Wolfe Video Movie Night: The Four-Faced Liar

By Kate & Carolyn

Welcome to Movie Night, where we choose a movie based on any number of variables and feelings, create a themed menu to match, then spend hours eating these foods and watching these movies!

This edition is a little wet, since The Four-Faced Liar is named after a real bar in the West Village, and the characters drink a lot more than they eat. Granted they’re seniors in college, which means they’re probably eating a lot of junk food and microwavable dinners and throwing together whatever shit they’ve got left in the fridge at the end of the week. And, of course, washing all that down with booze and tea. Our recipes are a little more appetizing, we promise.

I can be both. I can be! I can be the unreliable douchnozzle who grabs her ass in public and wears work boots but I could also be the one who holds doors for her and tucks her in at night and buys her fucking gerber daisies for no goddamned reason! – Bridget


The Movie

[Buy Me]



A story of love and lies for four twenty-somethings looking to find themselves in New York City. A pair of best friends and a seemingly perfect couple meet at a local Irish pub tucked in the winding streets of the West Village. Through their chance meeting, the four bond and over time all of their relationships with one another morph into love, betrayal and heartbreak for all.

I don’t know what it is about this movie. According to my calculations, I’ve seen Four-Faced Liar 16 times. Sixteen times! I don’t think I’ve even seen the The Lord of the Rings trilogy that many times, and pedin i phith in aníron, a nin ú-cheniathagir. At first I didn’t actually know there were lesbians in the plot. You can imagine my glee when lo and behold the main character Bridget is a womanizing lady who lives in a shitty apartment with her best guy friend, and falls for the new straight girl, Molly, who has already shacked up with the man she imagines she’ll marry. Complications ensue, and the complications are familiar to anyone who has ever been a twenty-something who thinks they can chainsmoke their emotions away.

Okay, uh, look at modern literature. All of the greatest female characters were written by a woman because no man could ever write from a female’s perspective. Women have this compassionate chemistry that allows them to listen with an unbiased ear. All women, even you. – Molly

You can rent Four-Faced Liar directly from Wolfe Video — our favorite lesbian-owned distributer of LGBT films — right now! When you rent through this embedded player, you’re supporting both Wolfe Video and AND Autostraddle, your favorite queer-owned distributor of everything that kicks ass.

There are so many things about this movie that speak to the experiences of all us quarter-life crises tripping through relationships, finding love crumpled in our back pockets and stuck to old receipts with gum. There’s one scene in particular where Molly is staying at Bridget’s place, and while they’re not sleeping together yet, the little moments that reveal the palpable tension were so achingly familiar to me that it felt like someone had brought a camera into my life. Some of the dialogue feels like things my friends and I have said time and time again, and fun fact, Marja Lewis Ryan, who plays Bridget, also wrote the screenplay, based on her earlier play.


Breaded Tilapia
Sweet Potato Fries
Chilli Aioli

Grand Marnier


Fish and chips are totally appropriate for Four-Faced Liar because the movie is mostly about a bar and they drink a ton. Baking everything in the oven instead of frying it in oil keeps this menu simple and far healthier and tastier than (most) real pub food. Also like most real pub food, everything here goes well with beer.

Breaded Tilapia


2 fish fillets, skin removed (I used tilapia, but any white-fleshed fish will do)
1 cup panko breadcrumbs
2 tbsp. olive oil
1 tbsp. thyme
salt and pepper to taste


1. Pat the fillets dry and arrange on a parchment-paper-lined baking sheet.
2. In a bowl, combine breadcrumbs, olive oil, thyme and salt and pepper.
3. Spread mixture evenly on top of fish and pat gently to adhere.
4. Bake at 425 degrees for 10 to 12 minutes, depending on the size of the fillets. (Ideally, you want to preheat the oven, make the fries and start to bake them, then make the fish and put it in after about 35 minutes, then make the aioli while you wait and finish everything at the same time.)


Sweet Potato Fries


2 sweet potatoes
1 tbsp. olive oil
1 tsp. chopped fresh thyme
salt and pepper to taste


1. Preheat the oven to 425 degrees F. Scrub the potatoes and cut in a French-fry like manner. Pat dry with paper towel.
2. Toss fries with olive oil, thyme, and salt and pepper to taste. Spread in a single layer on a parchment-paper-lined or greased baking sheet. Bake until crispy and browned, about 45 minutes, stirring part way through.


Chilli Aioli


Mayonnaise or veganniase
1 small clove garlic, minced
Squeeze of fresh lemon juice
Ground ancho chilli, to taste


Combine all ingredients to taste in a small bowl.

Grand Marnier

Serve neat, over ice or with 1 1/2 oz liqueur to 1 oz freshly squeezed lemon (shaken with ice and strained) and garnished with a slice of orange as dessert.


Share your recipes for broke twenty-something fare/feelings about complicated lesbian feelings in the comments.
Before you go! Autostraddle runs on the reader support of our AF+ Members. If this article meant something to you today — if it informed you or made you smile or feel seen, will you consider joining AF and supporting the people who make this queer media site possible?

Join AF+!


Full-time writer, part-time lover, freelancing in fancy cheese and cider.

Kate has written 130 articles for us.


  1. Our distributors just emailed us this link. Thank you so much for including The Four-Faced Liar. Indie movies are hard to make and we really appreciate the love and support!

    If I could cook (or cared to endure the sight of my own face for 82 minutes) I would totally join in.

    Thanks again!

  2. Our distributors just emailed us this link. Thank you so much for including The Four-Faced Liar on your site. Indie movies are so hard to make and we sincerely appreciate the love and support!

    If I could cook (or had any desire to stare at my own face for 82 minutes) I’d totally join in.

    Thanks again!

  3. Loving everything about this post. There are so many painfully relatable scenes in the film, I can’t even.

  4. I love this movie! It’s what actually got me to finally read Wuthering Heights (Bridget was reading it in the toilet, and I was really attracted to Bridget… so). This post made me want to watch it again. Yep. I’m gonna do it.

  5. I love this movie! I was an undergrad at NYU the first time I saw it, and I was all “OMG I’ve been to all these places!”

    When I actually accidentally walked past The Four-Faced Liar (the bar) in the West Village, I OMGed.

  6. This is one of my favorite movies. Probably because I have my own “Molly” and I want a happy ending.

    Maybe I should invite her over for movie night. Subliminal messaging could do the trick, right?

  7. Ugh, I love this movie so much. I think this was the first gay movie I saw that I really loved.

  8. Love this movie.

    Could someone who is good at film studies or some such thing explain to me the symbolism of red and blue, and how it shifts through the film?


  9. bleurgh, i wish it was available in my region! this would have been the perfect film for my movie-night-in date. alas and alack.

      • hee, i would’ve like to have gone through, eh hem, more legitimate channels, since it’s an indie film, but i guess those ways and means will have to do for short notice! i’ll buy the dvd later.

  10. I like this film, which is disappointing. I’m hoping it will get re-made featuring more two-dimensional characters, histrionic-tinged sex scenes and high-waisted jeans so that I can file it under “Terrible Lesbian Films,” otherwise it will break my whole cataloguing system.

  11. I just finished watching this movie and I was pleasantly surprised.
    Thank you for the recommendation! I really enjoyed it.

Comments are closed.