Six Couples Sue For Right to Marry In Florida, Joining Dozens of Lawsuits for Marriage Equality

On Tuesday morning, six same sex couples and LGBT civil rights group Equality Florida filed a lawsuit in pursuit of marriage equality in the Sunshine State. The case is filed against Miami-Dade County Clerk of the Circuit Court – where Florida’s marriage licenses are processed – and argues that the state’s laws barring same-sex couples from marriage are a violation of federal constitutional rights.

The lawsuit is the latest in a string of state-level battles that have sprung up post-DOMA, including recent successes in Oklahoma, Illinois, New Jersey, Utah and New Mexico.

Elizabeth F.Schwartz, one of the attorneys representing the plaintiffs, commented in a phone interview, “With over 40 lawsuits pending on statewide bans in other states, it was time. We needed to get into the fray with this issue. We have thousands of same-sex couples, from Key West to the Panhandle, and they’re sick of waiting.”

Plaintiff couples: Don Johnston and Jorge Diaz; Jeff and Todd Delmay; Dr. Juan Carlos Rodriguez and David Price; Vanessa and Melanie Alenier; Summer Greene and Pamela Faerber. Cathy Pareto and Karla Arguello are not pictured.

Plaintiff couples, left to right: Don Johnston and Jorge Diaz; Jeff and Todd Delmay; Dr. Juan Carlos Rodriguez and David Price; Vanessa and Melanie Alenier; Summer Greene and Pamela Faerber. Cathy Pareto and Karla Arguello are not pictured.

While all six couples on the lawsuit reside in South Florida, the group has deliberate range in age, gender, and race. Four of the couples are raising children, and another couple have an adult child and two grandchildren. With the case being tried in Miami-Dade County, Schwartz explained, Equality Florida felt it was particularly important to select plaintiffs who would represent the diversity of the area’s LGBT community.

“We have a tremendous immigrant population that knows what it’s like to be discriminated against, and knows what it’s like to be judged unreasonably,” said Schwartz. Accordingly, “Florida has always been at the forefront of social change in the South. If you look at the history of the civil rights movement, Florida was leading us out of segregation before it was much of a hope in the other southern states.” Because of the history and diverse population, many consider Florida a key state in taking the temperature of the United States.

Couples at the Equality Florida press conference, January 21, 2014.

Couples at the Equality Florida press conference, January 21, 2014. Cathy Pareto andKarla Arguello; Jeff and Todd Delmay; Melanie and Vanessa Alenier. Via Equality Florida Facebook.

At the Equality Florida press conference on Tuesday, plaintiffs shared their motivations for wanting to join the suit. Summer Greene told how her family tolerated discrimination for decades. Todd Delmay related how he and his partner Jeff created a new last name together. And Cathy Pareto explained how even though she and her partner of 14 years, Karla Arguello, have merged their finances and families and raise a son together, they are legal strangers in the eyes of the state:

According to a March 2013 survey by Public Policy Polling, 75% of Floridians support legal recognition of couples in Florida, in the form of either same-sex marriage or civil unions. This is higher than the July 2013 Gallup reported national average of 52% of Americans who say they would cast their vote in favor of a federal law legalizing same-sex marriage in all 50 states. (A slightly different question, but the numbers are in line with other polls conducted last summer on national support for same-sex marriage.)

While it’s too early to say whether the Florida case will be decided at the state level or move federally, Schwartz is optimistic and expects that they will receive a fair hearing. “We think that the law has sufficiently moved forward,” said Schwartz. “Whatever comes next, we’re ready.”

Profile photo of Laura Mandanas

Laura Mandanas is a Filipina American living in Brooklyn. By day, she works as an industrial engineer. By night, she is beautiful and terrible as the morn, treacherous as the seas, stronger than the foundations of the Earth. All shall love her and despair.

Laura has written 76 articles for us.

1 Comment

  1. Thumb up 4

    Please log in to vote

    Through out the internet, the argument has been pitched that Florida could be the first southern state for marriage equality, and it would be a beautiful day if that prediction won out despite Rubio’s stance on gay marriage.

Contribute to the conversation...

You must be logged in to post a comment.