WE'RE AT CAMP! Read all about it
The World's Most Popular Independently-Owned Website for Lesbian, Bisexual and Queer Women
Leave a Comment

//

30 Comments

How Cutting Olympic Women's Ice Hockey Would Destroy Hope, Dreams, Equality

Emily

Posted by and

THE SPORT:
The eligibility of both women's ski jumping and women's hockey isn't guaranteed for the 2014 Olympic games. So today Katy at Jezebel looks at the role sexism plays in determining Olympic Sports and we have tapped our in-house lesbian Canadian Hockey Expert for her perspective as well (more on this in a minute).

Katy explains that women's ski jumping maybe under scrutinity due to a "patronizing concern for the weak female body." Katy cites Ruth Gregory, who wrote in guest post for Sociological Images that the "rumor that ski jumping damaged women's ovaries and could lead to infertility...floated in the background of the many conversations that I had with coaches, ski jumpers and parents over the three years I was a part of the ski jumping world."

As for women's hockey, Katy explains that North America's dominance in this year's games has led many to debate if women's hockey should remain a sport, as it has been since 1998. When the US and Canada swiftly crushed the competition, the media reacted oddly:

Hockey writers are none too impressed by this display of dominance, with several writers calling it "unsportswomanlike." Kevin Amerman bemoaned the "embarrassing" win and told the Canadian time to "take it easy." "You won't see this behavior from the men," he argued.

Katy adds:

While no one is arguing that women's hockey is damaging to the ovaries (at least, not yet), the continued debate over whether two teams are too good rings with a similar patronizing tone. And North American teams may be kicking ass, but part of the reason that they are able to do so comes from what CNN calls a "chauvinistic lack of funding" for women's hockey players abroad.

We thought we'd ask Intern Emily what she thinks of all this -- Emily is 19 and lives in Montreal, Canada, where she played hockey for fourteen years (this is her first year not playing), most recently on Dawson College's Junior National Championship team (this is the highest level you can get to below the NWHL or Division I university).

Here's what she had to say:

Ever since Women's Hockey debuted in the Olympics in '98, it's become way more popular and honestly, the Olympics is the only time you hear about women's hockey. Did you know that there is a National Women's Hockey League? I bet you didn't. Men get paid millions of dollars to play not only in a national league, but also in other European countries with different leagues (though they get paid less abroad). Women, on the other hand, have to pay to play in the league and also keep steady jobs.

It's true that Canada and the US are way ahead of other countries in terms of talent. Obviously both countries have the money & means to support player development at a young age, but that doesn't mean that other countries aren't getting there.

Pulling Women's Hockey from the Olympics would be going backwards. Making the Olympic Team is any women's hockey player's dream -- because that's the highest you can go. While men aim for the NHL, women train with the Olympic goal in mind. For men, the Olympics is secondary to winning the Stanley Cup (not to say that the men don't care about representing their country --they do -- but the Canadian team has been centralized and training together for over a year specifically for the Olympics  (also recruiting people since like the age of 12) whereas men have been training for the NHL season.)

A good example of this is the men's game last night between Canada and the US. It's disappointing for Canadians that the men lost, but theres' a sense that it's not over because almost everyone on both teams will return to the NHL and try for the Stanley Cup (also, because there are still finals). If that had been the Women's Game (and it likely will be in the final), it would have been DEVASTATING.

There is NOTHING for women after the Olympics except the next Olympics. There's of course the NWHL and University teams, but that hardly compares to competing at the National Level in front of thousands of people.

Men in the NHL compete in front of thousands of people every night -- women in the NHWL compete in front of five fans if they're lucky.

Pulling Women's Hockey from the Olympics would be like giving up. It's like "Oh, our world is so unequal, let's just leave it that way."

WOMEN OF HOCKEY:
Although they use the word "podcast" how Alice did in Season Five of The L Word -- VLOG! VLOG IT'S A VLOG! -- here's a sweet video about the Women of Hockey:

CRY COUNT:
Also, skaters of all genders cry a lot, says The New York Times. (@nytimes)

TRANS:
Dr. Oz features transgender children who's "sex on the outside" doesn't match their "sex on the inside." This has been lauded as a sensitive and respectful portrayl by trans advocates. Check it out:

MONEY HONEY:
In honor of tax season, The New York Times is doing a series with tax experts answering you questions on specialized areas of tax finance. In their second installment, they're looking at same-sex couples and the unique issues they face. If you have questions for Tina Salandra, a certified public accountant who specializes in tax planning for gay and lesbian couples, ask her! (@nytimes)

SKIRTS:
Schools in the UK may no longer be able to force girls to wear skirts because uniforms discriminate against transsexuals -- "requiring pupils to wear gender-specific clothes is potentially unlawful." (@timesonline)

BAKERY:
The copy reads -  "Butch it up Buttercup, These ain't your grandma's cupcakes. Our objective is simple. We're men. Men who like cupcakes. Not the frilly pink frosted sprinkles and unicorns kind of cupcakes. We make manly cupcakes. For manly men."

Feminsting reacts - "With that kind of name (and located in NYC) I half expected it to be a super gay bakery catering to Butch lesbians and gay men. I guessed wrong."

30 responses to “How Cutting Olympic Women's Ice Hockey Would Destroy Hope, Dreams, Equality”

  1. Все о фильмах » Архив сайта » Женщины – The Women DVD

    [...] How Cutting Olympic Women's Ice Hockey Would Destroy Hope, Dreams … [...]

    Thumb up 0
  2. AL

    US women’s soccer dominated on the world scene for years before other countries started to catch up. Hockey will be the same way, and since (I assume) unlike soccer, the Olympics are the only big international competition, pulling it would be devastating.

    Thumb up 0
  3. marya

    Emily, I agree with all of this.
    I’m making it a point to watch all of the women’s games on tv, because every little bit counts.
    ps: we just got a goal. :) yay Canada!

    Thumb up 0
  4. Lynne

    Getting rid of women’s hockey would be LAME. Just like when they got rid of Softball for the summer olympics & I died a little on the inside. Emily is right, women don’t have the same professional opportunities in sports so the Olympics are what these girls are working their whole lives towards. And saying that certain teams are too dominant is a bullshit excuse, serious athletes are always gonna want to play at the highest level. Ew the sports world is lopsided and focused on men, it hurts my head.

    Thumb up 0
    1. wcollins2332

      I died too. Dream killing right there as a softball player for 15 years.

      Thumb up 0
      1. gena.

        same, it crushed my soul. i have not recovered.

        and my little brother hasn’t either, which is so sad/cute. he’s a softball umpire, and moved up the ranks quite quickly (he was the youngest level III in Canada when he got the certification, which is totally a big deal and yes i am super proud!), all with the dream of making it to the Olympics as an official one day. It was a super cute dream. He was probably sadder and more crushed about the decision than any other 18 year old boy on the planet.

        Thumb up 0
        1. wcollins2332

          Haha, I never made it past level 1. So good for him :)

          Thumb up 0
  5. Sam

    i like sports some more than others but getting rid of women’s hockey would be lame ass.

    Thumb up 0
  6. roxy

    and North America doesn’t always dominate women’s hockey. granted it was an upset, Sweden won silver in Torino ’06! Gah!!

    Thumb up 0
    1. raptor

      heja sverige!

      but also I mean, even if north american countries are dominating now it takes time for things to even out too, thats not a reason to kill it off. they’re just being lazy and sexist.

      Thumb up 0
  7. Morgan

    Take away women’s hockey?
    Over my dead body.

    For fuck’s sake, TRAMPOLINE is an olympic sport.

    Thumb up 0
    1. Dina

      Dude, have you seen what those trampoliners do? They’re badass.

      Thumb up 0
  8. Laura

    i was looking up olympic events because i didn’t believe that trampoline was really an event and saw “modern pentathlon” and thought it said “modern penetration.”

    but it would be ridiculous and sad if they really did try to get rid of women’s hockey. the olympics needs their own little title ix.

    Thumb up 0
    1. Lynne

      It’d be more helpful if they got a Title IX that actually got enforced! haha

      Thumb up 0
  9. Elise

    “Schools in the UK may no longer be able to force girls to wear skirts because uniforms discriminate against transsexuals.”

    But can they force boys to wear pants? Kind of odd how the article treats gender nonconformity like a one-way street.

    Thumb up 0
    1. KZ

      Boys in skirts are kinda sexy.
      Is that weird?

      Boys could have kilts!

      Thumb up 0
  10. Ziggy Hreins

    For some odd reason the U.S. female hockey team was the only thing i followed in the olympics. Hilary Knight is awesome by the way.

    Thumb up 0
  11. gena.

    Hey Emily, it is so cool that you played that level of hockey! Way to be like really Canadian.

    So if they remove women’s hockey from the olympics b/c the American/Canadian teams dominate will they next remove the Americans from the olympics because they dominate like the whole entire olympics? Or would that not be how sport/competition works?

    Really though, if this were an issue with a men’s sport these arguments would not be being made, obviously. Team USA dominates men’s basketball at the summer olympics and no one has considered cancelling that competition.

    Also, Tegan Quin’s twitter updates about the canadian women’s hockey team are so cute.

    Thumb up 0
  12. dot

    Whoa, the Canadian team juggles (or does something with juggling balls) before games? I wanna see!

    Thumb up 0
  13. DemiArianna

    These cupcakes remind me of that pants ad we were talking about. The MANifesto crap.

    Thumb up 0
  14. Same BS

    I’m getting sick and tired of people wanting to throw women’s sports out because of the lack depth. Go back and look at the scores from the 30s,40s,50,60s men’s hockey games. It’s not pretty. Canada just throttled teams.

    It’s going to take time to develope players and the IIHF and IOC need to put pressure on countries who are dragging their feet. There is also a certain amount of bitching going on about women’s bobsleigh even though it’s only been and Olympic event for two Olympics. The biggest reason ski jumping didn’t get in was because the federations do not want to share funding.

    People who look down their nose at women’s hockey are the same people who if they had their way the only sport women would be participating in would be figure skating. It has all the elements their type love: half naked young girls and and men who present them.

    On another note what is it with referring to the women’s events as “ladies” this or that?? CTV is constantly referring to ALL women’s events{except hockey} as “ladies”.

    Thumb up 0
  15. kaleemdecent

    LIVE ICE HOCKEY STREAMING THIS LINK http://www.nj43.com/live_tv_channels.asp?mid=70&sid=30

    Thumb up 0
  16. yodelmachine

    “hey women who play ice hockey. you are too talented, so you don’t get to play anymore.” how does this make sense. how.

    Thumb up 0

Leave a Reply

Site Meter