We may earn a commission through product links on this page. But we only recommend stuff we love.

How to DIY an “A League of Their Own” Halloween Costume

Between A League of Their Own and Yellowjackets, I personally cannot wait to see so many hot dykes in sports uniforms at Halloween this year. Both have so much potential for group costume possibilities! Perhaps you have already decided to become a Rockford Peach this Halloween. Perhaps you have already discovered that there aren’t a whole lot of already made costumes readily available online. WHY? Idk, probs homophobia tbh! But if you’re determined to make all your ALOTO dreams come true, I’m here to help. One of my most specific and niche skills in life is being very resourceful when it comes to planning and executing Halloween costumes.

Let me preface this guide by saying: I am not a DIY expert in the traditional sense! I don’t know how to sew. I don’t have a lot of artistic abilities. And while I enjoy crafts, I wouldn’t really consider myself crafty. That said, as aforementioned, I am incredibly resourceful when it comes to costuming — especially on a budget! I’m good at cobbling together costumes with a mix of store-bought and handmade items that don’t require too many technical skills. Some of my most iconic Halloween costumes — including a DIY Silk Spectre costume in 2011 — have been made entirely from thrifted components. I’m here today to tell you how to make an A League of Their Own Rockford Peaches costume that’s going to have a little bit of a DIY, scrappy approach but ultimately still have you looking fine and recognizably like the Peach you are. You won’t be building something from scratch, but you’ll be fashioning together a costume that’s distinctly yours.

There are of course some shortcuts you could take. Spirit Halloween has an official licensed Rockford Peaches costume for $50, but it appears more inspired by the film than by the new series. It also is only offered in sizes S-XL. (Am*zon’s also got some.) Spirit can sometimes work in a pinch for pop culture costumes, but if you have the time to plan a little more, I think you could end up with something more comfortable and more customizable. For around the same price, Etsy also has these dresses that look kind of like the uniforms but have more an actual dress look than a uniform look, but I suppose it could also be a workaround. And if you can sew, there are also patterns available for the dresses.

Another shortcut you could take is to skirt around the uniform approach and instead dress like a specific character from the show. I made a series of style guides for Greta, Carson, Max, Jo, Jess, and Lupe that are geared more toward channeling their looks in an everyday, practical sense rather than to costuming, but you could look at them for inspiration! A Greta/Carson couples costume could be very cute! Or a Max/Clance joint costume with your best friend could also be cute!

But if you have your heart set on a Rockford Peaches uniform, let’s get down to business. I’ll break down the essential components you’re going to need and link some purchasable options, but I also encourage you to use this as an inspirational guide rather than a super strict how-to. Go forth and thrift some of the pieces or add your own touches.

Edit: Shoutout to the commenter who plugged her Etsy shop! To support a fellow Autostraddle reader (and member!), check out thatgoodfluff’s League of Their Own costumes.


1. Skirt (or pants!!!!!!)

A pleated pink skirtYes, to be completely authentic, you actually need a dress. But short of those limited (and perhaps not very good quality!) shortcut options above, “baseball dress uniform” is not something you can find easily online or in a store. So, instead, I recommend going with a skirt + shirt combo as a workaround. The main Rockford Peaches uniform is a pale pink, though tbh I think you could get away with a cream or even white colorway. This ASOS pleated skirt ($19) could work, and once again Amazon does have some options, but I understand if you don’t want to purchase from there. This Etsy skirt is pricier ($38+) but goes up to a 3XL. Here’s the key if you want to hunt around online for a brand/sizing/price point that best suits you: If you want a shorter skirt (think: Slutty Rockford Peaches, which tbh is the vibe I will be going with if I choose to do a an ALOTO costume this year), then search for “tennis skirt” or “pleated mini skirt” and then filter for color (the tough thing here is the color! it’s like a VERY pale pink!). If you want a slightly more authentic skirt, search for “skater skirt” and add “knee length” to get more specific. This is also an opportunity to be resourceful at a Spirit Halloween or similar costume shop. A lot of those chain costume shops sell costume separates in addition to full sets, and it’s possible you could find a pale pink or cream skirt meant to be part of a cheerleader costume or something similar and repurpose it. I somehow have more than one cheerleading skirt from Spirit.

Pale pink pants

Also, here’s something to keep in mind: You don’t have to wear a skirt! Just because the Peaches were forced to wear skirts does not mean you have to be. Want to add some butch touches to a Peaches costume? Buy some track pants in cream or pale pink! These ones are $11 and look cozy as fuck. I’m sure you’ll get lots of wear out of them beyond the holiday. And for what it’s worth, I actually found a lot more pants options in the correct shade of pink than I did skirts, so this might be the move in general! Also, if you live somewhere cold, this’ll be more comfy.

2. Shirt + Patch

Rockford Peaches patch

If you’re going the skirt route, then you’re gonna need a shirt. Yes, you could shell out for a real baseball jersey, but it’s going to be 1. expensive and 2. not even all that accurate looking, because the dress uniforms worn by the Peaches button-close off-center, and most baseball jerseys button down the center. This is the part where I plug one of my favorite chain stores on the planet: Michael’s craft store. I know I said I’m not crafty, but I do have a Michael’s rewards program membership, so maybe the lady doth protest too much. Here’s my cheater uniform recommendation: Get a t-shirt from Michael’s that best matches the color of your skirt. Get a Rockford Peaches patch ($14+) and attach it with fabric glue. VOILA. If you want to add an extra layer of cuteness/baseball-ness, you could throw an unbuttoned baseball jersey over the shirt and even customize it if you want to. You could even get wild with it. For example, you could get a baseball jersey that says ROCKFORD DYKES rather than Rockford Peaches on it. Just an idea!!!!!!

3. Belt

A read pleather beltYou don’t even need a skirt with belt loops to rock the signature belted Peach look. Don’t overthink things, baby! This is definitely an item you could pick up at a thrift store. Or you could buy one for $18 at Nordstrom Rack (and hey, the best thing about buying real clothes/accessories for a costume rather than costume pieces is that you can probably get a decent amount of wear out of them beyond Halloween!).

4. Athletic Socks

Athletic socks

I am extremely biased, but I think you should go off-book here and wear the Autostraddle Gay Chaos socks. But if you want something more authentic, go with a knee-high sock in a shade of red similar to whatever belt you end up with. Fun fact: Most of the athletic socks — other than the Autostraddle Gay Chaos socks — I own were indeed purchased from Spirit Halloween. I’m realizing now just how often I shop at Spirit Halloween????? But also I feel like I’ve never purchased one of their complete sets before. It’s so much more fun to customize/cobble!

5. Hat

A vintage red baseball cap with an R on itHere’s the thing: I saved the hat for last even though it is the most important component. I think you can really have a lot of fun with the rest of the costume and go off-book in little, personalized ways. So long as you wear the hat. Maybe you can’t find the exact right length skirt in the exact right color. But if you’ve got the hat, people are going to know what you’re doing. Or, at least, the people who matter will. Lucky for you, there are like SO MANY Rockford Peaches hats on Etsy. I’m partial to this vintage one ($30), but there are seriously so many options, just see for yourself. But you could also just buy the patch and take that fabric glue back out and affix it to a plain red ball cap from — you guessed it! — Michael’s craft store.

As for the finishing details, I again encourage you to not overthink things. Wear a pair of sneakers you already own. Borrow a baseball bat from your jock friend or buy a cheap child-size one. Wear a red lipstick to match the red accents of the uniform — or don’t! Again, if you’ve got a couple of the specific touches like the hat and the logo patch, you’re going to recognizably be a Peach. There’s no need to get too hung up on authenticity. I believe Halloween costumes should be identifiable but still showcase personality! Swing for the fences and have a very League of Their Own Halloween.


Before you go! It costs money to make indie queer media, and frankly, we need more members to survive 2023As thanks for LITERALLY keeping us alive, A+ members get access to bonus content, extra Saturday puzzles, and more! Will you join? Cancel anytime.

Join A+!

Kayla Kumari Upadhyaya

Kayla Kumari Upadhyaya is the managing editor of Autostraddle and a lesbian writer of essays, short stories, and pop culture criticism living in Miami. She is the assistant managing editor of TriQuarterly, and her short stories appear or are forthcoming in McSweeney's Quarterly Concern, Joyland, Catapult, The Offing, and more. Some of her pop culture writing can be found at The A.V. Club, Vulture, The Cut, and others. You can follow her on Twitter or Instagram and learn more about her work on her website.

Kayla has written 458 articles for us.

9 Comments

  1. YESSS it’s weirdly so hard to find ALOTO uniforms that are the new series version, not the old movie version!! This bothered me so much I actually made my own. My hat/jerseys/shirts are pretty high up in several of the Etsy searches you linked above :) I strongly support doing it however the hell you want, but if anyone’s specifically wanting the 2022 designs, or just wanting to buy from a fellow ‘straddler, this is me.

  2. So excited to see this article!! Flagging a few additional ways folks can make their costumes more TV show-specific (because as the commenter above mentions, so much of the ALOTO swag is the old movie version), if that’s what you’re going for!

    1. If you buy either of the more official-looking costumes linked in the article, you may also want to obtain some large red buttons and replace the white ones it comes with, with your new red ones, as the costumes in the new series have red buttons.

    2. Make sure you get a patch with a red background — I found this one on Etsy, which is iron-on. It hasn’t arrived yet, so I haven’t been able to test whether it’ll easily iron-on over the patch that comes on the uniform I bought, but it seems to be a larger size than the one on the uniform, so I’m feeling hopeful that it’ll cover up the original patch and stick to the uniform well!

    3. Make sure your hat doesn’t have the white circle behind the “R” — that’s another small change that the TV series made. Or, you can do as I’m doing, and go a little rogue here to more purposefully flag to your fellow queers: I bought this “Fruits” hat, which coincidentally happens to be sold by the commenter above?!?! (Because of course — should have known that shop was run by a fellow ‘straddler.)

    4. Get yourself red stirrup baseball socks — in the series, they specifically wear stirrup socks. :)

    Of course, a Peaches costume will be recognizable without all of this and can/should be personalized however you wish, as the post says, but as someone who’s spent a lot of time in the last few weeks thinking about this, wanted to offer these suggestions!

  3. I bought the spirt one last month and they had it in plus size so I’m lucky.
    I’m switching the buttons to red, and finding some cute shorts to wear under the dress (btw I haven’t worn a dress in 30 years)
    I found the updated patches on esty as well, with the jersey number I want, but haven’t pulled the trigger because I think one of my sewing friends might be able to make some of it cheaper.
    I also have a wooden bat like the proper tomboy I am.
    I 100% support this article and costume!

  4. I cannot vouch for their quality/accuracy, but I have also found that there exist some more-show-accurate premade costumes — complete with red patch, stirrup socks, and a very weird screengrab of Carson Shaw.

    These ones are findable on ebay via a search like “A League of Their Own Cosplay Costume.” May the ebay gods be with you.

Contribute to the conversation...

Yay! You've decided to leave a comment. That's fantastic. Please keep in mind that comments are moderated by the guidelines laid out in our comment policy. Let's have a personal and meaningful conversation and thanks for stopping by!