WE'RE AT CAMP! Read all about it
The World's Most Popular Independently-Owned Website for Lesbian, Bisexual and Queer Women
Leave a Comment

//

20 Comments

Chinese Marriage Markets for Gays: Better Than Clubs, Not Much Else

Carmen

Posted by

The Chinese are putting the "convenient" back into "marriage of convenience."

Slate recently published an article that gave us an inside glimpse into the workings of a monthly "Marriage Market" meeting in Shanghai, and into the context of why the market exists. The big surprise of the article is that a new generation of gay- and lesbian-identified people are coming together in China. The not-so-big-a-surprise is that it's kind of awkward being gay in China.

It is estimated that somewhere between 30 to 40 million gay people live in China - but there has never been an official count. Gay people in China face so much pressure to be straight that it is estimated that 80 percent of them are married to straight people. Some people there may not even know what "gay" is, since pages containing "LGBT" online are conspicuously "not found."The pressure to be straight in China is high because of the culture's incredible focus on family and on heirs. It is expected that children in China will marry without exception, and grow up to bear families of their own.

Photo via weddingsinasia.com

In order to provide gay and lesbian people with a new option, China's largest gay website began holding marriage markets once a month, beginning about six months ago. The meetings provide a space for gay and lesbian people to find partners for marriage and family-rearing - but their partner will also be a gay or lesbian person. (Do you get this? They will marry someone of the opposite sex but they will still be able to be gay! Everyone wins! Kind of.) At the meetings, they speak out about what they are looking for  in hopes of finding other queer folk with the same desire - and in hopes of marrying one of them. An excerpted quotes from the meeting covered by Slate:

"I'm here to find a lesbian, to be with me and to build a home," No. 11 says to the crowd clustered on floor cushions at a sunlit yoga studio in Shanghai. No. 11 is a muscular man in a flannel shirt and cargo pants, and he easily commands the attention of the crowd of 40 or so young men and women who are gingerly sipping glasses of wine and whispering to their neighbors.

"In my view, a 30-year-old man should start thinking about having a family, but two men can't hold each other's hands in the street. We're not allowed to be a family," he says. The crowd nods.

This is a new alternative, and the people who participate in the marketplace think of themselves as members of a "transitional" generation. Whereas older generations of gay and lesbian people in Shanghai got their gay on in underground clubs and remained in committed relationships with straight people, the participants in the marketplace are looking to create families and homes where their partner, and even their children, know who they really are. And thank goodness: it is estimated that 16 to 25 million women in China are actually homowives - straight women married to gay men. (Most stay with their partners to avoid shame or maintain their family structure.)

The situation for gay people in China may not be perfect - far from it - but the marriage marketplace is creating a new culture where gay- and lesbian-identified people can be (a) comfortable with themselves in their homes and lives, (b) create a community for themselves that will lead to more education and awareness, and (c) shift the heteronormative culture in China.

Not perfect, but not bad.

20 responses to “Chinese Marriage Markets for Gays: Better Than Clubs, Not Much Else”

  1. allie

    but if all teh gays make babies with each other they are all gonna turn out gay! thats how it works!

    /sarcasm

    Thumb up 0
    1. Amanda

      Duh! And teh straights make straight babies, right?

      Thumb up 0
  2. calanthe

    When I was reading this, I found it kind of comforting? While obviously not ideal, these marriages can often provide a space where there is stability, support and friendship in a place where people aren’t really free to express themselves safely.

    Thumb up 0
  3. Claire

    Anyone else think of Johnny Weir, talking about how he would marry a woman, even though he’s gay?

    Thumb up 0
    1. Aaa

      That came to mind for me, too.

      Thumb up 0
  4. Emily

    according to america , according to the ministry of health, there approximately 30 million homosexuals between the ages of 15 and 60 (what happened to the between younger and older than that, i have no idea) and more than 80% of gay men married because of social pressure. you can find it in that giant report by ctrl F and searching “gay”, just to back up what carmen said.

    i did a research paper last semester on gays in china, and it’s really interesting how queer politics differ so vastly over there compared to in the west.

    Thumb up 0
  5. diver

    go Chinese gays

    Thumb up 0
  6. yorke

    How exactly does it shift heteronormative culture in China? It’s gay people still complying with heteronormative expectations and roles.

    Thumb up 0
  7. engineRoom

    Sometimes I feel like there are no gay asians. Although I live in Australia, the community I grew up and currently live in is largely made up of Chinese/Vietnamese people and even though I’m not ashamed to be gay, I feel like I can never come out because of the shame I would bring upon my family from the community and extended family. Everyone is so connected and in everyone’s business.

    I feel this doesn’t really have that much to do with the article but I needed to get it out.

    And thank you for the article

    Thumb up 0
    1. mon

      heyoo you are not alone, and it’s true all asians in australia are connected, news spreads fast

      Thumb up 0
    2. Tiara the Merch Girl

      Hello from another queer Asian in Australia! I personally find that most of my trouble is due to people not recognising me as queer – I get read as Foreign first and foremost. I’m a migrant and I don’t live amongst my cultural community so I don’t really have that to go back to.

      Thumb up 0
  8. Mao Ze Wrong
  9. tiger

    on valentine’s day i was in china queerspotting with my cousin.

    i was bemoaning the lack of queer couples about, and she shrugged and said, ‘don’t worry about it, a lot of the couples you see here are just for show anyway.’

    Thumb up 0
  10. catfish

    My family hosted 13 year old Chinese exchange students, and it was the best thing. One of them was this really extremely gay-seeming girl, all decked out in her board shorts with a non-gendered American name and alternative lifestyle haircut. She’s the only one of the 4 Chinese middle school students who lived with us that summer that we have any expectation of seeing again- she says she gets up at 6am to study English because she wants to go to Berkeley for college. She is awesome.

    It’s one thing to read about how much worse it is to be gay in other countries. It’s really different to have a real person who went to the mall with you and slept in your extra room’s face on it, you know? I want China to be okay, but I really just want my “Chinese sister” to come back where she won’t have to marry for anyone but herself.

    Thumb up 0
  11. longfeifengwu

    Cheerful news! I’m living in Beijing at the moment & there is some incredible LGBT progress being made, the scene is really buzzing and seeing how far China has come in the past 10 years in terms of public opinion and awareness surrounding LGBT issues makes me certain that the pace of change will accelerate the process of achieving equal gay rights and recognition. Maybe it’s just because i’m looking, but I seem to find lesbians EVERYWHERE in Beijing- in the shoe shop, waitressing in straight clubs, on the subway- those magic words “我没有男朋友,我是拉拉” “I don’t have a boyfriend, i’m a lala (lesbian)” keep popping up

    An issue specific to China is, of course, the pressures of the 1 child policy to produce the perfect children who get degrees, good jobs and produce their own perfect little child. From this perspective it’s easy to see how many Chinese lesbians and gay men choose to marry, rather than face family pressure. But, again this is something which is changing as more and more straight couples are choosing not to have children for financial reasons, or women are choosing not to get married for their careers, or men living in the countryside cannot find wives due to the gender imbalance. So, while the pressure to procreate may not diminish, at least there other people living “alternative” lifestyles to share to collective burden of family disappointment..

    An interesting aspect of the lesbian scene in China is the division between T & P, or butch (Tomboi) & femme (Po (=wife))- when going to Beijing’s most popular Chinese-speaking lesbian bar you have to sign your name and whether you are T or P before you can enter the bar. It almost feels like a parody- the cute, butch T’s literally have arm wrestling and press up competitions and drink beer while the P’s giggle in a corner and reapply lipstick. A little oversimplified but nonetheless it’s a lot more visually divided than i’ve seen in other countries. Although this is evolving too towards another identity- 不分 “not split”, which is a happy medium of futch (or bumme, as you like)

    Anyone who can read Chinese, check out http://www.lalabar.com for the lowdown on Beijing’s lesbian life. Oh and if you are having a bad day, this is bound to cheer you up- http://dgeneratefilms.com/wp-content/uploads/lesbian2.jpeg
    They’re a real couple who staged a fake wedding scene in one of Beijing’s most crowded areas to raise awareness on Valentines Day a couple of years ago.

    Also, Autostraddle isn’t blocked in China :)

    Thumb up 0

Leave a Reply

Site Meter