Lady Gaga’s “Judas” Music Video: The Mini-Recap

Maybe our standards are too high at this point. We were spoiled by Telephone and its cigarette glasses, PUSSY WAGON, lesbian makeout and overall campy awesomeness. We were spoiled by Alejandro‘s gender-bending pseudo nazi-ism. We were spoiled when Bad Romance made music videos relevant again. Her videos give me new appreciation for her songs.

But did I deconstruct Bad Romance so thoroughly at the time, thinking, “Huh! Looks like there’s more at work here than meets the eye!

I don’t think I did.

Don’t get me wrong. I love all Lady Gaga videos always. But when it comes to recapping, Telephone was so much fun to recap, and it embodied everything I love about this woman. But Born This Way and Judas have been a little bit more challenging.

In fact, Born This Way was SO challenging that I um, didn’t recap it. This was as far as I got with that one:

Lady Gaga Born This Way

Totally worth the wait, I know.

I’m torn as to whether Lady Gaga is attempting to impart any meaning/importance/social significance/commentary in her videos these days. Is she trying to make a statement or is she just making a crazy music video for her song? Judas is a song about betrayal — a betrayer she’s still in love with — and that’s a thing we can relate to. Of course we can find the religious imagery in the song and video, and that’s fun, but beyond that … I think this is just a … music video.

So the point is that this isn’t a traditional recap so to speak, it’s mostly screengrabs! However, I suggest/highly recommend reading every. single. comment our readers have left on this open thread about ‘Judas for incredible symbolic/biblical insight on the video. The discourse is amazing, and this is why WE HAVE BETTER READERS THAN YOU.

Okay? We cool? Ready — go!

The curtain opens, and the 12 disciples are on the highway to the dangerzone.

Lady-Gaga-Judas-Recap-opening

Clearly this is how my Catholic class teacher should’ve taught the gospel to me: “The 12 disciplines drove into Jerusalem on their motorcycles. Then Mary Magdalene showed us what she’s workin’ with!” (I went to public school but my parents put my brother and myself into a weekly night religion class so we could learn about Jesus. And I/we did.)

Gaga-slash-Mary Magdalene (because we all know that is who she is portraying here) is lookin’ back at Judas all lingering and shit. She probably can’t get over him even though he probs done her wrong or something. I don’t know, I just have this feeling, yannow?

Lady-Gaga-Judas-Recap-opening2

Why do the good girls always want the bad boys? #rhetorical

Lady-Gaga-Judas-Recap-judas

So pretty much there are two things that make this video worth-watching. And I think you would agree that one of those things is this red underwear get-up she’s sporting:

Lady-Gaga-Judas-Recap-red-outfit

I’ll get to the second reason in a hot second … but first — the macarena, duh:

Lady-Gaga-Judas-Recap-Macarena

Also. When I first heard Judas on the radio I was confused: “this can’t possibly be an actual song,” I thought. (That was mostly about the parts where she sounds like a cat. Also at first I thought the lyrics said “I’m just a horny fool.”)

I now realize this is a song, a real song, whether you like it or not. I’ve warmed up to the tune. I like it. The chorus is pop perfection. Also “ear condoms” are given a shout-out in the lyrics. This is the truth, just like the entire Bible.

Lady Gaga Judas Recap Earcondoms

Are you ready for the best dance sequence? Everyone can learn this choreography, even my friends dead cat. I am serious it’s awesome and the second best thing about this video:

Lady-Gaga-Judas-Recap-dance-sequence

I want this look/outfit so bad I can hardly stand it.

Next scene, verse 2: Gaga’s full-on in the blue and red garment situation, which according to my classes in art history, means she is one of the holy women — probs in this case Mary Magdalene, as we already discussed. I’m just stretching my art history muscles here (because really, when else do I get to do such a thing?), but when the Virgin Mary is portrayed in any art pre-renaissance and throughout the Renaissance, she is wearing the blue and red garment/robe. Ta-da! Thank you Fashion Institute of Technology!

Also, I think its interesting that Gaga points out Peter in this one specific sequence where she also says “I’ve learned love is like a brick you can / Build a house or sink a dead body” in the lyrics. Because as L. Valentine pointed out in this post, the disciple Peter went on to establish the catholic church:
Lady-Gaga-Judas-Recap-peter

Way to go, Peter. Now I can’t get married, and also, Jesus said not to worship “brick and mortar.”

Alright, back to the music: now we have Gaga seemingly marking Judas with lipstick, which I thought at first was just for funsies (and I LOLed a little) and additional gender-bending, but no actually this goes back to the bible thing again. This was how Judas betrayed Jesus: this, as the story goes, was how Judas identified the blasphemer to the roman guards. So then it became more significant and less weird, but whatever, Gaga knows her shit.
Lady-Gaga-Judas-Recap-kiss-of-betrayal

Then some water is like what’s up, then Jesus is like whoa, guys, chill! I got this! then Gaga/Mary Magdalene washes Jesus’ feet as I believe the story goes (again), and then I kind of stop paying attention cause this water part really throws me off:
Lady-Gaga-Judas-Recap-lots-of-stuff

The end of the video is kind of sad. I hate seeing Gaga surrounded by people throwing things at her while she wears her favorite Queen Amidala halloween costume:
Lady-Gaga-Judas-Recap-stoning

Aaaaand that about wraps up our Bible class for this evening, guys. Thanks for coming. Thanks for your amazing/scholastic reviews and insight deconstructions of this video. I thoroughly enjoyed what you had to say in our previous post/Judas open thread!

I’m looking forward to anything else you have to add!

Profile photo of Alex

Cofounder and Design Director of Autostraddle. Professional web/graphic designer. Whiskey enthusiast. Drumming hobbyist. A past speaker at the 2010 BlogHer Conference ("Good Blog Design: The Role of Layout in an Online Medium"), 2013 Salon LGBTQ Conference ("Innovative Best Practices for Brand-Blogger Campaigns") and featured in the Los Angeles Edition of Refinery29's 30 Under 30 in 2013. Co-owns and manages Tully's Training, a dog training company in Los Angeles. Twitter: @a_ex Instagram: alexxxvegaaa

Alex has written 114 articles for us.

83 Comments

  1. Thumb up 0

    Please log in to vote

    a:ex you just crossed my mind, reading the recent posts and was about to formspring riese re: where you are and we miss you already

  2. Thumb up 0

    Please log in to vote

    I didn’t have a chance to discuss my thoughts in the open thread last week, but during the weekend, I was discussing the video online with a friend of mine, and here’s what I came up with (re-posted from Facebook):

    The song’s mediocre, and while the video ain’t no Bad Romance or Telephone, there’s a lot of interesting stuff going on. She brings the story of Judas/Jesus into a modern context by conflating it with imagery from Latino gang culture (bandannas, Lady of Guadalupe hoodie, exaggerated chola make-up, releasing the video on Cinco de Mayo, etc.).

    I’m guessing it’s about her personal history with Christianity: she was raised as a devout follower of Christ, but talks about being pulled away by fame and the trappings that go with it, represented by the Judas figure (“I want to love you…but something’s pulling me away from you.”).

    She is later tempted to remain faithful to Jesus/hay-zeus by killing Judas with the lipstick gun (which represents Judas’ deadly kisses), but she can’t bring herself to do it and breaks down. She wants to be a good girl, but she LIKES what Judas has done for her.

    The water scene/threesome bath symbolizes rebirth, and a choice to continue to love and follow Christ, while dabbling in “Judas-y” things (hence her positioning between the two men in the tub; “Jesus is my virtue…and Judas is the demon I cling to”).

    Meanwhile, she has taken up the role of Mary Magdalene, one of the most controversial (a word Gaga wants desperately to epitomize) women in history. Also, Mary was described in the Bible as a sinful woman (prior to becoming one of Christ’s followers), and although many people believe that she was a prostitute, I don’t believe that that was ever explicitly stated.

    Like Mary, a lot of people view Gaga as this slutty, debauched woman, but no one really knows much about her personal life. We base our opinions of her based on how she looks. But what has she really DONE to earn the title of adulterous whore?

    I don’t think she’s playing Mary in the stoning scene, necessarily. The last scene illustrates letting those without any sin cast the first stone. Those who judge Gaga and condemn her are surely not without any sin, themselves.

    • Thumb up 0

      Please log in to vote

      That’s (almost/kind of?) what I was trying to say in the beginning, Deardelilah — I don’t think this video is a shenanigan of any kind. I just think she made a fun music video about Judas’ betrayal related to her personally and that’s it. I think it’s just a video/song about betrayal…

  3. Thumb up 0

    Please log in to vote

    i don’t think lady gaga has changed a bit. i think she’s always known where she was headed. remember when the bad romance video came out and we were like HOLY SHIT LOOK AT CREEPY BATHTUB CHICK’S EYES? and HOLY SHIT LOOK AT THOSE FLAMETHROWER BOOBS?

    i think gaga was just warming us up.

  4. Thumb up 0

    Please log in to vote

    I agree with the sentiments that GaGa is changing things up and not in a good way, But did anyone else chins hit the floor when they realized that NORMAN F**KING REEDUS was Judas?
    (For anyone uninitiated in the awesomeness that is Norman Reedus, he played Murphy MacManus in the Boondock Saints movies, ‘nuf said) He’s also in the AMC series “The Walking Dead”, I haven’t seen it but I figure Norman + Zombies = AWESOME!!!. And I was checking IMDB and it says he might be playing Eddie Dean in the Dark Tower adaptation which is beyond freakin’ awesome!!!!

  5. Thumb up 0

    Please log in to vote

    one time i happened to be standing on a balcony above a big dance party (that was after a women’s arm-wrestling tournament, a story for another day) and Born This Way came on, one of the club remixes, and i watched a bunch of homogay queermo dudes and ladies of all ages get down to that song in a bar that used to be a church, and it may have been the $2.50 smithwicks draughts talking, but it was the most moving experience of my 2011 thus far.

    this has nothing to do with this song or video. i am just saying that lady gaga is awesome. i feel ways about lady gaga.

  6. Thumb up 0

    Please log in to vote

    Okay, I can’t help it…I tried and I couldn’t. Hello, friends, my name is Reese and I study religion. DISCLAIMER: I’m a junior in college and am in NO WAY religious expert. However, I have had to do quite a few readings, etc and these are my thoughts:

    1. It’s a song, so obviously a lot of it is meant to be metaphorical. The Mary Magdalene thesis is intriguing, especially if one is sexualizing the Bible to read it in a histo-sociological frame.
    2. The colors are almost a moot point. Blue and red is used a lot throughout Biblical imagery. It’s used in the dress of the apostles, in the dress of Christ (especially when depicting the risen Christ), depicted with the Virgin Mary, etc. In one of the later dance scenes, she is depicted as having a blue ensemble with a red heart in the middle, but that would be indicative of the virgin Mary and since I don’t think that makes any sense, I dismiss it as Biblical imagery without cause.
    3. There are significances in the biker gang: for example; why show Thomas when you could show Bartholomew or Philip? She shows Peter, Judas, John, etc. the better known disciples.
    4. Multiple religions are actually portrayed in the video. The eye make-up work by Gaga is reminiscent of an Egyptian styling that is common in adorning all of the Gods of Egypt, including any sort of artistic interpretation, not to mention the costumes are indicative of Nubian clothing style, who share characteristics with Egyptian gods
    5. Jesus is already wearing a crown of thorns. THIS IS SIGNIFICANT because the betrayal of Judas was predicted by Jesus and the crown of thorns was given to him just before he was crucified. So, betrayal is already a major component of the video, at least, metaphorically.
    6. Jesus is super hot.
    7. I also don’t know what to think of the bridge, after all, Judas is never a sexual character. If she wants to depict Mary Magdalene, then it’s never said that she is a prostitute, if anything I agree with previous comments that perhaps Jesus is her morality and Judas is her sexuality or deviance from that “virtue.”
    8. As for the water scene–does anybody else find it indicative of the Aphrodite portrait by Botticelli? Water is re-birth, baptism, sanctification
    9. Jesus knows he is to be betrayed, so the Judas kissing scene, etc is already understood by Christ.
    10. As for the last scene, it’s strange–it evokes stoning, as if Gaga is a martyr. The first Christian martyr, Stephen was stoned to death, as was a common punishment. Although, if Gaga is siding with Judas, she would not be stoned. Jesus was executed according to Pontius Pilate, Judas was an informant, so if one had forsaken Jesus, they would have been spared the death penalty. Once again, a metaphor to her enslavement to Jesus? Perhaps dying with love?

    HUGE DISCLAIMER: I STUDY THE SOCIOLOGY OF RELIGION, NOT OLD OR NEW TESTAMENT STUDIES. ALSO I AM SLIGHTLY DRUNK. ALSO I LOVE AUTOSTRADDLE. THIS IS JUST MY MINOR OBSERVATIONS. I’M JEWISH SO THIS NEW TESTAMENT STUFF CONFUSES ME. L’CHAIM
    Reese

    • Thumb up 0

      Please log in to vote

      Okay, so art history commentary has got to be added here: blue was the most expensive paint, which is why it was used a lot on religious deities/figures in Christian iconography. It “pays” to spend money on God if you’re a painted, eh? Looks good on the ol’ Holy Reh-soo-may?

    • Thumb up 0

      Please log in to vote

      I have a lot of feelings about this…was not a religion major (biochem) but I was super close to minoring in theology (did music instead) and I love all this symbolism. It makes me warm and fuzzy.

      About the blue and red thing…in Orthodox/Eastern iconography, blue represents humanity and red represents divinity (royalty), so Jesus is always portrayed as wearing red with a blue cloak (divinity cloaked in humanity) and Mary is wearing blue with a red cloak (humanity cloaked in divinity). I know that Roman Catholic tradition is not 100% the same on this, but blue definitely, definitely represents the Virgin Mary for them, and red + blue screams religious symbolism for me.

      I’m going to go ahead and say that I don’t think it’s religious symbolism without cause completely, tho…

      I mean, what did Mary Magdalene and the Virgin Mary have in common? Basically, they were the most prominent woman followers of Christ and you could probably say that they were the most important women in his life (his oddly dude-centered life). So I think that when that sweatshirt and bandanna went on, it was a way of drawing a parallel between the Virgin Mary and Magdalene as devoted followers of Christ.

      I fully admit that I may be grasping at straws and I haven’t had a good night’s sleep in a while, tho…

        • Thumb up 0

          Please log in to vote

          I am not Ukrainian, but I had a confused religious upbringing (baptized in the Ukrainian Catholic Church, but went to Orthodox churches a lot…) if you’re ever really curious as to why shoot me a message and I will give you the rundown on my odd Catholic/Orthodox upbringing.

          When your friend’s dad is an Antiochian Orthodox priest it does help you to learn things like this. :)

          • Thumb up 0

            Please log in to vote

            You’re my friend, ‘kay? I’m Ukrainian Orthodox and everytime I tell non-Slavs that I’m Orthodox, they assume I’m Jewish.

      • Thumb up 0

        Please log in to vote

        Oh man, I totally agree with you on the colors. I’m in the UK right now and the damn computer keeps on insisting that I spell it “coloUrs” it’s irritating. Tangent done.

        I guess I was just saying that the coloUrs are used to depict any range of important religious figures. The apostle James is depicted wearing blue and red in DaVinci’s “Last Supper.” Of course, if you’re a Dan Brown fan, then it’s Mary Magdalene anyways, so who cares? I’m totally with your on Mary x 2. Mary Magdalene was the first person Christ appeared to after the crucifixion and Mary is venerated by about a bajillion people. Also, the Byzantine church, which operated in a lot of Eastern Orthodox countries used blue and red all the time to depict Christ, the Virgin, apostles, disciples, etc etc.

        Interestingly enough, the Greek Orthodox and Eastern Orthodox in general consider Mary to be the fulfilment of the Ark of the Covenant because she carried Christ, or the New Covenant, so emphasis on her from that perspective is definitely relevant.

        I’m slightly obsessed with Orthodox Christianity, so I’m really glad that you brought this up.

          • Thumb up 0

            Please log in to vote

            The best is the argument over the filioque clause–it’s Latin meaning, roughly “from the son” and it’s essentially what (in a very simplified fashion) split Eastern and Western Orthodoxy. I mean, obvs there’s more to it, but it’s from a verse in the Nicene Creed that says, “We believe in the Holy Spirit, the Lord, the giver of Life, who proceeds from the Father and the Son.” Anyways, the Eastern Orthodox weren’t down with that, cut the verse and it’s one of the main theological rifts between the two.

            Plus, Eastern Orthodoxy gets better outfits.
            Religious Studies for the win.

  7. Thumb up 0

    Please log in to vote

    …enjoyed reading all comments (& conflicting ideas), and your takes on the vid. Gaga is so special because she is beautiful on the inside, and challenges our thinking. I really don’t think that she’s really any different now than to before The Fame: apart from the audience that she enjoys!

  8. Thumb up 0

    Please log in to vote

    somebody wrote this on wikipedia and i really like it:
    “Judas” is a dance song that speaks of a woman in love with a man who betrays her while simultaneously embodying things that have haunted her in the past, thus representing something that was bad for her – something she could not escape. Gaga explained that it’s also about “honoring your darkness in order to bring yourself into the light, […] You have to look into what’s haunting you and need to learn to forgive yourself in order to move on.”

  9. Thumb up 0

    Please log in to vote

    D’aww…I totally feel like this kitten in the hoodie right now. The best is when you’re at cocktail parties and you’re all
    “What do you study?”
    “Oh, Economics”
    “Awesome”
    “You?”
    “Religion.”
    *Conversation ends*

  10. Thumb up 0

    Please log in to vote

    A;ex, that is the best recap of Born This Way evah.

    I dunno, I’m just not feeling the new songs. Born This Way was meh, and I’m stilling trying to process the somanyfeelings the video gave me (they weren’t good feelings). Now with Judas, I get the symbology and the meaning and all that jazz, but it’s just so meh to me compared to Telephone, Alejandro, Teeth and Bad Romance.

    I’m all for symbolism and statements and all that jazz (I’m in art school for chrissakes) but her execution isn’t doing anything for me.

  11. Thumb up 0

    Please log in to vote

    @A;ex “Way to go, Peter. Now I can’t get married”

    Nope, you’ll have to blame Paul for that one. He’s the asshole who introduced misogyny and homophobia into Christian doctrine.

    ((Offhand story: I was admonished in my Bible studies class by my prof who was in LOVE with Paul after I said that I didn’t want 60% of my grade to be dependent on solely his writings, because that’s what our final was on. Paul. The douchebag who twisted the Jewish sect into what it is today. Thanks a lot.))

    • Thumb up 0

      Please log in to vote

      Don’t forget St Thomas Acquinas — I blame him for perpetuating Aristotle’s particular brand of misogyny.

      I feel like there is a lesson in Paul: beware the convert, they will take things too far.

  12. Thumb up 0

    Please log in to vote

    Alex thank you for recapping this for us. I share a lot of your feelings about this music video which is just a music video. Also I love that Born This Way recap so hard.

  13. Thumb up 0

    Please log in to vote

    I must confess (oh no, my ancestors’ latent Catholicism is creeping back in with all this Jaysus talk…), the conversations this video/recap has sparked are way more interesting to me than the video itself. Not that I don’t love Gaga unconditionally. Actually, I love her even more now for making us all harken back to our religious studies/art history classes. Even if this video isn’t my favorite of hers, with “Judas” she’s done one of the things art is all about — getting people to discuss Ideas! And bedazzled leather jackets. Also important.

    Um, also I totally thought it was “I’m just a horny fool” also. Thanks for clearing that up.

  14. Thumb up 0

    Please log in to vote

    i hate her, i wish she would self-destruct already.
    Her God complex is super annoying, cause she’s just a guidette with a college degree.

  15. Thumb up 0

    Please log in to vote

    Does anyone thing that the style of the outfits has anything to do with a message she’s trying to send out?
    The style of the outfits are overblown and gaudy looking in my opinion.
    It makes me wonder if Gaga is trying to say the whole story of Jesus and Judas is a bit overly dramatic in some sense, or our reactions to the story is told too often.

    Do you feel me?

  16. Thumb up 0

    Please log in to vote

    Ok so I’m going to go off on a tangent because I’m a Jew and like to talk about the Old Testament a lot. Ok? Ok. Basically this has to do with the cutting off of Judas’ name to Judah (“Jude-ah-ah”), which I saw someone mention briefly but nobody actually talk about – if someone’s already said all of this, I apologize, but I didn’t see it.

    One main story about Judah in the Old Testament is about Judah’s relationship with Tamar. Judah was one of Jacob’s 12 sons, who formed/form the 12 tribes of Israelites/Jews. Tamar was a woman who married Judah’s eldest son. A big commandment for Jews is to procreate, make babies, etc – but this son didn’t want to impregnate his wife b/c Tamar was supes hawt and he didn’t want her to gain weight/get ugly/stretch her whatever by birthing a child, so he had sex with her but would use his own form of birth control – aka didn’t come inside her (sorry, graphic). THIS IS A SIN AND HE DIES REALLY YOUNG B/C GOD IS PUNISHING HIM. Tamar then marries the next son; this is legit thing to do, it’s his responsibility to take over from his brother and make babies, give Tamar a home and money to survive, etc. But he does the same thing as his brother AND DIES TOO. Then Tamar asks to marry the third son, who’s still really young, when he’s of appropriate age, and Judah agrees, but time comes and goes and nada for her, she’s just hanging around Judah’s family and being bored and broke.
    Tamar then decides to get what she rightfully deserves – and God totally agrees with Tamar on this one, which makes it a really controversial story and heavily discussed in Orthodox classrooms – she needs to dress up as a prostitute and covers her face to conceal her identity and waits by the city outskirts/gates and solicit Judah, b/c he/his family is really responsible for her. He sleeps with her but has no money to pay, so gives her his staff and a ring as collateral. When he goes back to pay with money and get his stuff back, she is gone.

    Tamar gets pregnant from this debacle. But she’s still living within Judah’s house, community, etc, so when she starts showing everyone’s like wtfff whooore and decides to kill her for her actions. Right as she’s about to be killed, she shows the staff and the ring and says, whoever’s possessions these are, is the father of my child. She doesn’t reveal Judah’s identity – nobody knows who’s shit she’s holding – but Judah sees it and steps forward and admits what he did and that it’s his child, and she’s not killed. And – get this – she has twins and becomes the great-great-great-foremother or whatever of King David and the entire lineage of the Kingdom of Judah, which is a big frickin deal.

    SO. GAGA.
    Obviously the focus is the Judas/Jesus thing. OBVIOUSLY. But I think that besides referencing Mary Magdalene, she’s also referencing Tamar. Hear me out.

    Aesthetically/video:
    – They all ride up on the city outskirts = city outskirts/gate where Tamar meets Judah to sleep with him.
    – All the bikers = all the 12 sons/tribes, which are, when you think about, like one gang going to start the Jewish nation.
    – Gaga has the sunglasses covering her face in the beginning and keeps brandishing the blue train thingy to conceal her face = how she covered her face when she was being a prostitute.
    – When they all dance in the big town square in front of a big burning thing = the center where they are all gathered to burn Tamar (her punishment was to be death by being burnt alive).
    – Judas is suggestively touching/kissing a bunch of slutty girls = hello he picked up a prostitute.
    – She’s brandishing that gun to kill him = she has evidence to take him down (“bring him down, down”), but in the end she’s not shooting – just showing her cards. The lipstick smearing on his face is aka her showing him the stuff he gave her when he slept with her – and even though they’re in this big crowd of people, this scene in the vid is super intense/personal/eye contact-y between them, which is what the whole point of Tamar was – that she showed him and only him the sign that it was her. She then falls to the ground = she’s willing to actually die if he doesn’t reveal himself; she’s leaving him that choice.
    – She’s with them in the water jacuzzi situation in front of a roaring fire = sex (which is what the jacuzzi sitch symbolizes) leads to death by burning fire.
    – In the entire video, she only wears one ring – and granted, it’s a huge cross, but she wears all this other jewelry and crazy nails and headdresses and little gloves but only ONE ring = symbolizes the ring she shows to Judah to signal to him that she’s the woman he slept with.

    Actual lines of the song:
    – “Even after three times he betrays me” = Reference to three sons. Even after all three sons don’t do what they’re supposed to, Judah doesn’t take action/care, which he’s supposed to.
    – “A king with no crown” = References that through this intercourse, the future kingdom of Judah will be born (originally there was only supposed to be one king and kingdom, of Israel, but the kingship splits and there are two dominions, Israel and Judah). He’s a future king, but no crown yet = this is sort of her duty slash God’s will that through this the new kingdom will be established.
    – The entire chorus = she wants to be a part of slash she’s meant to be a part of this particular family of Judah. Even after all this tragedy it’s not like she tries to marry anyone else – she’s “in love with” THIS family/lineage/person. And she is holy, as proven by the fact that God is totally on her side and rewards her a ton for this whole crisis.
    – “I am beyond repentance, fame hooker, prostitute wench” = she prostitutes herself for Judah. Duh.
    – “I just speak in future tense” = References that she’s just doing this for the future, for the lineage that will come out of them, etc.

    OBVS IT’S ALL ABOUT JUDAS AND JESUS. HELLO. IT’S WRITTEN ON THE BACKS OF THEIR JACKETS AND THEY ALL WEAR CROSSES ETC. This is just one aspect I think is hidden yet referenced continuously as well. Gaga is a multilayered cake, kids.

    Tell me what you think.

    • Thumb up 0

      Please log in to vote

      I think you may be on to something here, but that something may also be that there are a lot of parallels between Hebrew Bible Judah and New Testament Judas.

      And now it fascinates me how these stories repeat themselves and I need to go dig out a Bible.

    • Thumb up 0

      Please log in to vote

      I agree with @Marika; I think it’s more because of the parallels and coincidences between Jesus’s 12 homies and the 12 tribes, as well as Mary’s historical transformation into a prostitute. Nonetheless, that was a really great reference and just goes to show how prominent these same themes are throughout the Bible.

      And holy cheese, I just regurgitated Marika’s words lol Two for two?

      • Thumb up 0

        Please log in to vote

        Is okay to regurgitate my words, I am indeed awesome…

        Also. I win the nerd game because I just facebook messaged my former Old Testament theo prof about this. I will report back with her thoughts–I expect she will see a lot of the imagery that @Po is seeing.

    • Thumb up 0

      Please log in to vote

      I do think that the “even after three times he betrays me” reference being related to Judah is a bit of a stretch…the most obvious interpretation is referring to Peter’s denial of Christ (before the cock crows you will deny me three times). I mean, it’s not impossible tho.

      I know that certain numbers repeat throughout Judaism and Christianity…has anyone really thought about direct parallels between each apostle and the 12 tribes of Israel? Or have I not slept enough again?

      And if there are parallels between Judas Iscariot and old-school Judah, are there any with Judas Maccabeus? Or is that just a random dude who happened to be named Judas (and was a BAMF, from what I’ve heard)?

      • Thumb up 0

        Please log in to vote

        I think it’s a pretty obvious (re: intentional) parallel with the 12 Tribes and the 12 Apostles. That was probably the Biblical authors’ way of reconciling the two concepts of People of Israel united under 12 [insert noun].

        And about Maccabeus, he was a warrior-hero type, so I think the Judas name is just a coincidence. I mean, Jesus’ real name should be Joshua, but I wouldn’t say he resembles Moses’ buddy Joshua.

      • Thumb up 0

        Please log in to vote

        The transliteration of names from Hebrew to English actually means that “Judah” and “Judas” are both English words for the same name in Hebrew – Yehuda. And there were lots of dudes named Yehuda – including Judas Iscariot. But Judah Maccabee has no real parallels; he and his four brothers and father waged a war against the Greeks during the time of the second Temple. The point of his story is that they were courageous and the few overpowered the many, the weak overpowered the strong, etc, b/c God was on their side. There’s no hidden dark side or underbelly of the story, so I don’t think that fits exactly.

        Also I think you may be right about it just being parallels of the story, but the original Judah came first, and I do actually think there’s symbolism in the song/vid for it as well. And obvs I have strong opinions about the validity of the Old vs the New Testament, so maybe I’m not really only making an argument in regard to the vid but in regard to every story in the New Test being recycled from the Old Testament. Idk.

        • Thumb up 0

          Please log in to vote

          Uh yeah can we agree not to argue about the validity of the Old and New Testaments? Cause yeah then this thread will turn into a shitshow and I don’t really think we should start arguing who is right and who isn’t.

          I kind of suspected you were going in the direction that the New Testament recycles themes from the Old (obviously true) but I strongly suspect that most of these themes were based on the New Testament and therefore only tangentially on the Old.

          I mean, none of us are really gonna know exactly what was behind it, but I’m feeling a little bit like I was reading too much into it when I didn’t sleep ALL OF LAST WEEK.

          Also, asking if Judas Maccabeus was also a parallel was a stupid question and I realized it right away, so sorry for being stupid erybody.

  17. Thumb up 0

    Please log in to vote

    Interesting video! I’m reading the whole thing as a battle between virtue and betrayal. Throughout, you see Gaga tempted but publicly rejecting Judas, devoting herself to Jesus with hugely dramatic baptism and prayer (while Judas, um, baptizes her ass with beer). This seems in line with traditional views of Mary Magdalene as a sinner as well as Jesus’ most devoted apostle. Her final action is to be martyred as a bride in pure, virtuous white, personifying the bride of Christ concept, Jesus’s crucifixion bringing salvation for the sins of the world (and for her personal sins), and the early martyrdom of Christians after Jesus’ death. In Gaga’s regal imagery and long hair, I see a bit of references to St. Catherine of Alexandria who is usually portrayed in art as a woman with long blonde hair wearing a crown who marries Jesus. She’s also associated with wheels as a torture instrument (I may be reaching on this last point, but the motorcycles do seem associated.)

    So much Christian imagery. We need to get Sister Wendy up in here! What’s interesting to me is that the video seems to have the opposite meaning as the song – Gaga is tempted by Judas but ultimately finds salvation in Jesus before her martyrdom.

  18. Thumb up 0

    Please log in to vote

    I feel that lady gaga is on this kick about being culturally significant and is alienating her fans in the process. Unless the majority of them just love her period and will follow her blindly no matter how great or how shitty the work is. I personally am on the fence with her right now because i do enjoy the music and her videos but feel that the direction shes headed just came on to quick. Even though it began with the paparazzi video. But i dont think shes purposely trying to be shocking shes an artist and a person and she has every right to do what ever she damn well pleases just like the rest of us. its a natural progression. it cant expect someone to be the the same forever. personal views, taste and fashion sense change all the time but being in the spotlight everything you do gets picked apart. at the end of the day who really gives a fuck and why should it even matter. i commend her for being an equal rights advocate but unfortunately when artist incorperate their political views into their music their careers go down in flames shortly there after. i think the born this way album is going to flop and hopefully she learns from her mistakes. either be a pop princess or be a rebel but again unfortunately you cant have your cake and it too. not that i like that more than anyone else but its just society.

  19. Thumb up 0

    Please log in to vote

    This video is beautiful and as someone who is religious and gay it has a lot of symbolic significance. We are viewed as “sinners” by the “church” yet we are still in love with our “sin.” I love it. I don’t think her having or lacking a college degree is of any significance either…though an attorney myself, I have several friends who are smarter than myself who didn’t get past high school.

  20. Thumb up 0

    Please log in to vote

    So one thing people missed that goes with the Mary Magdalene theme: ALL THE OIL. That at one point she is like literally RUBBING ALL OVER HER BODY (thus distracting my homogay mind). I think at one point Judas pours some on her too. Unless that was beer.

    So this is signficant because I went to sunday school and Mary Magdalene is usually supposed to be the lady who came and sat with Jesus while he was dining with a Pharisee (I think named Simon) and she came in and everyone knew she was a sinner (aka a prostitute, adulterer, or whatever) but she came in and washed Jesus’ feet with her tears and then anointed them with an expensive oil/ointment. And Simon was like “Oh gosh what is this woman doing and where did she get that stuff did she steal it or pay for it with her money she got being a PROSTITUTE?” and then Jesus was like, “Hey. Well she is actually alright because she is repenting for the things she has done AND she is showing me a great symbolic hospitality by giving me the most valuable thing she can.” or something like that.

    So yeah, she she’s rubbing herself with oil and Judas is potentially pouring it on her (and anointing people with oil was like really symbolic in the Bible cause it meant that you were being approved, or chosen as someone special. The prophet Samuel I think anointed David as future king of Israel). Also the bathtub reminded me of the whole feet washing thing (Jesus also washed his disciples’ feet right before or after (can’t remember which it’s late) the Last Supper where Judas betrayed him and it was an important act back then because you know, your feet got all groty without sandals so offering someone some precious water to wash their feet with after traveling was considered how to be a super-hospitable host or so I’ve heard).

    I’m not analyzing any of this because I am tired but yeah. More Bibical parallels, maybe.

Contribute to the conversation...

You must be logged in to post a comment.