This season of Grey’s Anatomy started off strong with Amelia and Toni making up (and out) after their dramatic ending last season, but sadly the progress has been slow going from there. But honestly, on this show, maybe that’s a blessing. As long as we get to keep seeing them both, their romance being a C plot might keep them together (and both of them alive) longer, so maybe we should celebrate small victories.
Still, I do want to talk about their little moments that have been sprinkled throughout the season so far as we head into the mid-season hiatus. (I know it seems soon but, for some reason, this season only has 13 episodes total.) I will be covering almost exclusively Amelia and Toni’s story and subplots because we simply don’t have time for me to go on about the entitlement of Ben Warren or how the powers that be have decided to, inexplicably, distribute Ow*n’s assholery among the men he left behind instead of letting him take it all with him. Or even how they seem to have forgotten that Millen is bisexual and also a badass who is good at her job. Alas, those are rants for another day.
As I mentioned in my Pop Culture Fix when the show first returned, in the season premiere, Amelia went to Toni’s doorstep to beg for forgiveness for sleeping with Cass and asked her to give her another chance, and Toni still loves Amelia so she agreed and they kissed about it.
In the time since then, their relationship progresses to the point where Toni is ready to meet Amelia’s son Scout. When they go over to Jo’s to get him, they find her up to her neck in tasks and decide to stick around to help; after all, three moms are better than one. They have a cute little crafting moment and when Jo gets so overwhelmed she tries to kick them out, they talk her down and bond about how the “perfect mom” is a myth and they can only do their best.
We don’t see the actual Scout-Toni meeting, but we hear later that it was a success, due in part to Toni’s T-Rex impression. Amelia apologizes for their day off together looking differently than they originally planned, but Toni just likes spending time with her no matter what.

A few weeks later, Toni comes to Amelia with a surprise. She took it upon herself to clear Amelia’s calendar so they can spend a spa day together. As soon as she started talking, I tensed up; I know Toni is new here but I’ve “known” Amelia for 16 years now. I knew damn well this was not going to go over well. Amelia, to her credit, remains calm, if incredulous. She understands that Toni thought it was romantic, but that is not her idea of romance.
Later, she (very maturely, in a way that is rare and refreshing on this show) explains to Toni that ever since she got sober, she doesn’t love surprises. Toni apologizes and explains she just wanted time with just the two of them and no kids and offers to cancel, but Amelia can plan for it now so all she needs is the itinerary and their trip can still be a go. It’s all very mature and sweet.

Sadly that’s all the relationship-specific stuff we see between them, but in these last two episodes, Amelia has another side-plot going on: She has started to pick up on the signs that Link is abusing the pain medication he was originally prescribed for his shoulder injury.
After letting Toni “cut the line” to check a scan for her, Amelia tells Toni about her suspicions, but Toni recommends waiting until she has more evidence than “I can tell he lied to me” to confront him in case she’s wrong.

Sadly, Amelia doesn’t have to wait long to find her next sign. During surgery, she notices Link is having a hard time being precise, his pupils are pinpricks, and plus there’s the extra irritability lately, so she kicks him out of her OR despite him throwing a tantrum about it.
Afterward, Amelia’s hands are shaking from the confrontation, I imagine both because it’s hard to do tough love on someone you care about (Link is her ex and the father of her child after all) but also because I’m sure it’s triggering from times she’s had to be confronted about her own addiction. Toni notices her shaking but Amelia brushes off her offer to help.
Amelia pulls Link into a break room and tells him she knows that he has been abusing pain medication, and to save her the excuses because she’s heard (and said) them all. She’s not fucking around; she tells Link he has a problem and needs to start dealing with it, pages Jo, and leaves them to discuss it, hoping to force his hand.
Now, Jo has made a lot of progress on this show in regards to her maturity, so I’m really hoping she takes this seriously and doesn’t let Link strongarm her into believing him that he doesn’t have a problem and then they team up against Amelia. Because WE know that Amelia is right, and it would suck to have to watch her go through that.
But what I’m really worried about is Amelia and Toni. For one thing, Toni sort of brushed off her initial concern, which made Amelia second-guess her instincts and it almost affected her patient. And Amelia doesn’t fuck around about her patients. On the other hand, Toni did have a point, that accusing him without more evidence than a gut instinct probably would have gone worse. And, to Toni’s credit, as soon as Amelia said she knew for sure vs. she was just concerned about it, Toni’s answer was a simple and clear, “How can I help?”

I’m hoping Toni was just being used as a sounding board for us, the audience, to see where Amelia’s head was at this season and not setting up a fight. Because also: Toni might have known Amelia in med school and then reconnected with her last season, but she missed a lot of chapters of Amelia’s life. She wasn’t around for the infant loss or the addiction or losing her brother or the brain tumor. I don’t think she fully understands how triggering this will be for Amelia, and how hard it will be to have the father of her son going through this—especially if he doesn’t admit to it and get help right away.
In the trailer for the second half of the season there’s a clip of Toni and Amelia walking together and smiling, so I really hope Toni is equipped to be there for Amelia in the ways she’ll really need her coming up, because the last thing Amelia will need amidst all of this stress is a breakup. Amelia has been through enough, our girl deserves some comfort and happiness.