On her various social media platforms yesterday, trans performer, singer, classical pianist and Daniel Radcliffe’s friend Our Lady J announced that she has been officially hired as a staff writer for the second season of Amazon’s hit series Transparent. The show has been praised for it’s sympathetic and often very authentic portrayal of its trans characters and storylines and for its hiring of 25 trans people in its cast and crew including Alexandra Billings as a supporting actress and Zackary Drucker as a producer, actress and consultant. However, the show didn’t have a trans woman on its writing staff for the first season. That’s all changing now, as Our Lady J will be filling that much needed role.
Our Lady J announced on Instagram and Facebook, “I’m so happy to announce that I’ll be taking the next year off from touring to dedicate my life to the Pfefferman’s as staff writer for season two of #transparenttv. Thank you for having faith in me, @jillsoloway. The world is beginning to see us as we have seen ourselves.” Although the show did have trans consultants helping on the scripts for the first season, Our Lady J will be the first trans woman who is a full-time writer for the show.
Back in October, show creator Jill Soloway announced that for the second season of the show, she would be seeking out a writer who had a transfeminine perspective to join the staff, noting that “No matter what we did, we were always going to be otherising Maura in some way. And in the same way where I wouldn’t want a man to say, ‘I can have a writers’ room full of men and we can write women just fine,’ I can’t say that I can create a show about a trans woman and not have a trans woman writing for me.” Soloway then developed a writers workshop for trans women specifically to help them develop their television writing skills. She hoped that in doing this, she would not only possibly find someone to hire for Transparent, but she would help create a pool of trans writers who all had spec scripts and some industry experience that other shows could pull from.
However, there are many who criticize Transparent. First of all, the show stars Jeffrey Tambor as Maura, and although he does a wonderful acting job, the fact remains that casting cis men as trans women not only takes jobs that could go to trans actors, it also helps to reinforce the idea that trans women are men. Additionally, Transparent tells the story of a well-off, older, white trans woman with a family, a story that has been told many times already. Many trans women of color and younger trans people have said that although they think the show is well made, they don’t really see themselves or their experiences reflected very much in it. Some even found Solloway’s announcement that she would be mentoring trans women writers to be a bit condescending. There’s also the fact that having just one trans woman on the writing staff who is supposed to represent All Trans Women is not really the ideal situation. And as you might remember, Mari and I both had very conflicted feelings about the show before it came out.
This happened. And it was joyous. @ourladyj @reinagossett @zackarydrucker @JuliaSerano @shadipetosky @jillsoloway pic.twitter.com/hahSgxnnDz
— Jen Richards (@SmartAssJen) November 26, 2014
After hosting this workshop, Soloway did end up finding a writer who fit what she was looking for in Our Lady J. Based on other twitter posts, it seems like some of the other writers who were a part of this trans women writers workshop were Jen Richards, Reina Gossett, Julia Serano, Shadi Petosky and the aforementioned Drucker. Jen Richards took to twitter to congratulate Our Lady J, saying, “I’ve never been so happy to learn that someone else got something I wanted. I guess that’s real love & sisterhood. What a blessed feeling.”
It will be very interesting to see what Our Lady J’s writing adds to the next season. As a fan of the show who also recognizes its flaws, I’m very excited that the show will be adding a trans woman as a staff writer. As a trans woman, I’m very excited that trans women are getting opportunities like this. Hopefully not only will Transparent continue to expand its trans women inclusive behavior, but other shows will soon follow suit.
This is good news.
Friends have asked me if Transparent is a good place to start for learning about trans* “stuff,” and I’ve told them it absolutely isn’t, and explained a few of the more problematic issues it has. But then I tell them to watch it anyway, but approach it as the story of a person who’s going through a life change while wrangling three hilariously screwed up (nominally adult) children.
The addition of Our Lady J to the writing staff makes me just that much more anxious to see Season 2.
Mixed feelings. Personally, I’m not a fan of many of the statements Our Lady J has made in past, including her rather ugly dismissal of any criticism of RuPaul’s actions on his show. She’s certainly a talented muscian (although I’m not into her compositions) but of all the people in the trans community who have writing backgrounds, she would be low on my list… kind of on the same level as if it were announced Calpernia Addams, or Andrea James would be working on Transparent. I think she was hired to confirm the direction the show is going in terms of trans representation instead of adding new perspectives. I think Shadi Petosky would have been a much better choice as she has a lot more experience with story development.
Just to put it in perspective, I’m a white, Jewish, west coast, ‘older transitioner’ who’s also a parent and it’s not like I see myself in the series either.
I had exactly the same reaction. I guess there’ll be a lot of people saying “t—-y” on the show, if she has anything to say about it. She’s the last person I wanted to see get that job.
Also: I don’t see myself on the show, either, and I’m a white, Jewish, east coast older transitioner (although I was 45, not 70, and always had “passing privilege”) who’s a parent. Even apart from the specifically trans-related issues, being Jewish means something very different to me from what it seems to mean for the people on the show (perhaps because I’m the daughter of a Holocaust survivor). For another, my son was 15 when I transitioned, not an adult, which presented different issues from transitioning when one has adult children. Plus my son and I were a lot closer than Maura seems to be with her children, and he was considerably more loving and accepting of me. It probably helped that I was the same towards him when he came out to me as gay at the age of 12. Nine years after my transition, we remain as close as ever.
That is a beautiful Tweet. I’m excited to see how the future of this show develops!
Jen Richards would have been a far better choice.
I am glad a trans woman is on the show.
I am not glad it’s this one.
I can be both.