In Attics and Cellars: Hunting Down Queer Women’s Performances at the Edinburgh Fringe

Edinburgh is a magical place at any time of year: winding cobbled streets, tall granite buildings that think they’re castles, all the independent shops and cafés you could ever visit and even a lingering sweet malty scent in the air from the breweries at its edges. It’s even better in August, though, when every spare space in the city is full of performers putting on shows in cellars, attics, theatres and sheds as part of the world’s arts festival, the Edinburgh Fringe.

It often feels like queer women in theatre are kept behind the scenes, flicking the lights or managing the venue; not telling their stories. With a programme that profiles 2,695 shows, finding LGB performances is pretty daunting, but amongst the loud voices and big adverts there are some stunning shows — and the best thing is, you could see them all in a weekend. I tracked down these shows by asking friends, by word-of-mouth, and by hunting down companies I’d enjoyed seeing in years past — all of them are well worth a visit.

The most Google-friendly LGB show at the Fringe this year is New York parody musical Miserable Lesbiansone look at their YouTube video and there’s Anne Muffaway singing “I dreamed a dream of open thighs…” They’re not the only big company making slightly ill-advised swipes; there was a bit of a trend this year of shows plonking lesbian characters into plays in a not-very-well-thought-out sort of way, to be the butt of jokes or to add a bit of heaving-cleavage. For LGB women on stage that make you cringe in a good way, it’s best to stick to stand-up.

Anne Muffaway singing in Miserable Lesbians

Anne Muffaway singing in Miserable Lesbians

Comedy is really well catered for at the Fringe by big, heavily commercial venues that tend to take on established stand-up comedians, whereas there’s less and less theatre every year; as big venues get more cautious, there’s increasingly a big divide in programming between them and the smaller ventures that offer more experimental theatre and performance. This is mostly recession logic; theatre has expensive sets and actors to pay. Increasingly, the theatre shows that do go up tend to be smaller, stripped down and with tiny production teams. This can actually be a good thing, as it provides an environment where women can write and play big, complex parts. Most of the best things I saw were one-woman shows: Ciara, Dark Vanilla Jungle, The GB Project and the The Veil are all amazing, and well worth a trip.

Unless you want to catch a really big name act, it can be a lot more rewarding — and a lot cheaper — investigating some of the less well-known venues. The Fringe started with theatre companies showing up uninvited to the city’s bigger International Festival in 1947, keen to showcase their alternative to the theatrical mainstream. The Free Fringe, The Forest Fringe, Summerhall and Northern Stage at St. Stephens keep that outsider spirit alive, and are full of incredible work. You can go to pretty much any show they put on knowing that it’ll be interesting and imaginative, staged because the venue loved it , and not because the performer’s producer turned up waving wads of cash.

The Confessions of a Rabbi’s Daughter

This show is pretty special; you tiptoe into a cheesy, sticky-floored nightclub in the middle of the day to be met with an incredibly gentle one-woman cycle of songs. Emily Rose’s musical tells the story of an Orthodox Jewish woman who falls in love with her best friend, just as she prepares to finally achieve her dream of becoming a Rabbi’s wife. It’s a show about falling in love, struggling to find a place in a repressive community, and keeping hold of a personal relationship with Judaism through it all. It’s not the most polished, but it feels intimate and true.

If it all sounds too sweet for your taste, she’s also doing a show called Synagogue Slut, about her escapades as an interdenominational synagogue reviewer.

1:20pm, Mood Nightclub, free

Executed for Sodomy: the Life Story of Catharina Linck

An all-female cast of three swap roles to tell the true story of cross-dressing soldier Linck, who was put to death in the early eighteenth century for lewd acts with another woman.This didn’t completely blow me away when I saw it in a wintry garage in London, but hopefully it’s warmed up over its Edinburgh run. Although the focus on her trial can make the piece feel heavy going, there are so many fascinating historical details too — like the fact that Linck’s alias Rosenstiel deliberately combined the words for flower and stem, emblems of femininity and masculinity.

6:30pm, C Nova, £7-9.50

My Pregnant Brother

The title might feel stolen from a tasteless shock-documentary, but Johanna Nutter’s one-woman show is a lot more subtle than it sounds. She tells the story of her trans* brother’s pregnancy, and the changes it brought into both their lives — in a raw, intense and completely compelling narrative.

2:50pm, Pleasance Dome, £8-9.00

Walking:Holding Portraits by Rosie Healey

Walking: Holding

The Forest Fringe is Edinburgh’s anarchic home/squat for shows that are less commercial, more experimental and political. Rosana Cade’s one-on-one performance is no exception. You’re sent on a walk through the city, holding hands with a series of strangers — volunteers of all ages, genders and appearances — in a piece designed to provoke spontaneous connections, and examine people’s reactions to different sexualities.

1-3pm and 4-5:30pm, 20th-22nd and 24th August, Out of the Blue Drill Hall, free

Fanny Whittington

Dick’s turned to Fanny, a lesbian feminist orphan, who’s seeking her fortune in London, in a queer political take on the classic English pantomime story. I’ve seen and loved Lashings of Ginger Beer Time!’s cabaret set in previous years; expect pop-cultural references, innuendo, silly songs and loads of gags, as well as plenty of politics in the mix.

8:15pm, Gryphon Venues at the Point Hotel, £7

via Gay Straight Alliance trailer

via Gay Straight Alliance trailer

Gay Straight Alliance

Free comedy! New York comedian Veronica Elizabeth’s brought her monthly show at the Stonewall Inn (yup, that one) to Edinburgh, with a different line-up every night, and even the odd straight stand-up. There’s some great sarcastic digs at OKCupid’s cringy birthday messages, awkward straight-girl questions and a truly disconcerting take on Anne Frank.

10pm, Laughing Horse@The Phoenix free

Tig Notaro: Boyish-Girl Interrupted

Tig Notaro, a stand-up comedian best known for her role on the Sarah Silverman Program, is bringing a show up to Edinburgh for the first time. Last year, she got rave reviews for a brutally honest show that included announcing her breast cancer on stage. Thankfully, she’s now in remission, and she’s enigmatically explained that her new show will be “just me doing my stuff“.

6:45pm, Gilded Balloon, £14.00

Hannah Gadsby: Happiness is a Bedside Table

Hannah Gadsby’s comedy show is a bit darker than last year’s hit Hannah Wants a Wife, which looked at gender stereotypes through art history and time travel. She uses comments from an online troll as the starting point for the story of her weight and body image issues, and the hilarious situations they’ve trapped her in.

4.30pm, Assembly Roxy, £9.00

Take a Break! 

Word of Mouth Café is a really good place to sit out a hangover in ethical comfort – they recycle, source locally and do the best veggie fry-ups in town. They also put on the odd LGBT spoken word night, so have a look out for flyers. Other great places for non-theatre-based hang-outs include gay bar The Street’s pub quiz at 9 p.m. on Wednesdays and the Hunt & Darton Cafe, which is a fully-functioning art installation with – when I went – broccoli-themed waitresses.

It was tough making this list; the Edinburgh line-up is so huge and sprawling and uncategorised that finding any path through it is a struggle. Any Autostraddlers at the Fringe this year? What have you seen that you think is worth a look?

The festival runs until the 26th August, as do all these shows unless otherwise stated. Tickets and more information on Prices vary, and there are also concessions and half price deals available.

Before you go! Autostraddle runs on the reader support of our AF+ Members. If this article meant something to you today — if it informed you or made you smile or feel seen, will you consider joining AF and supporting the people who make this queer media site possible?

Join AF+!

Alice S

Alice has written 3 articles for us.


  1. Yay for Edinburgh. Yay for Fringe. Unfortunately I haven’t been able to immerse myself in it much this year despite being in the theatre sector, but thank you for your article! Gave me at least a glimpse of what is going on!

  2. the fringe is just at the worst possible time of year for students scraping by until uni starts again. it looks so good this year too. i’m only in glasgow and i still never get to go along! always next year. of course if there was talk of a straddler fringe get together it might just force me to spare a few pennies for it! anyone interested? x

      • haha it’s more a case of scraping them off the ground! i’ll see what i can do. i’ve been offered a ticket to see neil gaiman (aaahhh) so if i manage that i’ll definitely try make it along to some of these free events. sorry you didn’t get to see tig! do you know why she cancelled?

        • Neil Gaiman! You lucky thing. I’ve just started reading his new book. Tig had a “medical emergency” which is why she had to cancel but she is apparently ok now & is doing the rest of her shows. I just couldn’t make another night.

  3. I live in Scotland so I get to go every year. This year I saw Hannah Gadsby’s show that was mentioned in the article and it was so good. I had tickets to see Tig Notaro but she ended up cancelling the night I was due to go so I was a bit disappointed but I’m hoping she’ll be back next year.

    Another lesbian comedian that is there this year is Mae Martin. I saw her show last year and she’s hilarious.

      • Good tip, thanks! I’m not actually great on comedy — more of a theatrey person — so feel slightly out of my depth in the rising tide of standup each year.

  4. YOU GUYS. The woman who won the BBC poetry slam is Sophia Walker who is an amazing queer lady and is doing a show called Around the World in 8 Mistakes which is FREE and has been called one of the best Spoken Word events of the Fringe. By people who can see this stuff because they’re already in the UK and not stuck in the states and super sad that she’s missing out on all the poetry fun times… :/

  5. I WISH I WAS AT THE FRINGE RIGHT NOW SO BADLY! I was in a play there in 2010 and it was one of the greatest experiences of my life. I really hope I go back (multiple times) someday.

  6. ALSO, The Events at the Traverse Theatre is a fantastic play with a lesbian lead character. Refreshingly, the story is not at all related to her being gay, it’s just a really moving story that happens to be about a queer woman. i highly recommend.

    • Oh, I’m desperate to go and see that, completely forgot to put it in! Bizarrely, I heard about it originally because David Grieg also wrote the new musical of Charlie and the Chocolate Factory — odd pair of plays to have staged in one year…

  7. This makes me miss Edinburgh!I wish I was there to see Tig, and to hold hands with strangers for theatrical walking of the streets!

    Anyone staying at the hostel on Cockburn Street, be sure to check out the Baked Potato shop opposite the hostel where they have vegan coleslaw that’s amazingly good (the hostel also does a good vegan breakfast fry up). Also, if you’ve got a little more cash to splash, ignore David Bann’s (the high end vegetarian restaurant) and head instead to Black Bo’s. This was my restaurant of choice when living there; fabulously inventive food in a cosy, romantic setting, with a vegan menu and winelist. I really hope both of these establishments are still going strong! They made my year in Edinburgh extra special.

    And check out the anarchist bookshop just off Nicholson Street, Word Power books.

    And, and, and, I could go on. Enjoy!

  8. Ahhh I was in town the first weekend of the Fringe and I wish I had known where all the queers were!

    In any case, I did see a version of Much Ado About Nothing where the guy who played Benedick was blackout drunk. Silver lining?

Comments are closed.