slaps a baby truth seeker alien on her mother’s arm and starts asking her questions.

Lena starts with a test and asks about a high school boyfriend. Lillian blurts out that she paid him to leave Lena alone. Since this confirmed Lena’s suspicions, she starts asking her about a procedure to extract the Harun-El. Lillian knows she can do it, and as an incentive to do it quickly, Lena informs her mother that she has poisoned her and she has 24 hours to do as she’s told or she won’t get Lena’s antidote.

Lena holding antidote

Frankly this seems way more fun than the knock-down, drag-out screaming matches my mom and I would have.

Before Lena can leave, Lillian blurts out one more truth, but this is one Lena didn’t suspect: Lillian says she loves her.

Lena looks surprised

Lillian’s love language is scheming.

After leaving her mother, Lena heads to a parking garage to confront Lockwood, which is a role reversal I’m into. Lena asks where Lex is, and it quickly becomes clear that he has no idea that Lex Luthor has been the puppetmaster of his life for the past few years. Lockwood looks a little ill, his hair is falling out, and he’s mad. He starts yelling at Lena, but she yells back, saying he’s dooming humanity.

Lena looks surprised

I know there was a conversation happening but all I could think about is whether this was a new suit or the same one, and how good her eyes look in this normally-unflattering lighting.

After she leaves him and gets back in James’ car, Lena tells James that Lockwood is deteriorating because of the untested Harun-El he stole. She almost calls the mission a bust, but then Lockwood speeds away and they realize he could lead them somewhere useful.

J’onn, Brainy, and Dreamer follow one of Nia’s visions to a shipping company where they find a lot of the aliens rounded up in raids being packed into shipping trucks. Dreamer has a plan.

Dreamer looks VERY CUTE also determined

I really respected the fact that Dreamer pitched her plan, and when it was deemed too dangerous, she didn’t fight or push or pout. She’s such a team player.

But J’onn and Brainy think it might be too dangerous. So instead, J’onn is going to do a fly-over to see what he can see before they decide what their next move is. But while he’s gone, Brainy is so frazzled from almost confessing his love to Nia that he agrees to do things her way and they head into the fray with Brainy pretending to be Lockwood and Nia pretending to be his prisoner.

At the DEO, Alex is startled when Supergirl swoops in to tell her that the President is working with Lex. But Alex trusts her, so she immediately shuts off the cameras so they can work in private. Alex starts using sunlamps to get Supergirl back up to full strength, talking about what it’s like to absorb the sun’s energy, when Col. Haley bursts in, horrified to see Public Enemy #1 in her Director’s lab.

Alex looks busted

“I KNOW you said we couldn’t have a puppy but LOOK AT HER.”

Alex tells her the whole thing about the Supergirl copy and the President being corrupt Haley is immediately on board with taking them all down.

Brainy and Dreamer’s ruse is found out almost immediately and they’re split up, despite their protesting. Brainy is tortured and worried about Dreamer and eventually his ancestral memories flood his brain and his emotional boxes get smashed to bits and he’s essentially, in his words, rebooted. Suddenly he’s cold and emotionless. He’s not our Brainy anymore. He’s Brainiac 5.

Alex, Kara, and Haley exchange info and brainstorm and realize that they have to find the Red Daughter before she causes any more havoc in Supergirl’s name.

Alex stands with her hands on her hips, Supergirl with her arms crossed

Both Danvers girls in power stances makes my heart flutter.

They find an address, and Supergirl insists on going alone. Alex thinks it’s weird that Supergirl is so insistent she not join her on this mission, but she hangs back.

When Supergirl gets to the Red Daughter’s apartment, it’s eerily similar to Kara’s loft. As she slowly looks around, she realizes she’s been stalked but good. #YouonLifetime

Get it? Because the Red Daughter is like a mirror-universe version of herself?

At the compound, Brainy’s voice is deep and scary, and despite his humanity switch being entirely turned off, he does concede to J’onn that they can go save Dreamer, because she might be useful. When he finds her though, he doesn’t save her. He tells her to astral project from the other side once she’s fully kidnapped, then knocks J’onn out so he’ll get caught too, and walks coldly away.

Dreamer looks confused

“I swear to Rao if you show me your evil nipple eyeball right now…”

Lockwood is still deteriorating, so he gives himself another injection of Harun-El and storms into a safe house to confront Otis, who confirms everything Lena said about Lex pulling his puppet strings. Lena and James creep in and watch from the rafters as Lockwood realizes that no one else believes in his cause like he does, and that all Lex wants is to fake an attack from Kaznia so he can be the hero.

Otis says that now that Lockwood knows, he has to die, and a fight breaks out. James tries to intervene, but his head starts to hurt and he’s incapacitated.

Kara is looking at a sketch of Alex in the Red Daughter’s journal, along with a photo of Mikhail, when Alex busts in, confused as to why the apartment looks so much like Kara’s. She realizes that you can see into Kara’s loft from this apartment, and starts to panic; she hadn’t considered her normal human sister could be this caught up in all this. She describes the way she worries about Kara feeling like part of her heart is just running around in the world, unprotected.

Alex looks out the window

“All the pieces, pieces, pieces of me.”

As Alex tries to collect herself, Supergirl puts her hand on Alex’s, comforting her. Before Alex can examine why it doesn’t feel as weird as it should that her coworker is holding her hand, her mom calls her and tells her that Kara is there. Alex is relieved to hear that, until Supergirl panics and says that Eliza is not safe.

Alex is on the phone and looks scared

Insert “you in danger, girl” meme here.

Supergirl flies to Midvale as fast as she can, and the Red Daughter is there, furious at the life Kara had that she didn’t. Kara tries to reason with her, she knows the Red Daughter is having doubts about Lex, but she snaps and says his name is Alex.

Red Daughter dressed as Kara looks mad, standing behind Eliza

My kingdom for the unaired scenes when Red Daughter is trying to impersonate Kara but Eliza totally figures it out and plays along.

Supergirl tries one more time to connect with the Red Daughter, mentioning Mikhail, but instead of being the bonding agent she hoped, it sets her off, because she thinks Americans killed the little boy she cared about. The Red Daughter suits up in her new supersuit, complete with helmet, and flies outside. Supergirl is hot on her tail, and they do some pretty epic fighting in the sky. But the Red Daughter has some kind of purple lightning situation, and punches Supergirl with it so hard, possibly into next Tuesday? Because suddenly it’s dark. And they fall to the ground, where they fight some more.

Alex rolls up on her motorcycle, and when she sees Supergirl getting punched, memories start flooding back to her. She remembers moments in their childhood when Kara would use her powers. She remembers pivotal moments they shared as adults. She remembers the moment Kara saved the falling plane she was on. Laughter and tears, pizza toasts and the time she fell off the clip but Kara saved her. She remembers everything.

Alex looks overwhelmed but not necessarily in a bad way

From every time they saved each other’s lives to every time Kara stole her clothes without asking.

So she runs to save Supergirl. To save her sister. But by the time she gets there, the Red Daughter has already heard Supergirl’s heart stop beating and flown away. She does stop for a moment as she watches Alex cry over her sister’s unmoving body.

Alex tries to listen for a heartbeat, pleading with her little sister, she remembers, to come back to her. Alex says she knows her Kara, and Kara doesn’t quit.

Alex listens desperately for Kara's heartbeat

Filed under Images That Will Haunt My Broken Heart Forever

Eliza watches and cries as her oldest daughter cradles her youngest. Two pieces of her heart, breaking right in front of her. Between sobs, Alex insists Kara will be fine. She’s only not healing because there’s not enough sun. But there’s sunlight in everything! So she starts shoving handfuls of grass into Kara’s hands, begging her to use the sunlight in the leaves to heal herself. It felt very, “He can’t see without his glasses” and it hurt my feelings.

But then streaks of brightness start to glow around them, and Eliza tells Alex to look. Kara is pulling in the sunlight.

Alex watches as Kara pulls the sunlight

“Deep in the meadow, under the willow, a bed of grass, a soft green pillow. Lay down your head and close your eyes, and when they open, the sun will rise.”

And that’s how Kara always gets back up when she gets knocked down, isn’t it? No matter how many times she’s defeated, how many people tell her she can’t, whether it’s running into issues at CatCo or red tape at the DEO, fighting family members or losing friends, every time it seems that by all measures, Kara Danvers should be defeated by the darkness, she starts pulling in the sunlight. Even though sometimes Alex needs to remind her she can.

When Kara finally wakes up again, and she sees her sister looking down at her with love in her eyes despite being in the Supersuit, she says, “I’ve missed you.” The sisters are reunited. Finally.

Back in Lena’s lab, Lena is going to have Lillian extract the Harun-El so James won’t be in pain anymore, but James wants to keep his strength because the season finale is next week and Rao knows he’ll need it. So instead, they give him another dose. To thank her mother for all her help today, she gives her the antidote.

Lena hands over the antidote with a smirk

Happy Mother’s Day

While debriefing and reconnecting, Alex and Kara get a call from Col. Haley. Lex’s plan has come to fruition. The president is on TV, saying Kaznia attacked, lead by Supergirl, and that Lex Luthor saved the day.

Alex and Kara watch the news and look upset

“Just because everything’s changing doesn’t mean it’s never been this way before. All you can do is try to know who your friends are as you head off to the war.”

Things look darker than they have in long time, but as long as she has Alex by her side, Kara will be able to pull the sunlight and get through it.

See you next week for the Season Four finale!

Before you go! Autostraddle runs on the reader support of our AF+ Members. If this article meant something to you today — if it informed you or made you smile or feel seen, will you consider joining AF and supporting the people who make this queer media site possible?

Join AF+!

Valerie Anne

Just a TV-loving, Twitter-addicted nerd who loves reading, watching, and writing about stories. One part Kara Danvers, two parts Waverly Earp, a dash of Cosima and an extra helping of my own brand of weirdo.

Valerie has written 560 articles for us.


  1. Sounds like they overstuffed this episode with too many storylines. Also, did we know that Kara could pull sunlight from plants and stuff? I haven’t really been watching Season 4 but is this weird Kryptonian photosynthesis doohickey a new development from this season or is it something we’re supposed to know she can do?

    • I don’t think it’s been shown in the series before, but it has happened in the comics occasionally with Superman.

    • I think she didn’t think of it until her scientist sister thought of it in her desperation and pressed the blades of grass into her hand.

  2. The chemistry between Lena and Alex is REAL even in that short scene. Damn.

    I have to say these last few episodes have been really good and I could not be happier that Alex has her memories back. I’ve missed them too!

    Great recap as always Valerie.

  3. It felt very, “He can’t see without his glasses” and it hurt my feelings.

    This is the perfect description.

    Also… 😭😭😭

  4. I wonder what the DEO storyline will be going forward. The entire purpose of the DEO is to apprehend and contain dangerous aliens. But with the way they’ve hammered the “Aliens pose no threat to us” message, can they really go back to aliens being the big bad?

    • I personally think alex will leave the deo and use her medical training to have a clinic for aliens who are sick.

  5. I will admit, I totally was crying in that scene where Kara died. I mean, I knew they couldn’t leave her dead, of course, but it was so so well done, and the chemistry between Alex and Kara as sisters that have effectively been separated for so long was seriously great.

    This whole episode was quite excellent I thought, even though really it was mostly about setting up for the finale.

  6. Shoutout to Jessee Rath for his intense portrayal of Brainy refusing to regenerate, I mean, reboot, and Sam Witwer for his hilarious portrayal of Brainy being so discrete.


    It seems the good ship BraiNia sails the same cursed waters as the S.S. FitzSimmons.

    • I’d say it’s 75% likely that love for Nia snaps Brainy out of it next week; and 25% likely that the same thing happens, but not until he’s the Big Bad for a while next year.

Comments are closed.