Michele Smith Makes History: A Love Letter to Title IX and Women in Sports

Being the softball player who used to pick dandelions in the outfield and only caught a pop fly because she threw up her glove to protect her face, it’s no wonder that I’m astounded by women like Michele Smith. Smith has a mile-long list of accomplishments in softball, including being a part of two-time Olympic gold medal American teams, one in 1996 and another in 2000. She’s got three world titles for Team USA.  She’s a member of the Softball Hall of Fame.  And now she’s got one more to add to her resumé of history-changing things.  She’s the first female analyst for a national broadcast of a Major League Baseball game. TBS had Smith call the Braves-Dodgers game on Sunday. Ladies, you are now welcome in the wide-world of baseball analysis, at least according to one broadcasting booth. And if you are as awesome as Michele Smith.

Michele Smith, via Deadspin

Smith is vocal about Title IX and what that means for women in the sports world. It’s no coincidence that this is the 40th anniversary of Title IX, a law that prevents girls from being discriminated against in any publicly funded school activity, sports included. One can infer from Smith’s comments, as posted on MLB.com, that she thinks the law is directly responsible for the recent successes of female atheltes, coaches, managers and, yes, analysts in the previously male-dominated sports world:

“It opens up the possibility that this is the 40th anniversary of Title IX, and how that ruling has changed women’s sports. If you look back at the last couple of Olympics, and, obviously, ’96 in Atlanta, women’s team sports were just outstanding. We just saw it again this year. Women have more opportunities on the field to make a difference on their lives. We don’t always have the opportunity to go on and have those professional dreams, though. Olympics are often the peak of women’s careers.

“We saw that in London, it’s inspiring,” she said. “These women who competed there are basically a generation of female athletes who have come from moms who have also been in Title IX — especially in team sports. Those of us who were in that era, 1996 Olympians, our moms really didn’t get the benefit of Title IX. They were pre-Title IX women. Now we find a generation of women whose moms competed, and we see the difference it makes in a young girl’s life, to be able to compete in sports and have that camaraderie.”

Ah, Title IX.  Title IX is the reason I was given the chance to suck hard at softball.  Basically, here’s what Title IX says:

No person in the United States shall, on the basis of sex, be excluded from participation in, be denied the benefits of, or be subjected to discrimination under any education program or activity receiving Federal financial assistance.

It says lots of other stuff too. And this was signed into law in 1972. And every time I think about Title IX, I have this complex, conflicting feeling. I love that we have Title IX and that it’s done wonders for women in the sports world. And at the same time I squirm that we need it, or that it’s taken this long to do something as simple as have an extremely qualified female sports analyst comment on a damn baseball game. I mean really, why is it a big deal?

We’ve come a long way, with projects like The Faces of Title IX presented by the National Women’s Law Center highlighting our accomplishments. Thanks to the inclusiveness promoted by Title IX, women can now run in the Boston Marathon and be sports writers and even play sports at all. And it wasn’t that long ago.  These stories are from women still running, still writing today. Title IX doesn’t just apply to sports, either – it covers things like sexual harassment and science, a field we know could use a little more diversification.

The Rockford Peaches. Women were amazing athletes before Title IX (naturally), but now they’re legally protected from discrimination. via bloglovin.com

But then there’s that other creeping feeling, the not so good one. Why were any of the above things ever even questioned? And why does the progress seem so slow? Every time a woman tries to do A Thing in sports, she gets ish for it. Deadspin reported on the sexist, misogynist tweets surrounding Smith’s successful sportscast, many of which questioned her abilities simply due to the simple fact that she is female. Some did not even deny her ability, but just said they didn’t want to listen to her because she was a woman. This on its own isn’t proof of our lingering backwards sports culture, but consider the overwhelming evidence (as if our own personal experiences haven’t been enough). Erin Andrews, an ESPN sportscaster, has had not one but two high-profile harassment cases. In 2009, Michael David Barett stalked Andrews and made a nude video of her by removing the peephole from her hotel door and filming through the opening.  He posted that video online.  In 2011, she was allegedly harassed by Keith Clinksales, an ESPN executive, when he masturbated next to her on an airplane. The first major sexual harassment case that I can remember really following came out of Madison Square Garden, with Isiah Thomas sexually harassing Anucha Browne Sanders and then firing her. Over and over again, we see that many sports foster a hostile environment for women. And when women succeed, sometimes we see a measure of shock and awe like the much of media coverage of how amazing the US Women did at the 2012 London Olympics. Basically these stories have one thing in common: women are assumed incompetent until they prove themselves, and occasionally they are still assumed incompetent after they prove themselves, and these assumptions are almost always based solely on the fact that they are women.

We can fix this. The patriarchy seems so big and scary sometimes, and it is. There’s a lot of dismantling that needs to be done. But people out there are working on it, tirelessly, and have been for quite some time. Take the Women’s Sports Foundation, for instance.

via Women’s Sports Foundation

The Women’s Sports Foundation, founded by tennis player Billie Jean King, advocates for female athletes and provides grants and financial assistance to help with things like traveling to competitions. So let me conclude on an up-note, much like the one I started on. Progress happens, even in the boys club that is Major League Baseball and other professional sports, and we haven’t stopped marching forward. Title IX was a step and look how many steps we’ve marched forward since. We should all congratulate Michele Smith and look forward to the day when a female commenter in professional sports isn’t news because there are so many of them. A girl can dream, can’t she? Even a girl as bad at softball as I am.

Before you go! Autostraddle runs on the reader support of our AF+ Members. If this article meant something to you today — if it informed you or made you smile or feel seen, will you consider joining AF and supporting the people who make this queer media site possible?

Join AF+!

A.E. Osworth

A.E. Osworth is part-time Faculty at The New School, where they teach undergraduates the art of digital storytelling. Their novel, We Are Watching Eliza Bright, about a game developer dealing with harassment (and narrated collectively by a fictional subreddit), is forthcoming from Grand Central Publishing (April 2021) and is available for pre-order now. They have an eight-year freelancing career and you can find their work on Autostraddle (where they used to be the Geekery Editor), Guernica, Quartz, Electric Lit, Paper Darts, Mashable, and drDoctor, among others.

A.E. has written 542 articles for us.


  1. Together with John Sterling, Suzyn Waldman has been co-announcing the Yankees on CBS 880 AM radio out of New York City since 2005. She’s great and really seems to know the game!

  2. Great article! Really made me think back to growing up and being on all those sports teams and how lucky it was that there were the girls teams too.

  3. One of the unforeseen side effects of Title IX was that as women’s sports gained parity and prestige, the chance to coach these teams became much more desirable – to men. Female college coaches are declining in number according to this article on ESPNW (http://espn.go.com/espnw/title-ix/7754090/back-game). It’s my hope the trend eventually reverses itself as more women become embedded in both sports and colleges at the administrative level.

    • That’s an interesting point. In the Olympics too, I noticed an overwhelming majority of male coaches teaching women/female teams. It was really weird to see.

  4. Great article!

    It brings up another thing that’s been bothering me for a long time though. I’m a big Baseball fan and while I have nothing against Softball, I’m really bothered that there’s zero support for women’s Baseball in this country. Women can play Basketball, Tennis and Soccer at a collegiate and professional level, but the one sport this country is best known for is off limits?! I did a little searching and there are women’s Baseball leagues in cities around the country, but no official organization from any school or college and that feels like sexist discrimination.

    I really don’t understand why everyone is okay with this. When you watch a pro Baseball game on TV there are thousands of women in the stands. Don’t they want their daughters to be able to play Baseball if they feel the urge?

    • I’m not a sports person at all – like Ali, I spent the whole of the time that I was forced to play softball in gym class standing in the outfield and praying the ball wouldn’t come near me – but I never understood this either. Besides the size/weight of the ball and the style of pitching, is there any difference between baseball and softball? Also there are co-ed Little League teams, on which girls play baseball. Why not just continue with baseball on a girls-only team? Baffling, really.

  5. I saw a post about those sexist tweets going around on tumblr. The worst part is that most of the men who tweeted wouldn’t even give Michele Smith a chance, or didn’t want to listen to her (regardless of how good her commentary was), just because she’s a woman.

    I feel like, just like the LGBT community needs straight allies, the female community (in sports or science or any other male-dominated arena) needs male allies to stand beside us and tell jerks like that that it’s not okay to disparage someone just because of her gender. Saying we “need men” might not be a popular opinion, but we need as many like-minded individuals as possible, regardless of their gender, to stand up to the misogynistic, sexist jerks of the world.

Comments are closed.