Pretty Little Liars Recap 409: Into the Dyke Birthday Party

Welcome back to Pretty Little Liars, a one hour excuse for me to eat Annie’s macaroni and cheese and email with Intern Grace.

Last week Mona gayed out for Hanna by confessing to Wilden’s murder. Other than that it was pretty effing boring. Actually the last four episodes have been snoozeville without any Paige action. This week, thank goddess, Paige is finally back and she’s throwing a surprise birthday party for Emily! A high stress night where every teenager in Rosewood attends? What could possibly go wrong?!


We open on the Rosewood police department where Mona is being interrogated for consistently dressing like a middle-aged country clubber who just killed her much older husband. Just kidding, we all know she’s being interrogated for confessing to Wilden’s murder. I have no clue if Mona is innocent or guilty, but at least she’s giving the police a good show.

He didn't understand me like you do!

He didn’t understand me like you do!

Mona explains that she heard Wilden say he was nervous Garret would tell the truth about The Night Alison Saw Everyone And Did Everything And Died (Maybe). She tells the police she didn’t go to them because she thought she would get in trouble for sneaking out of Radley.

Go get my progeny Hanna and bring her to me.

Go get Hanna and bring her to me.

That’s right. Even if everything else is bullshit Mona owned up to at least one lie. For this reason I’d better just list this out as Shit Mona Confessed to the Police because otherwise we’ll never get through Mona’s confession and onto the Gay Stuff. And there really is gay stuff this episode. 

Shit Mona Confessed to the Police:

1. Mona shot Wilden two times in self defense
2. Wilden killed Garret
3. Wilden was trying to pin Alison’s murder on the Liars
4. Mona tried to blackmail Wilden
5. Mona confessed to keep Ashley out of prison

Of course, the police officer never asks what happened to Ali that Mona might know about. Who knows? Maybe Mona would have said that she and Ali were secretly carrying on a torrid vampire love affair.

And she had the softest lips I've ever tasted.

And she had the softest lips I’ve ever tasted.

Across town, Hanna and Spencer lie around amongst cardboard boxes and Pottery Barn couches waiting for news.

Life is so hard.

Oh to be young, pretty and have unlimited access to a Restoration Hardware

Laywer Mistress Hastings comes in and announces that some of what Mona has been saying contradicts the evidence and therefore everyone thinks she’s full of shit. Good thing none of the girls were involved in this. Oh wait. Of course Hanna was.

Oh you've got to be kidding me. Four seasons and this shit is still going on?

Oh you’ve got to be kidding me. Four seasons and this shit is still going on?

Spencer calls Aria to fill her in on the new details. To exactly no one’s surprise Sensei Hot Stuff stayed the night. Of course, he stayed on the couch because you wouldn’t want to upset the Ezaria fans. Or the Religious Right.

I'm not sure about our relationship, but I think if I play my cards right I'll be able get a dick pic.

Hold on a second. I just need to open the camera app. I think I can get a dick pic.

Aria tries to tell Sensei to GTFO but he just wants to get brunch and stare longingly into each other’s eyes and maybe adopt a cat or two. Oh god, another lesbian. Except this one is a lesbian chimp.

Can we name our cat banana? I love bananas.

Can we name our cat banana? I love bananas.

Elsewhere, Emily and Paige finally give their relationship a little TLC and, more importantly, a little screen time. Paige thinks Mona totally killed Wilden because Paige has that tendency to hop on whatever A of the week is most obviously just a misdirection.

Maybe Spider Man killed Jenny. Did you ever think of that? No. No one ever thinks of that.

Maybe Spider Man killed Jenny. Did you ever think of that? No. No one ever thinks of that.

Also Paige wants to plan Emily a birthday party! Did you know time passes on this show? Girls actually get older and have birthdays and everything! This is indeed a rare occasion!

WITH ANAL.

WITH MY HITACHI MAGIC WAND!

Page also got Emily a classic lesbian birthday gift: something weird, overbearing, moderately invasive and borderline critical.

Is this a new set of kegal balls?

Is this a new set of kegal balls?

No it’s not an entirely new wardrobe, it’s a consulting session with one of the best swim trainers in the world. You know, even though Emily can’t really swim anymore.

This gift if like our love. If you don't appreciate it then you probably don't appreciate me.

This gift if like our love. If you don’t appreciate it then you probably don’t appreciate me.

C’mon Paige, you can do better than that. Would an overly sentimental and engraved promise ring have been too hard?

If you don't like it I'll totally return it. And then kill myself.

If you don’t like it I’ll totally return it. And then kill myself.

Paige wants Emily to take a year off to rehab and train so she can actually go to a college she wants to on a swim scholarship. It’s actually a pretty solid plan until Paige inserts herself into the plan. Ah, I see now, Paige wants Emily to follow her to the San Francisco Gay Area to frolic in the sunlight forever. Classic lesbian pre-college move.

And then we can scissor off into the sunset.

And then we can scissor off into the sunset.

Over at The Life Cafe, Sensei Hot Stuff orders Aria a large triple shot extra-hot half-caf soy mocha with whipped cream. It’s probably delicious. Unfortunately, Aria can’t focus on Sensei or her  large triple shot extra-hot half-caf soy mocha with whipped cream  because all she can do is stare at Maggie Mac and Ezra chatting in the corner.

Girl in the back left is totally hungover. She understands me.

Girl in the back left is totally hungover. She understands me.

Someone needs to put another coffee shop in this town, clearly everyone in Rosewood drinks coffee all the time. Ezra, of course, can’t focus on Maggie Mac telling him that she got accepted into grad school. All he can do is stare daggers at Sensei and plot his revenge.

The only thing ruder would be taking out his cell phone to play candy crusher

Oh man that large triple shot extra-hot half-caf soy mocha with whipped cream looks so fucking good.

Of course, he just about does a spit take when Maggie Mac tells him the grad program is at Wash U. Looks like she’s taking Malcolm across the country. She also got a new haircut but that doesn’t come up. This show is officially unrealistic.

I never should have worn this butt plug in public.

I never should have worn this butt plug in public.

Over at Rosewood Federal Correctional Facility, Ashley, Hanna and Mistress Layer Hastings hash out the recent events. Looks like Mona’s confession created enough doubt in the judge’s mind that they’ve set bail for Ashley to come home! Hooray! Unfortunately, they haven’t dropped the charges. Plus bail is set at ONE MILLION DOLLARS.

Would I get to continue rooming with Alex Vause?

Would I get to continue rooming with Alex Vause?

FYI I realized I didn’t know what bail actually was, so I looked it up. It’s like a deposit you give to the prosecutors so they know you will show up to trial. But usually you don’t have to pay all of it. Also, a million dollars is pretty typical for murder.

I'm typical?!

I’m typical?!

Starsweep across town to the most modern/ art deco olympic swimming training center of all time conveniently located in Rosewood, Pennsylvania.  Emily meets with Mr. Super Trainer at his super fly facility. There are girls in swimsuits mulling about and even though I disagree with the sexualization of women when their bodies are exposed for non-sexual reasons such as athletic competition: hawt.

You like the bodies on the girls in here?

You like the bodies on the girls in here?

Mr. Super Trainer: Let me tell you a little about how I run things. We work out six days per week. Four hours in the pool, one hour of weight training. I also monitor what you eat, drink and how much you sleep. Have I scared you yet?

I’m not scared but I feel like I could use this guy in my life. I sleep like 4 hours per night, I haven’t worked out in a year and I just ate a grape off the floor. Although I am generally creeped out by the overzealous man coaching teen girls trope.

If this is going to turn into something weird then I'm getting the fuck out of this story line.

If this is going to turn into something weird then I’m getting the fuck out of this story line.


Starsweep to the neighborhood hiking grounds where Hanna takes an oddly located phone call with her father. She wants him to put up 10% of the ONE MILLION DOLLARS of her mother’s bail. That would be like $100,000 or like two years of med school! Based on Hanna’s crying her father just doesn’t want to front money.

But if I don't have the money how the hell am I going to be a doctor?!

But if I don’t have the money how the hell am I going to be a doctor?!

Hanna is approached by exactly who you would want to see when crying about your imprisoned mother: her boyfriend/pastor, Ted! Pastor Ted explains that he left messages and can’t figure out why the hell Ashley didn’t call him back. I mean, he knows she’s in prison but still, that’s just rude.

You look like you could use a dose of softball for god.

You look like you could use a dose of softball for god.

Actually he’s really worried about Hanna and Ashley and says the kind of nice things that people say when they’re generally good people who are also involved in organized religion.

It's call "The Patriarchy" and I run it.

It’s call “The Patriarchy” and I run it.

Hanna tells Pastor Ted that Caleb is selling his car to help raise money, because Caleb’s whole world is Hanna, but it won’t be nearly enough money! Maybe they should have a bake sale. Or a kissing booth. That’s what they always do on Glee.

THE AUTOSTRADDLE STORY

THE AUTOSTRADDLE STORY

Over at Ezra’s Love Studio he and Maggie Mac discuss her upcoming visit to Oregon. She needs to find an apartment and such. Ezra volunteers to take Malcolm. First for the weekend and then… for forever. You see he saw this show called The Fosters and learned all about good parenting. He figures he should be fine.

What's the worst that could happen? It's not like I could sleep with ANOTHER sixteen year old!

What’s the worst that could happen? It’s not like I could sleep with ANOTHER sixteen year old!

Maggie Mac basically says no fucking way bro, back the fuck off my kid.

This is a Mom Face.

This is a Mom Face.

Starsweep to Rosewood High where Spencer and Aria stalk the halls preying on unsuspecting young girls, luring them in to the lesbian lifestyle with their sweet kisses and– wait. I think that was my dream last night. Actually they’re just discussing how Mona is so totally out to screw them over in the long run.

Oh right, like you've never been to third base with a girl.

Oh right, like you’ve never been to third base with a girl.

Spencer: When has Mona ever done something out of the goodness of her heart?

Aria pulls out of her locker a picture of Emily and Paige. She just keeps a copy in there, you know, for private moments.

The Gaybies Of Rosewood Swimsuit Calendar

The Gaybies Of Rosewood Swimsuit Calendar

This time, though, Aria has a framed copy that she’s going to give to Emily for her birthday at Emily’s upcoming super double extra secret birthday party thrown by one Miss Paige McCullers.

And next you'll be telling me that Miley Cyrus is just a straight ally.

And next you’ll be telling me that Miley Cyrus is just a straight ally.

The two turn the corner and see the one and only Jenna Marshall gaying out with Shana lezzie style in the courtyard.

Rosewood. Every corner you turn around there's another set of high school lesbians doing it.

Rosewood. Every corner you turn around there’s another set of high school lesbians doing it.

Between hand holdings, promising to be together forever, and discussing in vitro options, the two also mention that Jenna feels like she should have “told the police about Ali.” Shana’s like, “But why?! Lying is working so well!” She’s wrong.

I can't do fisting! It's just too many fingers!

I can’t do fisting! It’s just too many fingers!

Starsweep to the Marin household where to trumpet flares Ashley returns home looking as glowing as the day she was born. Prison was good to her.

When you're a middle class white lady it's just like an enforced diet!

When you’re a middle class white lady it’s just like an enforced diet!

Ashley also has a great new accessory: an ankle monitor! Womp womp.

An-kle. By Gucci.

An-kle. By Gucci.

Do you know about this shoe Orange is the New Black? Girls do all sort of crazy things together in prison.

Do you know about this show Orange is the New Black? Girls do all sort of crazy things together in prison.

And I liked it!

And I liked it!

Back over at the Mega Gym, Emily and Mr. Super Trainer watch her recruitment video. Mr. Super Trainer is unimpressed. Emily might think she’s hot shit but he says she’s nothing but cold potato unless she starts training ASAP.

You may have been the hottest dyke in town in Rosewood but at Mount Holyoke you'll be just another fish in the pond.

You may have been the hottest dyke in town in Rosewood but at Smith you’ll be just another fish in the pond.

What about Bryn Mawr? or Smith? There too?

What about Bryn Mawr? Or Vassar? There too?

You may have been the hottest dyke in town in Rosewood but at Mount Holyoke you'll be just another fish in the pond.

Even at Mount Holyoke.

Emily points out she has to let her shoulder heal. Looks like Paige didn’t tell Mr. Super Trainer that part. He’s basically like, “Move the fuck on with your life because you are not going to be a champion swimmer by next year.”

I thought I had more time...

I thought I had more time…

Emily’s dreams are basically dashed. It’s sad.

THIS SAD.

THIS SAD.


Teleport across town to Paige’s aunt’s lake house, where Aria and Spencer are in new outfits but having the same conversation. Blah blah blah Jenna, blah blah blah why is she so fishy blah blah blah shiny hair. Also TobAy is in New York tracking down some apartment which turns out to have a PO Box that redirects to Philly. I have no idea what they’re talking about which means this show is officially too confusing. Also isn’t this exact same story line happening on Twisted?

Can you follow this shit?

Can you follow this shit?

Paige shows up and is all frazzled that the Liars aren’t doing more to prep for Emily’s Surprise Super Sweet Eighteen.

Do you guys like this outfit? Lizz told me it was Lesbian Birthday Chic on this website Autostraddle Dot Com.

Do you guys like this outfit? Lizz told me it was Lesbian Birthday Chic on this website Autostraddle Dot Com.

Side note. When I was in high school this really cool popular gay guy in my class held a birthday party at the rollerskating rink for his 18th birthday and filmed it to cut together into a YouTube video. He called it his Super Sweet Skateen. I think that’s what Paige should have done for Emily. If she really cared about her at all.

Super Sweet Skateen. Fuck. Why didn't I think of that?

Super Sweet Skateen. Fuck. Why didn’t I think of that?

Paige is in a pre-party panic that is so adorable I wish I could bottle it and use it as a perfume to attract girls at Dyke Night. To make matters worse, Spencer and Aria want Paige to invite Shana in hopes that she’ll drag Jenna along. Everyone wants a word with Jenna.

Well I guess we'll just have to go back to my original theme of Cake And Fingerblasting.

Well I guess we’ll just have to go back to my original theme of Cats And Fingerblasting.

While Spencer plans her Jenna conversation, her mother has a very different conversation. Ezra has stopped by to ask for legal advice about Malcolm and Maggie Mac. No one explains how the hell Ezra knows Mistress Lawyer Hastings. Aren’t there other lawyers in town? It makes no sense — he’s just Spencer’s English teacher.

**Speaks in Parseltongue**

**Speaks in Parseltongue**

Unfortunately Mistress Lawyer Hastings says that Ezra doesn’t have much of a chance. He’s not on Malcolm’s birth certificate and he hasn’t been present in Malcolm’s life.

Other lawyers you say? In the city of Rosewood? Here?

Other lawyers you say? In the city of Rosewood? Here?

Back over at The Party, the house is filling up with rambunctious teens. Emily’s high school must be a lot like mine because it looks like she just got even more popular when she came out. Who are all these kids? Did Pam approve them!?

Vag Bash 2013

Vag Bash 2013

Everyone goes to hide, in preparation for Emily’s arrival, when Aria spots Sensei Hot Stuff with a cute blonde girl. I wish she had made a scene but instead she just hides and turns off the lights.

In which Aria preps for her new sexploitation film where she plays a sexy ninja

In which Aria preps for her new sexploitation film where she plays a sexy ninja

Emily walks in and is clearly pissed at Paige for not telling Mr. Super Trainer about her torn rotator cuff. She gives the best pissed-off-at-your-partner face ever.

Who's ready for fingerbanging!?!?!?!!!

Who’s ready for fingerbanging!?!?!?!!!

Don't Piss Off Your Girlfriend.

Not Emily.

Then everyone yells surprise.

And we all practiced Jazz Hands!

And we all practiced Jazz Hands!

Emily is not thrilled.

Cake and Fingerblasting themed again?!

Cats and Fingerblasting themed again?!

Pages: 1 2 See entire article on one page

Avatar of Lizz

Lizz is a consumer, lover and writer of all things pop culture and the Fashion/Style Editor at Autostraddle.com. She is also full time medical student at Brown University in Providence, RI. You can find her on the twitter, the tumblr or even on the instagram.

Lizz has written 272 articles for us.

9 Comments

  1. Thumb up 3

    Please log in to vote

    I don’t even care about Aria but this made me laugh so much: “How dare he arrive with another girl after Aria made it perfectly clear that she has no interest in him.”

    Also, I think Emily meant physically in the same place together at Stanford, not we won’t finger bang Be Together together.

    Thirdly, Lindsey Shaw, go away with your crying face, I can’t handle it.

  2. Thumb up 2

    Please log in to vote

    i can’t believe it wasn’t a ring. i wanted to see paige on her bended knees giving emily a commitment speech.
    i also can’t believe that they slept on the same bed and nothing happened. nothing happened. no spooning! no nothing! they didn’t even kiss! i cried for this episode because it was very emotional and there was no birthday sex. devastating.

  3. Thumb up 3

    Please log in to vote

    We know the hoe down is coming up and from the pics Paige is so hot she makes the surface of the Sun seem cool! So don’t despair yet. From all the signs I’ve seen Paily isn’t going anywhere they just have to work through this.

    I am still waiting for Paily sexytimes to be put ON SCREEN. It’s getting so old. -_-

  4. Thumb up 2

    Please log in to vote

    I haven’t watched a single episode of this show in more than a season and I still read the recaps religiously because they are just so PERFECT.

    It’s amazing how much better a show gets once you decide to treat all the characters as lesbians.

Contribute to the conversation...

You must be logged in to post a comment.