21 Indications That This 1892 Teenage Murderess Was Insane, and By “Insane” I Mean “Gay”

In 1892, the entire country was captivated by the trial of Alice Mitchell, a 19-year-old from a respected Memphis family who’d gone and murdered her ex-fiancee Freda Ward after Ward reneged on their plan to get married and be together forever. The story of Alice and Freda is told by writer, historian and researcher Alexis Coe in the book Alice and Freda Forever: A Murder in Memphis. Coe meticulously researched the girls’ romance, the case against Alice and her trial, revealing the particular social norms and cultural shifts happening at the time w/r/t popular conception of gender roles, class and race that made the case such a sensation.

Nobody doubted that Alice had killed Freda — the murder had occurred in broad daylight in public — but her lawyers needed to prove that she was insane in order to get her committed to an asylum rather than sentenced to death or life imprisonment. Their primary argument: any woman who could be in love with another woman was obviously insane for that reason alone. “Therein lay the brilliance of the present insanity plea,” writes Coe. “It explained what appeared to be inexplicable, and recast a murderess as the sympathetic victim of her own illness.” Nobody used the word “gay” back then, of course, the popular term was “invert” (as you may recall from The Well of Loneliness) and was used to describe humans we’d now categorize as transgender and/or gay.

Unfortunately, my dear queer friends, I worry that many of you are at risk as I suspect you also possess many of these qualities. I fear for the health of your soul!

21 Qualities of Alice Mitchell Presented By The Defense As Part Of Their Case To Prove Her Insanity (And By “Insanity” I Mean “Homosexuality”)

aliceandfreda

1.  “[Her mother] undertook to teach her crocheting, but could not.”

2. She “delighted in marbles and tops.”

3. Her best friend’s older brother asked her to dance this one time and she said no, she’d rather lie in a hammock with her best friend

4. Her face was asymmetrical

5. “She often rode [her horse] bareback.”

6. Her mother suffered “puerperal insanity” following the births of her children and because Alice was her final and most difficult pregnancy, it was therefore obvious that her mother had easily “passed her insanity” onto her daughter, making Alice “someone capable of perverse, unnatural love.”

7. “She was regarded as mentally wrong by young men.”

8. She believed she could marry a woman and that they could have a family together without having children. (“A childless home, to [the doctor’s] mind, served no purpose, and could only be understood as another sign of unreason.”1)

9. She was left-handed

10. She could “pump a [baseball] swing” better than her brother

11. She suffered from nosebleeds during her period, labeled as “vicarious menstruation.”

12. She planned on passing as a man and supporting Freda financially

13. She kept marbles and baseballs in her bedroom

14. She thought she was in love with a woman

15.  She failed to “balk” when the butcher called her a tomboy

16. She enjoyed target shooting with a small rifle

17. She disliked sewing and needlework

18. She suffered from extreme nervous excitement and headaches

19. She was on a baseball team

20. She was a very good climber.

21. “When only four or five years old, she spent much time at a swing in the yard of the family performing such feats upon it as skinning the cat, and hanging by an arm or a leg.”


1. Dr. John Hill Callander testified that “The frankness and sincerity of her manner on this topic was evidence either of a gross delusion or the conception of a person imbecile, or of a child without knowledge of the usual results of matrimony or the connubial state, or of the purpose of the organs of generation in the sexes.”


Check out Alice and Freda Forever: A Murder in Memphis for yourself and learn the whole sordid story. I liked it a lot!


Are you following us on Facebook?

Riese is the 36-year-old CEO, CFO and Editor-in-Chief of Autostraddle.com as well as an award-winning writer, blogger, fictionist, copywriter, video-maker, low-key power lesbian and aspiring cyber-performance artist who grew up in Michigan, lost her mind in New York and then headed West. Her work has appeared in nine books including "The Bigger the Better The Tighter The Sweater: 21 Funny Women on Beauty, Body Image & Other Hazards Of Being Female," magazines including Marie Claire and Curve, and all over the web including Nylon, Queerty, Nerve, Bitch, Emily Books and Jezebel. She had a very popular personal blog once upon a time, and then she recapped The L Word, and then she had the idea to make this place, and now here we all are! In 2016, she was nominated for a GLAAD Award for Outstanding Digital Journalism. Follow her on twitter and instagram.

Riese has written 2554 articles for us.

51 Comments

  1. I am halfway through this book and everything about this whole story is BONKERS, everyone is BONKERS for various reasons, it’s so delicious.

    also re #8: would it….would it have been better if she wanted to adopt? would it have been better if she’d thought they COULD have children? I have questions for this doctor.

    • The prosecution actually took a huge issue with the inclusion of her baseball-playing as evidence, moreso than other ideas presented in the trial. From the book:

      “By the time Lillie confirmed that Alice had been on the baseball team at Miss Higbee’s, as if it were a revelatory admission, Attorney General Peters had heard enough. He took issue with the defense’s emphasis on sports, asserting that it had nothing to do with insanity, nor was it even rare. After all Alice had not started the baseball team at Miss Higbee’s. It existed before she enrolled, and when she joined, her name was added to a roster of other young women who enjoyed sports, but still acted in an otherwise non-homicidal manner.”

    • no, it wasn’t legal! but it also was not entertained or discussed in any way, you know? so even though she’d never heard of a woman marrying another woman, she also didn’t know of any woman being told she couldn’t marry another woman. alice just had it in her head that she could dress up like a man and marry her girlfriend if she wanted to. the fact that she thought this could actually happen is part of what enabled them to convince people that she was insane.

  2. Also, I Googled “lesbian barebacking,” to see if there actually was an equivalent meaning for that. Or because I’m a creepy weirdo with a search history that deserves a warrant. Whatever. At any rate, this is what I found:

    “More unfamiliar, to almost any reader, will be the train of thought that Stockton pursues here: The suggestion that readers, by virtue of reading, are “lesbian” barebackers.”

    So, any of you who are reading (ahem, if you’re on this website, for starters), are also in trouble. This, according to the lecture “Reading as Kissing, Sex with Ideas: ‘Lesbian’ Barebacking?” by Prof. Kathryn Bond Stockton, 2015.

    Brief description here: http://www.haverford.edu/calendar/details/263252

  3. This “sewing as defense against lesbianism” is definitely a thing. In the Old Idaho State Penitentiary there is an excellent parole application letter from a teenage girl who, despite being convicted of bigamy for marrying three men, was accused of being a lesbian.

    Here is her proof she has reformed:

    Since I have come back this time there has been a complete change in my life. I’m letting my hair grow, I wear nice little dresses and wouldn’t think of putting on a pair of slacks, or being tom-boyish. I’m a regular little lady. I’ve been sewing ever since I been back. I’ve made a set of 5 small sofa pillows, a dresser scarf edged with lace, 4 pot holders and a bed spread that contains 54 foot square pieces that I cut out and drew and embroidered.

    Turns out the old pray-away-the-gay adage is a fallacy. You need to sew away the gay.

  4. I think I also fail to “balk” when people call me a tomboy or similar. I should probably work on my balking skills, but I’m not altogether sure how to adequately balk at insinuations. Is there a YouTube tutorial for that?

  5. I read this article yesterday and then dreamt about it last night:

    I was Alice Mitchell and had murdered my beloved. Riese and Laneia were my lawyers, trying to prove I was insane.

    There was a weird repeating cycle where I would be all femme-d up; Laneia would yank off my jewelry, smudge off my makeup, and thrust some baseball item (bat, ball, glove) into my grasp; and then a few minutes later the item would be gone, I’d be all dolled up again, and Laneia would do it all over again while simultaneously complimenting and berating my outfit.

    Riese was interviewing a series of boys: boys I wouldn’t dance with, boys I’d bought marbles from, boys I’d kicked out of trees.

    And all of this was going on while we swung from vines.

Contribute to the conversation...

You must be logged in to post a comment.