On January 7th it was announced that military members who were discharged without full separation pay under DADT will now be fully compensated with the remainder of their pay. This victory comes after a class action law suit, Collins v. United States, brought forward by the American Civil Liberties Union and its New Mexico affiliate. It was named after the lead plaintiff, Richard Collins, who was honorably discharged from the Air Force in 2006 after two civilians reported to the military that they saw him kissing his boyfriend a whole 10 miles from his base. Though Collins wasn’t even on duty at the time, he was discharged and further discriminated against by not being given his full separation pay. On Monday, Collins issued a statement saying that the “settlement means a lot to him and others who were forced out of the military against their will.”
Separation pay is given to military members who have served at least six years before being involuntarily and honorably discharged. However, under Defense Department Policy dating back to 1991, certain factors, such as drug or alcohol abuse, discharge in the interests of national security, and yes, homosexuality, can prevent a person from obtaining his or her full separation pay. Because it’s a separate Defense Department policy, it wasn’t repealed last year along with DADT.
Laura Schauer Ives, the managing attorney for ACLU of New Mexico, is calling the settlement a “long-delayed justice.”
“There was absolutely no need to subject these service members to a double dose of discrimination by removing them from the armed forces in the first place, and then denying them this small benefit to ease the transition to civilian life,” she said.
To use military language, this battle has been won. But I’m still left with a lot of questions and concerns for what remains to be achieved when it comes to gay people and the American military. According to the American Civil Liberties Union, the settlement will force the military to pay a total sum of $2.4 million, but it will only cover the 180 veterans who were discharged on or after November 10, 2004. Considering the fact that the Defense Department policy went into effect way back in 1991, and DADT lasted from 1993 to 2011, I’m sure there’s a significant number of military personnel who have been discharged for being gay and won’t get their full separation pay because they unfortunately didn’t make the November 10, 2004 cut-off.
And by no means does the repeal of DADT and this recent settlement signal the end of all problems for gay people in the military. As Rachel explained, the spouses of queer people in the military have yet to be given the same benefits as the partners of straight service members. A new bill, HR 6046, or the Military Spouses Equal Treatment Act of 2012, would change the definition of “spouse” to allow all couples to receive the same benefits, but it hasn’t passed yet; so as we drink to this recent victory for gays in the American military, let’s remember to keep some in the fridge for the victories that have yet to be won.
It’s also frustrating that 2.4 million dollars is a drop in the bucket for the defense budget. Why can’t we spend more of our tax dollars on the people actually serving our country instead of on defense contracts and weapons?
Also, the DADT repeal didn’t really benefit trans* people. Their rights as far as the military goes are still fucked.
Thank you for this insightful and informative article….so many battles still to be won!
Great victory for “some” gays. What about the ones booted prior to DADT?? I would have been a lifer!! DADT came out 5 months AFTER I was booted. I had to fight in court 12 hours just to get honorable discharge and I was one of the most outstanding soldiers in each unit I was in. Expert marksman, 300 PT scores. Set the pace for the fast runners, top of my graduating class, numerous achievement and accommodation awards, life guard, sports, air assault school, etc, etc, etc. I had nicknames like “Rambo,” “Rambette,” “Super troop,” and “hot rock.” What kind of compensation do I get?? Any one what to help me start a law suit??
I was kicked out just before this dadt nonsense. I was in the air force, airman of the year, many bullet points and great standing. No one even questioned why within 6 weeks, everything went out the window. they didn’t even call it what it was, instead they gave me misconduct charges that were absolutely false and worded so that only a lawyer could understand.
months later, the Dadt came through. I would have been in the air force for as long as it would allow if given the chance, if it not for 1 awful supervisor, and his (man made belief) hatred of different people.