They’re My Friend Now But Saying Very Unfriendly Things About Me
Q.
A long time ago I was hooking up for a few weeks with a friend in a group that was just starting to become my friend group. I kinda crushed on them but it was clear they didn’t feel the same way. i started dating someone els. they did too. and without really talking about it we stopped hooking up and became actual friends. i don’t have any complaints about the hookups, we were both drunk and/or high and i thought it was fun and we could potentially build more chemistry. (i didn’t cum, but that’s not the point of sex for me.) when people ask me about it i just say it was good and fun. but APPARENTLY when they get asked about it, they say we just “weren’t a match” sexually and APPARENTLY they say this in a snarky way. i was very hurt to hear this, even though “not a match” isn’t necessarily mean, i first of all imagine they probably said something meaner than that in reality but i’m not getting the whole story, but the tone. i feel like i’m getting bad reviews and it has made me take a step back from our friendship. but that is so petty of me, i think, because who cares? would i look like world’s biggest dummy to ask them about it?
A:
Valerie: If it’s getting back to you like this, and you two are supposedly friends, I don’t think it’s a bad idea to talk to them about it. But also definitely approach it with more curiosity than accusations. It’s VERY possible people are misinterpreting their tone or exaggerating their snark. I could see a joking “we were not a match” just being a polite way to tell people it’s none of their business, actually. Or maybe since you guys are friends they think it’s just a funny joke to make and don’t realize that it’s getting back to you as a “bad review.” However, if that’s how people are interpreting it, I don’t think it could hurt for you to ask them to stop saying it. Maybe you can both agree to just answer something like “we’re friends now, don’t make it weird” when your mutual friends ask about what it was like to hook up with each other. Because the truth is, it’s very possible the sex was bad to them even though it was fun and fine for you. Since you’re no longer hooking up, that doesn’t really matter. And it doesn’t mean you’re bad at sex. It means you two weren’t a match, as they said. Which isn’t inherently a bad thing or a judgement on either of you. And it’s their experience, so if it’s something they want to confide in people in their lives, that’s their prerogative. But if it’s getting back to you like this and with this interpretation it’s possible they’re saying this casually and/or in groups of people that you know and a little flippantly, so if you want that to stop, I think it’s a fair ask. I don’t think it’s worth losing a friendship over if it’s one you want to keep; an open conversation can clear the air on this quickly.
Summer: Valerie’s right. You should be able to talk to them about this as friends. Given the long gap since then, I’m hoping everyone involved has put enough distance from the hookups to have a mature conversation. That should clear the air. I also don’t know exactly what they mean in their tone, but you won’t find out for sure unless you get it from them or someone very close to them.
There is another side of the coin, which is you. This could be a time to think about why it means so much to get ‘good’ reviews from your past sexual encounters. I mean, this isn’t a consent violation or anything — at worst, it sounds like they didn’t have as good a time as you thought. That’s the most normal thing in dating, but why does it make you ache even years afterward? Would you feel this sting if it came from someone else? There’s stuff to think about here.
Ashni: I don’t think it’s petty of you! Queer community is so small, and word travels fast. If there’s a rumor going around that implies you’re not good in bed, I think it’s totally reasonable for you to be upset about it, especially if the originator is a close friend and someone you trust(ed). It could lead to you not having as many sexual opportunities as you might like! But I think that hinges on there actually being a rumor. You mention you’re not getting the whole story, just the tone. To Valerie’s point, tone is an easy thing to misinterpret. If you do decide to say something, I’d encourage you to get the whole story first.
Is It Weird To Keep Stuff From my Exes?
Q.
is it crazy to keep shit from my exes? i don’t know why i do it, but i still have photos, letters, cards. it just seems like stuff that is important, meaningful, feels so weird to throw out, but i’m about to move in with my girlfriend of 4 years and am asking myself if this is a fucked up practice…. i am an artist and sometimes i do look at old stuff when i am creating material about those experiences, but other than that i am not sure why i would look at it. is this a question about the purpose of nostalgia in general maybe…
A
Valerie: I am EXTREMELY pro-nostalgia. I have letters my pen pal wrote me when we were eight, playbills from the theater group I was in growing up, every birthday card my grandparents ever sent me. I have a box of notes people passed to me throughout high school, even though I’m not friends with 90% of them anymore, art my classes made me when I was a student teacher, and a cool rock I got on a field trip in sixth grade. I don’t pull them out to look at them often (I usually only even remember I have most of it when I’m doing a deep clean of my apartment or moving) but I also am glad I’ve never thrown those things away, because they were important to me once and I like remembering that. So I might be biased but no, I don’t think it’s weird to hold onto a few mementos from your life, even from the hard times, even from people who aren’t part of your life anymore. These are still your experiences, still things that happened to you, and having a touchstone to help you remember doesn’t seem like a bad thing to me. As long as you don’t find yourself bringing the stuff out to look at constantly in a way that feels obsessive or unhealthy, and it’s not hurting you to have it (and you don’t have like…a shrine to your ex in a room you share your currently girlfriend), I think it’s nice to hold onto a few meaningful things. And it helping you with your art sometimes is just a nice bonus. I actually started a junk journal to try to curb my instinct to cling to memories by way of things like napkins with restaurant logos on them or event bracelets; this way I can still keep those things, but it’s contained, linked to a specific memory, and now it’s *art* instead of a pile of what looks to anyone else like trash.
Summer: I don’t think it’s fucked up and I think it’s even less fucked up if you have a practical use (artistic inspiration) for it. What are your intentions for keeping these items? Is it solely for artistic utility and occasional memory trips, or is there an underlying longing that could jeopardize your current relationship. I think this habit is only harmful if there’s a risk of undermining your current relationship.
I have stuff from my exes that represents the love we had (and now have as friends). It’s different in my case since I’m on good terms with all my exes so these objects are now friendship mementos. The end of a relationship is a form of loss and we manage loss differently. I don’t think you’re doing anything wrong unless there’s tangible harm or risk. I mean, it’s your property at this point — they haven’t asked for it back, right?
Ashni: I think (within reason) it’s totally normal, but I say this as a person who loves collecting ephemera. I feel like when relationships end, we’re quick to discard all remnants of them — I know people who immediately unfriend their exes on social media, who delete their numbers, who think that the way to move on is to pretend that it never happened. But sometimes, a relationship isn’t all bad, and it still ends! I don’t think you need to remove all memories from the relationship just because it’s over. Moving on doesn’t mean forgetting. But because you’re building a home with your girlfriend of four years, she (very likely) will not want to see your collection from past lovers. If you’re going to bring these items into your shared home, you might want to check in with her and ask if she’s okay if you have a private box of things tucked away somewhere. Every couple has a different approach to privacy, and the last thing you want is for someone to be looking for a lost thong in the closet and to (surprise!) come across a box of love letters from a previous dalliance.
Submit your own advice questions right here!
AF members get the benefit of having your advice questions answered by the team. We do our best to answer every question, which is like, 99% of them — very rarely do they stump us. Questions remain anonymous!