Even My Soft Butch Hufflepuff Dreamboat Couldn’t Redeem the Cash-Grabbing Mess of “Hogwarts Mystery”

When I turned sixteen, my mom wanted to throw me a big party. You know, Sweet Sixteen, and all that. I told her absolutely not, that I’d much prefer to save us all a lot of stress and money and celebrate my birthday in my favorite way: by ignoring it. We ended up sort of compromising, and I brought a bunch of friends to see Harry Potter and the Sorcerer’s Stone when it premiered instead. If I had to acknowledge my birthday, I was going to at least enjoy Harry Potter while doing it.

Like so many other queer kids, I had fallen in love with the wizarding world — with its mail-delivering owls, and chocolate frogs that jump — almost immediately. Hogwarts was a place where being different was something to be celebrated, not hidden, and that sounded like heaven to my closeted teenage ears. I’m not a kid anymore, and I came out a long time ago, but I still love Harry Potter with all of my heart. So it really does pain me to tell you that the new mobile game, Hogwarts Mystery, makes me want to smash my phone into a million pieces.

None of the sense of wonder that made Harry Potter special is anywhere to be found in Hogwarts Mystery. Instead, the game is a hollow and nearly unplayable attempt to cash in on a billion-dollar franchise. It’s advertised as a narrative/RPG-style game “where players can create their own character and experience life as a Hogwarts student,” but none of the choices you make seem to actually impact the story in any meaningful way.

The general plot of Hogwarts Mystery is that your older brother tried to find some Cursed Vaults in Hogwarts, but something went wrong. He was expelled and has since disappeared. It’s your turn to start at Hogwarts now, and you’re determined to figure out what happened. As far as story set-ups go it’s fine, I guess, but the notoriety surrounding you because of things you didn’t do (and don’t really know about) plays out a lot like the beginning of Harry Potter. You even have your very own version of Draco Malfoy named Merula, a pure-blood obsessed Slytherin who despises you from the get go.

Not All Slytherins.

One of the only good things about Hogwarts Mystery is that I was able to create the softest butch imaginable from a pretty limited character creator. She also makes consistently hilarious facial expressions, like this one:

Look at this dork.

Once you create your character, there’s a brief tutorial that introduces the gameplay. Gameplay is a term I am using very loosely here, because the main mechanic, and probably about 85% of the game so far, is tapping on anything that is outlined in blue. I figured I would just go with it, even though it was repetitive and boring, in hopes that the game would pick up once I actually made it to Hogwarts. Reader, it did not.


In fact, the very first time there’s any excitement at all, the game hits a wall. You see, the little blue lightning circles were actually “energy” all along and it turns out you only have a finite amount of energy to complete tasks, which was somehow not really covered in the tutorial. So here you are, being literally strangled to death by Devil’s Snare:

And suddenly you run out of energy! Never fear though, you can just buy more energy with gems. Easy enough, right? But what if you run out of gems (which you will surely do all the time)?


So at this point your options are to shell out some cash or wait like an hour for your energy to recharge, which makes absolutely no sense given your current predicament. And that’s basically the whole game. Sure there are dialog options and choices to make, but the main choice of the game is this: do you pause and break up the flow of the story in inexplicable ways or do you pump money in to keep blindly tapping.


“Freemium” isn’t a new concept and Hogwarts Mystery isn’t the first game to use dark patterns in an attempt to make some money, but the blatant lack of effort to create an entertaining game here is disheartening. Puzzle games like Candy Crush that use a similar tactic work because there’s actually some level of skill involved; you want to keep playing to solve the puzzles.

In Hogwarts Mystery, the only thing that keeps you going is the story, which is… still fine, I guess. You mostly interact with Rowan, who becomes your best friend after you meet in Diagon Alley during the tutorial. She’s in your house no matter which one you choose, which is another thing that doesn’t make sense because she is so clearly a Ravenclaw:

She’s a cute nerd though, which is 100% my type, and if I don’t uninstall this game from my phone before year four or five I’ll probably try to romance her (if that’s even an option). Anyway, Rowan is down to help you investigate the Cursed Vaults and also help you learn to how to duel, which is another part of the game that I think was probably created by someone who has never read or seen any of the Harry Potters.

The way duels work in Hogwarts Mystery is that they’re exactly like rock-paper-scissors, and also sometimes if you win a round you can “throw a vial” to reduce your opponent’s stamina (which is definitely not a thing). It makes no sense, but it’s such a relief not to be tapping randomly at the screen that I don’t even care.

Throughout your first year, you also meet a few more friends named Penny Haywood and Ben Copper. Ben is a cowardly Gryffindor and mostly a boring character, but Penny is a total babe with a heart of gold. She takes an interest in you because you stand up to Merula’s bullying and beat her in a duel, like a badass. Penny starts talking to you and reduces you to a stammering gay disaster, which is the truest part of the whole game so far.

This is the collective queer reaction to every pretty girl.

At the end of the year, you can choose whether to take Penny or Ben (along with Rowan) on an adventure to try and find a Cursed Vault. Obviously, the correct answer is to take Penny, which I did, but apparently that choice doesn’t actually matter because in the beginning of the second year Ben is somehow the one affected by the trip. Hey look, it’s another thing that doesn’t make sense!

As of right now, the game is only playable into the third year, but I haven’t made it to that point yet because I’m not willing to spend a single cent on this thing. The idea of a Hogwarts RPG is such a good one, and it had the potential to be a robust and fun experience, but Hogwarts Mystery is a complete let down. Unless the developer, Jam City, makes some serious and fundamental changes, I do not recommend this incredibly frustrating game — even (or maybe especially) if you’re a Harry Potter fan.

Before you go! Autostraddle runs on the reader support of our AF+ Members. If this article meant something to you today — if it informed you or made you smile or feel seen, will you consider joining AF and supporting the people who make this queer media site possible?

Join AF+!


Jenna is a designer and writer who lives in Boston with her wife, Stephanie, and their two cats, Flapjack and Ellie. She is very passionate about fictional queer women, interspecies friendships, and food. She's still hanging onto a semi-impressive DVD collection. Just in case, you know? You can find Jenna on twitter, instagram, or check out her design website.

Jenna has written 34 articles for us.


  1. Damn! This bums me out so hard! (That Hufflepuff soft butch, though, makes my heart sing.)


    (for context, i’m the one who yelled about this at you in an overly long thread on twitter lol)

    your hogwarts student looks basically the exact same as mine! and v much agreed about penny, she’s the best. i really hope romancing is a thing and that i haven’t shattered my phone/uninstalled by then because both she and rowan are pretty adorable! (though i notice that tonks becomes available as a friend later on, which could be interesting…)

    interesting also that rowan is the same when you’re not a ravenclaw! i thought she’d be less of a research nerd, hmm.

    but yeah agreed, unless i see some big game mechanics changes in the next update, i doubt i’m going to be playing much longer :/

    • My Hogwarts student looks the same too! Except her alternative lifestyle haircut is a lighter brown and she’s Ravenclaw, therefore so is my Rowan.

      However, Hermione was a Gryffindor and she also acted just the same as Rowan about books.

  3. okay while I support a lot of this review! The moneygrubbing is annoying! The mechanics are a little repetitive! The clothing choices are INCREDIBLY LIMITING (i am also a soft butch hufflepuff)! you forgot a key thing.

    THE FLYING. I spent so long trying to learn how to fly and watching my little avatar fly around hogwarts was AMAZING. I have a lot of feelings about this! I quite like the dueling mechanic – it breaks up the classes monotony, and I am enjoying the story thus far, though I wish Rowan was less Hermione-lite (and obviously a ravenclaw) and Ben was less Neville-lite and your story choices actually mattered.

    It feels very based off the Kim Kardashian Hollywood game where you become a model and also work in Dash and date other celebrities – the photoshoot/event mechanic is very much the same, but this is far superior because it actually has a plot that isn’t just ‘get famous’ and other mechanics than the dull tapping. I also really like the spell casting aspect, though I wish you could do it more on command instead of just when you are prompted to by the task you are currently doing.

  4. Is it wrong that I’m a little turned on by the idea of ‘soft butch Hufflepuff’?

    • My girlfriend is a soft butch Hufflepuff. I can assure you it isn’t wrong at all.

      • Okay, “soft butch Hufflepuff seeking same” is gonna go on my tinder profile now.

        • Man, if I’d started out with “tomboy femme Ravenclaw seeking soft butch Hufflepuff,” maybe I wouldn’t have been single for so long…

          • My Tinder profile literally says, “Gryffindor seeking same”.
            Works like a charm.

        • I only messaged my now-wife on OKC because her profile said “Slytherclaw who comes off as a Hufflepuff.” If she hadn’t written that WE MIGHT NOT BE MARRIED.

  5. My Hogwarts student looks the same except she’s Ravenclaw, so Rowan makes sense. I didn’t know she acted the same no matter the house.
    Anyway, I agree with everything. So much so that I uninstalled the game

  6. OMG YES. I was expecting this to be a point & click adventure or puzzle game, or hell even a hidden object game ala Original Flavour Pottermore – that one at least felt like you were DOING something. These tappity-tappity-tappity games? Yawn.

  7. I was excited to play this game and it was fun at first, but as soon as I got to that devil’s snare part and had to wait like half an hour for my energy to recharge it became apparent that it would probably be unplayable… It’s so bizarre to me that there’s yet to be a good Harry Potter RPG game where you have a lot more control over what’s going on and really do experience being a Hogwarts student in more depth.

  8. I liked the Kim Kardashian game!
    And I really didn’t like this. It’s a bit wooden and clunky.
    Thank you so much for this review that saved me having to trudge through more tediousness.

  9. They also missed a golden opportunity to name this game
    Hogwarts: A Mystery

    I read that somewhere and it broke me because it’s sooo obvious

    • So Lego Harry Potter remains the only video game version of this game worth playing then?

      • The Lego one is so much fun! But yeah this one is kinda dull. I’m kinda curious about the brother but all the tapping and nothing else is dull. My avatar is also a soft butch Hufflepuff though which is honestly the best part.

  10. This echoes a lot of my feelings about this game too!

    I play a lot of visual novels, so I’m not bothered by the lack of traditional “gameplay” in favor of making choices, but what frustrates me (along with the money issue) is how little impact your choices make on the game. Which is not true of good visual novels; the choices and the different endings they give you and how your choices shape your character are the whole point! But I felt like I was forced into a character type who didn’t feel much like me regardless of what I did.

    I’m a Ravenclaw and was talking with a friend (who is a Slytherin) about this game, and she brought up a good point: “it feels like you’re playing as a Gryffindor no matter what.” Like you’re forced to be the rule-breaking risk-taker no matter what, with the professors disliking you for it, and that’s fine but it sure diminishes the whole “you as a student at Hogwarts” feeling of it, you know? Like I’m a Ravenclaw for a reason; I’m here to learn, I wouldn’t be the one going exploring some cursed vaults just because i can like my character does at first. There’s a part where my prefect tells me that he’s not even sure why I’m in Ravenclaw and man, that stung, but also makes sense for the way they make your character act in the game!

    I really wish that Harry Potter would just give us the Hogwarts MMO that must know we all really want.

    Also re: freemium games, I wish that gameplayers would realize that something like Animal Crossing Pocket Camp, where paying money is more like a nice bonus that makes the game better and go faster, but not a requirement just to enjoy it at all, is a better business model. I mean, maybe it isn’t and that’s why games keep doing this, but I feel like I at least am more likely to both want to spend money, and also keep playing the game, in that instance. A game that works like Hogwarts Mystery does might get a lot of money in the short run, but I can’t see how something that builds up so much resentment you end up quitting is a good model in the long run.

Comments are closed.